I think the latter is a wildly unfair statement. I'm a big fan of Destroy It All And Love Me In Hell and that's pretty damn toxic yuri. I loved Black and White as well. This is entirely different. We've had basically 0 from Hana. She's given us nothing and no reason to root for her, and this specific chapter some good reasons not to root for her.
I agree, I jumped the gun there, and I edited my earlier comment.
But everything about chapter 3-4 just confirms it to me that this is not really a yuri manga where it counts. There is Hikaru with her one-sided obsession, and there is the "homewrecker" who barely shows her face in the story at all. They don't really form what we could call a pairing. It's not that this story is toxic, it's that there is no yuri narrative taking place. Not even a toxic or tragic one.
Which, again, shouldn't be surprising in this manga, given that it's officially packaged and sold only with the romance tag. Readers on Dynasty are taking the Yuri tag (and the lack of a Het tag) applied by the uploaders at face value, and expecting something that was technically never promised.
main character doesn't even get horny about the supposed homewrecker, and the husband is a "green flag"
I don't think using that as a metric works because most of Yuri's works don't start with "I like this girl, she makes me horny." Masturbation is also not common. Most of the time it's "I like this girl gets nervous" and that happens here. But also, her husband doesn't make her horny either.
I didn't mention masturbation... I was of course talking about yuri manga with cheating or wife-stealing, not just any random yuri manga. For example, in chapter 1 of Pinky Candy Kiss, Takara is already thinking about the taste of the kiss she shared with her now married ex-classmate almost two decades before. Authors usually want to prime the audience for what will generally happen in the story.
last edited at Jan 28, 2026 7:53PM