You all have written a shit ton on this, I've seen borderline novella-length articles as well in various places on social media. I could too, in the usual fashion I've seen, but I'm tired. I'm really, really god awfully tired of the whole sthick where we pretend to have amnesia about the very long history of how lesbian relationships are treated in media and how that informs the contemporary circumstances and how we ought to gauge them. And especially in Japan, where its historical and material conditions have led to a particular handling of lesbian stories in the line of what we see here.
A good primer on this (which also discusses Japanese-specific history!), is this video essay "The yuri was always doomed": https://youtube.com/watch?v=ciY9IM8a-GU .
Instead, I am going to write a long post in the way that I feel like. I am going to ignore a lot of what others consider necessary evidence to establish because I categorically refuse to entertain this nonsense, honestly.
I, also, frankly do not care to entertain the whole "well maybe the authors meant XYZ" or it was "supposed to be this way". I am much more interested in the:
A. Actual story as it appears to the audience and;
B. The historical and material circumstances giving rise and influence to the story's formation.
(A bit of a non sequitur) We use the word "chair" for chairs in English not because of any special reason, any hidden ultimate truth, but for the material conditions we grow up within. A "chair" is a "chair" because of its psychosocially-instilled form and function which we learn to label. This grows outwards of a long chain of human behavior and cultural norms that proceeds from generation to generation, society to society. Often even coming forth from the wide upheavals the many, many invasions of imperialist design have wrought upon us collectively. Studies have even shown that there's been a massive decrease in language proliferation due to the hegemony set up by these empires conquering large swaths of human civilization. So on.
In that sense I am not of the mind to speculate on authorial intent. It's much more productive to analyze the story's design from the looming influences in the room. It's often conflated that the mind forms very originally and from there comes the social context and behavior of a person. This is backwards: the social context is where the mind actually grows into being.
Your circumstances initiate the ongoing dialogue between your mind and your social context. People have autonomy, but they do not choose the circumstances they originate in, and those have much influence.
Hence, with that out of the way, this story ended like shit:
\1. Mari's character development was criminally underbaked:
Mari was given many trials: her mom's passing, her consistent grief as symbolized by her cross necklace, her own dismissal to how she (evidently) cared about Lara (going so far as to get visibly jealous), how her long-time friend "Gon-Chan" (Grace) died suddenly, how her inability to sufficiently aid Lara effected her emotionally, how Lara then decides to leave her (if temporarily, even if technically not-so-far). Not to mention literally being killed and revived by her crush. None of these are solved satisfyingly, or perhaps more objectively, it was done so unconvincingly. She is fifteen (?) years old. If she were a real life person I would expected debilitating trauma that she would need intensive therapy for. This is some fucked up shit. Even trying to be lenient about it, many are left with the impression that she was royally screwed over, consistently by each subsequent story beat. This is hard to argue against without sounding deranged.
\2. The thematic trajectory takes a fucking U-Turn at the end
This is really not hard to establish. Many here and elsewhere have argued to the contrary, that there were many hints of this theme of "independence" portion being key. I agree, somewhat. What I do not agree with is the implications that are poorly demonstrated from this facet. The simple truth of the matter is that it was borderline beat into our heads that choosing Mari as a love interest was a choice barred from Lara! The show, perhaps without intention, followed a thematic throughline of some pretty extreme comphet behavior. Lara ignored her own feelings over, and over, and over, and over. Meanwhile, an alternative was pantomimed in front of audience in a distinct Mari-shaped manner over, and over, and over.
There were hardly any hints of the outcome that the small 6-month timeskip section grew to be. While again, several have argued that the LaraMari Chekhov's gun was indeed fired in the form of a couple small clips and statements by the characters (which seems like an absurd point to make with how much more explicitly, and with more screen time, the conclusion of the relationship between Lara and Luca came to be), it is much more accurate to say it misfired and the bullet had stayed in the barrel.
It is really hard to unsee, that, from the trajectory the story was taking, Lara choosing Mari could have only been considered as a step towards independence. That her love was her own and not a duty and/or a destiny. "Live for love, not for laws," correct?
Let's say this is a cage too, that she had to free herself from. Sure. I am only certain (wow I am not being sarcastic at all /s) that a groundswell of genuine emotional attachment to another person is a cage. We must free ourselves for the certainty of steel yada yada. Kill your earthly attachments and reach enlightenment within my weird individualist fetishism where we pretend, for a moment, that the atomic family is a holy ordained construct that humans must approach or they end in disaster. This could not possibly be a bullshit culturally imposed ideal. What do you mean MY human psychology is usually reliant on long-lasting relations with other people? I should go throw myself into a low-income apartment with absolutely zero lifelines! How smart and satisfying to my personal development. How very rational.
(What Lara really should have done, in the extreme of this aburdist logic, is have ran off from the beginning perhaps, or let Mari die and revived her 20 years in the future after growing up to become a surgeon with a very sizable 401k and have gone through 13 different husbands to make absolutely sure she was totally and completely gay. And not that fake bisexual shit that they teach you in The Gay School that is state-mandated.)
I am intentionally straw-manning to beat you over the head with my point. To be blunt: kids have relationships. Sometimes, no, often, poorly. This is ok. It is ok for them to go into a relationship neither of them are "ready" for, since that is precisely how people do get ready: making mistakes. This is what kids do, they get in over their heads, they fuck up a basic interpersonal situation, they feel like shit and like the world ended, and then the world moves on. They grow, they learn, and next time they try they know a bit better about how to treat each other.
Yes, of course, it is possible to be unhealthily codependent, or so on. And it's certainly possible to take some time to work on yourself instead of throwing your weight in the ring immediately. But none of that alleged potentiality locks off Lara and Mari from each other prima facie. What an absurd, almost borderline snobbish perspective to take, in the light of the story we were presented, that Lara was somehow knowably unready for love. Her last real attempt isn't exactly a fair strike. That prince literally tried to kill her.
But who's argument am I fighting against here? A culmination of claims, perhaps. Maybe I'm fighting ghosts. But my conclusion remains the same: There would be no real narrative issue with it have culminating in an explicitly dictated relationship; on the contrary it would have only made the most narrative sense on the trajectory we were on.
Frankly the whole "time away" thing would have made more natural sense after a messy breakup from bullshit miscommunication. The standard death of young love of pretty much any fashion. And, wherein, for the purposes of this narrative it could have been left on an upbeat note that they'd reunite after "finding themselves" or some relevant fluff. I would have respected that much more. One has to wonder why the option doesn't seem to ever be on the table...
\3. They slaughter Lara's characterization
As well as independently observable, it has been stated everywhere her demeanor becomes "cold" the timeskip segment; that she is stand-offish, unresponsive, so on. She acts completely unlike herself. Beyond what many have said, I find it personally insulting that this seems to be design to paint her as changed; "grown up" even. Like, personally insulting. Emotions are treated as a childish, vapid thing in many cultural contexts we find ourselves in. What a shallow lie we get shoved down our throats on the regular. Do I even have to deign to disprove it? You surely understand, by now, how nonsensical that is. Surely, we've learnt this.
Another point: Part of Lara's charm as a character, and what made her ostensibly "Lara" in the eyes of the audience as they watch her move from experience to experience, is the genuineness of her emotional response. The sheer honesty and fullness and awe with which she interacted with in the environment.
So while we can speculate about authorial intent in making her appear "grown up", well, you already know how I feel about that. Also, A: That's bullshit and a terrible message to send. B: You just threw out the baby with the bath water.
In this way, we say "goodbye" to Lara twice in the same ending. Once, to Lara as we knew her, and again to her hollow shell as she gets on the train. What a waste. There was hardly, also, any characterization to refill what "Lara" became. She was left with nothing after they ripped out her soul.
\4. Subtlety was neither used much, nor of much strength
As a last point in the ghost-fighting match I have clearly taken on, I'd like to fight against the culmination of impressions that a lot of the narrative design can be rationalized under the banner of an intentional "subtlety". That it need not be, in-your-face.
There's a number of problems with this. It may or may not have to do with Lara's history and grievances with love being demonstrated with a giant man-eating fish-monster-dagger thing that literally eats peoples' souls. And that we had an entire in-house explanation of it thrown at us from Grace's subplot. It may also have to do with the fact that Lara herself is anything but subtle in any way whatsoever. She is criminally unable to be subtle. Lara "I Would Die for Cake" McSubtle?
Except, I suppose, when leaving Mari. Or when discussing her love towards Mari. Hm.
And, of course, my philosophical stance on authorial intent: Bluntly it's just incorrigible with the story as presented. But I suppose I must give them the benefit of the doubt when it uniquely seems to be applied to the centerpiece relationship of the story. Which just happens to be of the lesbian kind. In Japan. Hmmmmmmm...
IN CONCLUSION:
To re-include, finally, the surrounding social and cultural context. This is not a new direction this media category has taken. Lesbian media has always been treated in this strange standoffish, inability to be explicit, kind of way. Especially and particularly in Japan. The flailing, fledgling and doomed romance of young girls, as so demanded.
Sure enough you could take a butcher knife and mercilessly remove this context, tear out the organs and taxidermy the body, and call it something entirely different: that stories should be allowed to be this way, that this is just another facet of human experience, yada yada.
Perhaps you are right in the fiefdom of your mind. In a lobotomized scope of literature, the ending was at worst kinda mid. Indeed.
In the known history and experience of lesbian media, on the other hand, it was murder on soil soaked red with that of thousands before. I can't see it as anything but. I refuse to be charitable.
Now, if only everyone could stop trying so hard to hide the bodies, that would be great.
Holy shit you fucking KILLED it, this is pretty much exactly what I've been thinking about the show since that finale aired and it drives me up a wall seeing people twist themselves into pretzels to spin it positively.