Forum › Giniro no Genders discussion

joined Oct 27, 2018

if i can pull off a cross dress that attracts every guy on the streets and i keep doing it after almost getting raped, am i not asking for it?

Please don't make light of rape in the comment section

Icon%20(4)
joined Jan 20, 2014

I sly HATE IT when someone says "there isn't somebody 100% heterosexual", so am I not 100% homosexual, then? Because nobody can have a 100% sexuality according to that people. Superprogresive the invisibilization. Lesbian don't exist, are the fathers.

Rosmontis
Nevrilicious Scans
joined Jun 5, 2015

Polioro posted:

I sly HATE IT when someone says "there isn't somebody 100% heterosexual", so am I not 100% homosexual, then? Because nobody can have a 100% sexuality according to that people. Superprogresive the invisibilization. Lesbian don't exist, are the fathers.

Well not to say you're wrong, but sexuality is not a hard line like people like to imagine, but more of a spectrum. Your spectrum can be 99% for women and 1% for men but it is still there. What I mean, you can feel like you're only attracted to women, but you can still find 1 very specific man that you feel attraction to (not specifically sexual). It might be meme, but there is the "I'm gay for" joke after all. I consider myself a full-fledged lesbian too, but I do find some male voices attractive and I'm totally straight for Archer, so there is exception for any rule. Just 1 exception doesn't break the rule and destroy your whole identity. That being said, as a person who did not read chapter (because that manga is trash), I can't say how it was said and there is a real chance it was presented in a insulting way. I only wanted to say idea itself might not be completely unreasonable.

last edited at Dec 13, 2018 8:13PM

Icon%20(4)
joined Jan 20, 2014

Well not to say you're wrong, but sexuality is not a hard line like people like to imagine, but more of a spectrum. Your spectrum can be 99% for women and 1% for men but it is still there. Just 1 exception doesn't break the rule and destroy your whole identity. That being said, as a person who did not read chapter (because that manga is trash), I can't say how it was said and there is a real chance it was presented in a insulting way. I only wanted to say idea itself might not be completely unreasonable.

You have a point. I have to say that I only read the last chapter because of the ""yuri"" tag and one of them said that when she heard a guy didn't pass in a "girl" (who is in reality a boy cross-dresing) because she was wasted (so being a person makes you gay know). A moment later she continue saying that for talking about transgender people "they are like that too, is a gradation". Sly, I can't talk for the rest of the manga because I'm not into cross-dresing and gender confusing things, so I won't read it, but this last chapter really pissed me off in some parts.

Ryuko
joined May 1, 2018

I thought the blonde haired dude in chapter 7 was a new girl character and was so confused for a straight like 6 minutes. Speaking of, wtf is wrong with him? He's stalking Gin and scratching his chest/throat vigorously, what a creeper

Yuu
joined Mar 28, 2015

if i can pull off a cross dress that attracts every guy on the streets and i keep doing it after almost getting raped, am i not asking for it?

That was the most dumb comment ever.

So, an attractive girl on the streets that doesn't hide under layers of clothes, is "asking for it".

And if she got almost raped, she should stop wearing whatever she was wearing because it could attract a rapist again.

The problem are the rapists, not the way girls dress. If they can't control their urges, there is a serious problem in their education.

4fe5eecd-bb71-4108-8d32-020d4e723c02
joined Oct 3, 2018

Somebody tell every cishet writer/speaker alive that reproducing the “Queer Theory” page from their Women’s Studies 101 textbook does not ever make for naturalistic dialogue.

White%20rose%20index
joined Aug 16, 2018

One of the best series being scanlated right now. The plot is passionating, and the art is like ten times more realistic and elaborate than your usual manga.

F6c7d5d1-1d08-49c3-974d-d6169caf13f6
joined May 8, 2017

this chapter was so weird. Ogura, this is not how you teach people how to dance. And blonde guy, go eat a snickers.

last edited at Mar 12, 2019 8:36PM

24-1
joined Sep 21, 2011

if i can pull off a cross dress that attracts every guy on the streets and i keep doing it after almost getting raped, am i not asking for it?

That was the most dumb comment ever.

So, an attractive girl on the streets that doesn't hide under layers of clothes, is "asking for it".

And if she got almost raped, she should stop wearing whatever she was wearing because it could attract a rapist again.

The problem are the rapists, not the way girls dress. If they can't control their urges, there is a serious problem in their education.

Totally agree!

Even if we were going to say some forms of dress are "asking for it", it's not like he is wearing suggestive clothing that would typically be considered "asking for it".

joined Oct 27, 2018

Somebody needs to teach Gin how to tuck.

Dynasty%20icon
joined Nov 18, 2018

There should be some sort of warning for the last part with his hard-on and all that, but there's no "erection" tag or just simply a "dicks" tag.

Hololive%2032
joined May 1, 2018

I honestly really like the story of this one so far! Even though I usually read yuri, LGBTQ+ stories are very interesting too, and I'm enjoying myself quite a bit. The only thing that makes me think this isn't as good as it appears to be, that the author might actually be pretty lazy is that, looking at the art, doesn't it look an AWFUL lot like CG?

joined Jan 24, 2019

Oh no... dynasty finally did it. They took the SJW route with the tags. They fell into... the trap. Lmfao. I’m outta here.

Dscans%20avatar
joined Mar 30, 2013

The only thing that makes me think this isn't as good as it appears to be, that the author might actually be pretty lazy is that, looking at the art, doesn't it look an AWFUL lot like CG?

Yeah, looks like they directly traced over a model/mannequin. Their bodies are super stiff and the expressions aren't much better. But, other than the stiffness, the art isn't bad.

DR2 Hajime Hinata
Image_2023-07-05_193410907
joined Jul 20, 2016

Great. He's really cut out for himself to get some grudges against him now isn't he?

At this point Seiji hates him and if Asa knew what happened, she would hate him too

Untitled
joined Dec 16, 2014

Is this worth reading?

Town
joined Feb 8, 2018

...What. You know i actually didn't mind this series before? But with this latest chapter... That just felt too much. I might be thinking too much but uh, i'm pretty sure you cant just ejaculate over almost nothing like that? I had one+the testosterone for random erections for quite a while. And uh. Unless i was an unusual example. i needed to actively touch it and such. Touch boob and ejaculate feels like something you would put in a humiliation fetish story too show how pathetic the mc is.

Actually thinking about it has this series sometimes felt a bit... porn plotish? Sometimes it feels like a FictionMania story from the early 2000's. It bugs me.

Also the traced feel is even more with the black girl stereotypes? Especially with how shiny they look.

last edited at Mar 13, 2019 12:00AM

joined Oct 16, 2016

You know it's the last time Igot baited into reading a yuri tagged work without checking manga content before.
How the hell you give a yuri tag to a chapter where a crossdressing guy has constant boner and he ejaculates over thinking about two girls making out and then after being allowed to molest a girl? Seeing how this manga goes soon I bet we will get the "lesbian" turn bi for him and let him fuck her with his penis or something. I see people praising this work, but it's just your typical hentai plot, a guy being into girls who crossdresses and is into a girl is now considered a yuri tag cause reall that short girl x girl male fantasy for sure didn't validate to give this chapter a yuri tag at all.
I hate a chapter where an author gives a message it's ok for a guy to fuck and molest a lesbian he has hots for.
This comic really turned quite homophobic with this chapter, but then I should remember the premise of it, a male MC always does that at some point.

Reimari2%20-%20crop
joined Sep 7, 2016

You know it's the last time Igot baited into reading a yuri tagged work without checking manga content before.
How the hell you give a yuri tag to a chapter where a crossdressing guy has constant boner and he ejaculates over thinking about two girls making out and then after being allowed to molest a girl? Seeing how this manga goes soon I bet we will get the "lesbian" turn bi for him and let him fuck her with his penis or something. I see people praising this work, but it's just your typical hentai plot, a guy being into girls who crossdresses and is into a girl is now considered a yuri tag cause reall that short girl x girl male fantasy for sure didn't validate to give this chapter a yuri tag at all.
I hate a chapter where an author gives a message it's ok for a guy to fuck and molest a lesbian he has hots for.
This comic really turned quite homophobic with this chapter, but then I should remember the premise of it, a male MC always does that at some point.

That's what I would have expected from Yuri tag, if I was on any typical porn site.
No wonder my ISP blocked Dynasty just recently :v

Yuu
joined Mar 28, 2015

^Not sure if trolling or serious.

Ogura has always been advertised as the "Bi" character. See right page here: https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/giniro_no_genders_ch01#1 She's supposed to have good chemistry with Sumon too. And it's yuri, since at this point, she thinks Gin is a girl and is actually trying to turn "her" lesbian. If she discovers his true gender, they are probably to have a huge drama. Nothing proves that she'll jump with him in bed.

At this point, as the title suggests, I think the MC is gender-fluid. Depending on who he interacts with, he feels more like a guy or a girl. That's consistent with him cross-dressing.

As for Seiji, he's a closeted gay and is going to make mistakes.

last edited at Mar 13, 2019 6:55AM

Sayako
joined Mar 1, 2013

Yes.. "yuri"..right

Sandra2
joined Mar 22, 2013

I also would not use yuri tag for this chapter. there were not two girls involved. One was just in his imagination and the other was with one being a crossdresser, who identifies as male.

LilLegalLoli94
241
joined Sep 25, 2018

And it's yuri, since at this point, she thinks Gin is a girl and is actually trying to turn "her" lesbian.

That's not yuri, that's misunderstandings and deception

joined Jan 26, 2019

The main character comes off as extremely in denial about their gender feelings rather than just being into crossdressing

To reply you must either login or sign up.