Forum › Ienai Himitsu No Aishikata discussion

Old%20man%20prof
joined Oct 25, 2022

Certainly one of the endings of all time.

Screenshot%202024-08-04%20044759
joined Jun 21, 2021

Maybe not the ending we wanted, but at least we got an ending. Better than being forever lost in hiatus hell

Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

Would have preferred a more decisive ending, but this is fine as well. At least the author was able to come back and give it an ending at all, and taking a step ahead to show us where their lives would go from here may have well been a better end than a rushed conclusion.

Cs4_cover
joined Jul 13, 2015

Bah, it was impossible for the author make a decent conclution since from sensei part need development
But really prefer she choice both but wait until they graduated

Wormworld
joined Jan 13, 2022

bullshit

Nq9nh0qj
joined Oct 25, 2023

I mean we got an "ending" insofar as there was a chapter that said "fin" at the end of it.
Nothing was resolved and I honestly don't see the point in the author putting the effort into one last chapter like this after a long hiatus. I feel no more satisfaction from that last chapter than I would have if it never existed. Not even the kiss does anything for me since it was a surprise attack and feelings weren't confirmed.

I'm disappointed we didn't get to see any development between the stepsisters. The MC was convinced her family hated her despite her younger stepsister being quite fond of her. Would've been nice to see her come to realize it.

We need more gremlin MCs like this one. She's such a pain in the ass but also entertaining.

last edited at Aug 27, 2024 5:15PM

Psyduck
joined Jun 17, 2015

It's not even an ending lol. For the majority of the chapter, there is plot hooks and developments as if this was just a normal, monthly chapter. The last 3 pages feel like they were hastily stapled on to this chapter to slap a fin on a story that didn't reach any conclusion.

maidenlessclaire
Rkkixs_v_400x400
joined Feb 16, 2023

Meh

543633_50
joined Sep 10, 2022

It's not even an ending lol. For the majority of the chapter, there is plot hooks and developments as if this was just a normal, monthly chapter. The last 3 pages feel like they were hastily stapled on to this chapter to slap a fin on a story that didn't reach any conclusion.

That's exactly what it was. This feels no better than if it had ended last chapter. And they had easy opportunities to try and put a bow on things.

Why not have the teacher just outright reject Mizuki? We know that's where it's going anyway. Mizuki could have left, consoled by her friend. The end. Instead we have this "she technically didn't say no yet," non-ending, as though there's more chapters coming. (The "technically she didn't say no," trope is annoying anyway, so I'm sort of glad that was avoided.)

It's not like we don't know who the main couple is. Then we have the actual kiss, blush and promise of a future for the main couple, which makes it even more silly not to edit in that rejection. Weird all around. Feels like they just changed the last 2-3 pages to end it and washed their hands. Even a time skip would have been better.

last edited at Aug 27, 2024 6:56PM

420e065dfd1a4d6b3655ec2b8f710afc%20(1)
joined Apr 25, 2020

Yada yada yada I don't care, weird asf series absolutely despicable chatacters horrendous dynamics, awful would not recommend

Jesus
joined Sep 3, 2022

This is one of those situations one person says "no one loves me, that's so unfair" and the other one just thinks "it's not, your personality sucks", the first person is haruka, she has the nerve to say "I haven't done anything to deserve this!" while blackmailing sensei, bitch, you deserve the pain

420e065dfd1a4d6b3655ec2b8f710afc%20(1)
joined Apr 25, 2020

We need more gremlin MCs like this one. She's such a pain in the ass but also entertaining.

I would have to disagree sadly, MC is probably the worst part of this god forsaken series

Nq9nh0qj
joined Oct 25, 2023

We need more gremlin MCs like this one. She's such a pain in the ass but also entertaining.

I would have to disagree sadly, MC is probably the worst part of this god forsaken series

A reasonable sentiment, but I tend to enjoy characters with off-putting flaws.
The pain in the ass, overbearing gremlin was a decent contrast for the pushover teacher. A more well-adjusted and reasonable MC would have made for a terribly boring manga...not that it ended up particularly entertaining as it is.

last edited at Aug 27, 2024 7:58PM

joined May 3, 2014

We need more gremlin MCs like this one. She's such a pain in the ass but also entertaining.

I would have to disagree sadly, MC is probably the worst part of this god forsaken series

Sadly for you that is just an subjective opinion

last edited at Aug 27, 2024 11:31PM

Purple Library Guy
Kare%20kano%20joker
joined Mar 3, 2013

We need more gremlin MCs like this one. She's such a pain in the ass but also entertaining.

I would have to disagree sadly, MC is probably the worst part of this god forsaken series

Sadly for you that is just an subjective opinion

Well la de da. Nobody ever gets to say anything on one of these forums ever again, then.

Charon-sml
joined Feb 14, 2016

For me the problem is that this was a story that set up all its elements as something more along the lines of psych / psych-horror or suspense, and this last chapter tried to resolve it as, for some reason, a bog-standard romance. Gives the story about all the coherence of the whipped cream on top of a hamburger.

1pixel
joined Dec 3, 2010

This!
A character that I can resonate T_T uuw.. (not the teacher x student part), but a girl/lady who likes to read Yuri manga ..T_T..
I'm glad uuww...
The people I've known so far are fujoshi, they prefer yaoi pairings but it's so little to know people who are ladies/girls and read/like Yuri mangas T_T...

The circle is so small after all...T_T..

P.s. I see..
The genre of this story is drama.. ;'|

last edited at Aug 28, 2024 2:27AM

420e065dfd1a4d6b3655ec2b8f710afc%20(1)
joined Apr 25, 2020

We need more gremlin MCs like this one. She's such a pain in the ass but also entertaining.

I would have to disagree sadly, MC is probably the worst part of this god forsaken series

Sadly for you that is just an subjective opinion

What???? Why did no one tell me that, I must I've looked like an idiot shi I thought it was objective goddamn (ToT)

joined Jul 31, 2022

We need more gremlin MCs like this one. She's such a pain in the ass but also entertaining.

I would have to disagree sadly, MC is probably the worst part of this god forsaken series

Sadly for you that is just an subjective opinion

Lol wut? No shit sherlock.

Anyways, I feel like the author just wanted to end it. This was a whole lotta nothing! Sensei literally sat there for like 4 chapter with her thumb in her mouth and head in outerspace. Pushover types are interesting but she was just like...there? MC's realization of her love for sensei felt really out of place. Meh that was an ending of all time.

Yuu
joined Mar 28, 2015

After the nearly 2 years hiatus, it was predictable it would be axed.

At least, the scanlator didn't drop it. It's been the same one for 4 years. They sure are dedicated.

Some manga get directly cancelled and don't even get an ending (Prism anyone?). At least, we got a conclusion here.

It probably means the sales of volume 1 were really bad and the author lost motivation and found something else to do. Maybe they got married, maybe they got a kid, but I think their mangaka career is over.

Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

Regardless of everything else, this will always remain one of the greatest manga ever just for giving us this.

joined Apr 16, 2022

It's a shame it ended like this, unlike some others I really enjoyed Haruka -- it's rare to have a love interest as flawed as her and I thought she was a really interesting character. Oh well. Maybe I'll use it as inspiration to write my own story with a similar character dynamic lol.

Regardless, thanks a lot for the translation!

Sdm%20ladies%20cheering
joined Apr 10, 2023

We need more gremlin MCs like this one. She's such a pain in the ass but also entertaining.

I agree. I love a deeply flawed fuckup protagonist

Yuibless
joined Jan 30, 2017

We need more gremlin MCs like this one. She's such a pain in the ass but also entertaining.

I agree. I love a deeply flawed fuckup protagonist

Hopefully the success(?) of Girlsband Cry makes them more common.

Ad3popdgqsfc1
joined Apr 18, 2023

yup certainly one of the manga of all time....honestly it feels like over-elaborated oneshot to me, there was sooooo little for 13 chapters

To reply you must either login or sign up.