Forum › The Blue Star on That Day discussion

Avatar%20(pride%20version)
joined Oct 22, 2018

Series so good that reading the newest chapter of it ended the emotional self-harm episode I've been having for the last 18 hours

joined Dec 7, 2022

Someone please complete Umi's thought for me. Not exactly sure what she wanted to say.

"I know she loves me too. But even though I know that, sometimes..."

I guess she's going for "sometimes Shou is too physically distant"? Or "sometimes it doesn't feel like Shou lusts after me the way I'm lusting after her"? Lol

joined Mar 23, 2022

Damnnn everything starts with the sweet smoochie until that last panel. It's like Umi wants more assurance from Shou??

joined Mar 23, 2022

Never expected I will ended loving an extra chapter.<3. I just hope whatever Umi meant on that last panel, she will be able to communicate it with shou in the future.

Candy....
joined Dec 10, 2021

umi my poor baby with an anxious attachment style... This extra took place between volumes 5 and 6 meaning that whatever she's worried about still hasn't been addressed and has just been festering this whole time, im sure it's nothing :)

543633_50
joined Sep 10, 2022

Someone please complete Umi's thought for me. Not exactly sure what she wanted to say.

"I know she loves me too. But even though I know that, sometimes..."

I guess she's going for "sometimes Shou is too physically distant"? Or "sometimes it doesn't feel like Shou lusts after me the way I'm lusting after her"? Lol

She wants Shou to initiate; Shou then does this by asking to hold her hands. That's why we get the pause on Umi's face as an interruption of her thoughts. She's touched. So it ends happily. The "problem" is pretty much resolved there.

last edited at Oct 26, 2025 12:16PM

Subaru
joined Jul 31, 2019

Someone please complete Umi's thought for me. Not exactly sure what she wanted to say.

"I know she loves me too. But even though I know that, sometimes..."

I guess she's going for "sometimes Shou is too physically distant"? Or "sometimes it doesn't feel like Shou lusts after me the way I'm lusting after her"? Lol

I think at least part of it must also be the fact that at this point of the story they're technically "super friends" or whatever you want to call it, certainly adds at least a little bit to insecurity. Shou actually saying out loud that they're pretty much girlfriends already was only ch18.

last edited at Oct 26, 2025 11:21AM

1451751812512
joined Jul 23, 2014

Ahh such a cute chapter, I can face the workweek without issues now

Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

Lovely. ^_^

Img_20151224_170313
joined Feb 21, 2016

Hmm... I actually like this change (retcon?) establishing that there was more of a basis of physical intimacy to their relationship than we readers might have assumed... But I still just wish this extra was created closer to when it takes place chronologically. That's just because I'm really picky and "perceptible lack of a pre-planned plot" is my biggest fear when reading ongoing manga though lol.

ANYWAY this dovetails really nicely with the emerging arc from volume 7; my reading was that Shou is unnerved by her own feelings of desire that spark when they touch each other, not simply reacting to an unfamiliar situation. This extra giving Umi a little uncertainty on her side too suggests that the story could be heading towards the sort of strong emotional climax I would like, I hope!

joined Oct 15, 2019

Really cute side chapter. Thanks!

She wants Shou to initiate; Shou then does this by asking to hold her hands. That's why we get the pause on Umi's face as an interruption of her thoughts. She's touched. So it ends happily. The "problem" is pretty much resolved there.

This was how i read it as well.

last edited at Oct 26, 2025 12:38PM

joined Dec 7, 2022

Someone please complete Umi's thought for me. Not exactly sure what she wanted to say.

"I know she loves me too. But even though I know that, sometimes..."

I guess she's going for "sometimes Shou is too physically distant"? Or "sometimes it doesn't feel like Shou lusts after me the way I'm lusting after her"? Lol

She wants Shou to initiate; Shou then does this by asking to hold her hands. That's why we get the pause on Umi's face as an interruption of her thoughts. She's touched. So it ends happily. The "problem" is pretty much resolved there.

Love this explanation. Thanks!!

Dr%20soul
joined Oct 20, 2025

The thing I like most about this series is how realistic yet chill it is. Its cute and calming for the soul.

Img_0215
joined Jul 29, 2017

Someone please complete Umi's thought for me. Not exactly sure what she wanted to say.

"I know she loves me too. But even though I know that, sometimes..."

I guess she's going for "sometimes Shou is too physically distant"? Or "sometimes it doesn't feel like Shou lusts after me the way I'm lusting after her"? Lol

She wants Shou to initiate; Shou then does this by asking to hold her hands. That's why we get the pause on Umi's face as an interruption of her thoughts. She's touched. So it ends happily. The "problem" is pretty much resolved there.

Love this explanation. Thanks!!

Right, it's the contrasting match with the scene on page 4 when Shou pulls her hand away. Umi thinks it's about holding hands, but Shou is just self-conscious about the way her hand might smell. But on the way back Shou has gotten over that because of Umi's previous reaction.

Img_3750
joined Feb 3, 2021

Little bit delayed, but volume 8 has been released. This one isn’t free but it’s set at only 99 yen. https://x.com/aoikanidayo/status/2035529428340801714

Fb_img_1492462408743
joined Jan 18, 2014

Little bit delayed, but volume 8 has been released. This one isn’t free but it’s set at only 99 yen. https://x.com/aoikanidayo/status/2035529428340801714

Oh, i did saw on pixiv that the new vol. Came out but as the translator app on my phone became crap due an AI update, it was harder to understand the notes from the author.

So this means that the new Volume will not be submitted as is no longer technically free?

Img_3750
joined Feb 3, 2021

Little bit delayed, but volume 8 has been released. This one isn’t free but it’s set at only 99 yen. https://x.com/aoikanidayo/status/2035529428340801714

Oh, i did saw on pixiv that the new vol. Came out but as the translator app on my phone became crap due an AI update, it was harder to understand the notes from the author.

So this means that the new Volume will not be submitted as is no longer technically free?

No idea, that would be up to the scan group.

Hoshikuzu%20telepath%206%202
joined May 15, 2025

they're so cute

Old_Man_Majes
Old%20man%20prof
joined Oct 25, 2022

OMG, Umi's face when Shou gave her the chocolate was too good.

And dang, poor Ibu's got it bad. The series has made no secret of her having a crush on Umi, but this chapter is probably the most obvious its been.

joined Jan 14, 2020

Long chapter or Knight heron is spoiling us. Anyway, it's analysis time!

We learn that some students commute by bus. We'd previously seen Zumi seem to bicycle up from somewhere. Reinforces that this isn't a boarding school per se, just a school that draws some people from far enough that they have to find a place to live -- affiliated dorms for Umi et al.

(I was re-reading Chapter 21, and noted that Umi's mother seemed out of touch with Umi's studies. But, right, Umi lives in a dorm in another town, it makes sense that mom wouldn't know anything Umi hasn't told her.)

lunch table: Team Nae-Zumi-Umi at one end of the table. Ibu next to Yosshi, and in a good position to keep an eye on Umi.

When Umi gets roped into friendship chocolate, Nae and Zumi seem to go "what?" and sweatdrop respectively. Do they suspect Umi has a girlfriend? Has Umi told them off-page? (I sure hope we didn't miss that.) Sadly, we don't revisit this.

In the chocolate scene, I thought "Ibu is really self-centered", but then we see her latch onto Umi's favorite -- which we do revisit, as she leaves some for Umi later! Anonymously. Ibu capable of selflessness, or just self-defeating?

Poor Ibu getting hand-fed by Umi the Ladykiller.

(Then there's Zumi, who feels obliged to go along with the secrecy, but resents it.)

Umi's little brother seems a lot bigger than I remember. Did he growth spurt since the summer?

Makki gets a last name! Matsuki. Is Makki a nickname based on that? Given trends, her name might be Matsuki Maki, with Makki the nicknamified version of Maki.

Aww, another kiss. With due diligence scouting first.

Oh. Hey. Notice what did not happen? Zumiko talking about chocolate for her alleged boyfriend. Or anyone asking her about it. I guess they've gotten used to her stonewalling them.

last edited at May 26, 2026 8:26AM

In%20your%20butt
joined Jun 21, 2021

Ughhh, they're so sweet they're giving the chocolate a run for its money

Rosenakahara
Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

I feel SO BAD for Ibu, it's hard enough being gay when most of your friends are straight but even worse when the girl you're into isn't but is already in a relationship.
Like a tiny bit of hope is there only to be snuffed out.

9286787ab50153acb27cd03b385edb3d949d719e0b569799723637ee189d1f4b_1-1
joined Aug 14, 2020

Warn a guy before ya hit him with the cutest shit in the world eh?

That "being in love is so much fun" damn near sent me into diabetic shock it was so sweet.

last edited at May 26, 2026 9:39AM

joined Jun 11, 2021

the absolute dopamine rush i get when i see an update. i can't get enough of them they're soooooo sweet

Magic Numbers
joined Mar 17, 2020

love is a gentle thing ;-;

To reply you must either login or sign up.