Forum › I Wish Her Love Could Come True discussion

Gay%20panic
joined Sep 11, 2020

What the hell is it with guys like this? If it's not portrayed as heinous awful shit, which it's not here, who is this for?

Slight caution though, things don't really get better until chapter 8 and the guy gets a redemption arc and "good guy" treatment by both girls that I don't think he deserves in the slightest.

Well that is extremely uncomfortable.

18992b47e3036da3324d1a85848e4b9e
joined Jul 16, 2019

Babe, who's the best hitman you hire last time? I want to make an appointment

Phpcmgiip_c2pm
joined Dec 14, 2016

I usually never post. But what the fuck was that!? I know about tropes but this is just plopped into the plot just like that and I am not even sure what it accomplishes.

last edited at Sep 24, 2022 12:18PM

Kirin-kun Uploader
Oip
Rehashed Scans
joined Mar 21, 2021

An interesting take is that since it's from 2020, the disclaimer from the publisher is about people not wearing masks and practicing social distancing.

joined May 23, 2017

I liked this manga cos it's angsty as hell, great for late night reading... But that kiss ugh now I gotta cleanse my mind. I'm hoping yoh is gonna kick him in the balls in the next chapter

Not to mention how cringy and inappropriate that 'you dislike me but not indifferent with me' wthh

last edited at Sep 24, 2022 12:47PM

D05536d6-01d1-4527-9102-4cc772fad5ed
joined Jul 6, 2020

EW WHAT THE FUCK

HOLY SHIT I WANNA KNEE HIM IN THE GROIN SO BADLY

If this guy really is getting a fucking redemption arc somehow I’m done with this series. Not worth my time.

joined Mar 26, 2021

Feels like classic shojo toxic tropes...

joined Sep 6, 2018

I think “Dick Move” applies here. I’d bet mangaka is going to push the envelope in the next chapters.

Yup, I was right. So, I’m out.

To be honest, mangaka had to do something controversial at the end of volume 1 or else no one would bother to read the subsequent volumes. I think the reader response in this thread is a case of posting a manga to the wrong audience… which is why I’m out.

1622968954411
joined Jun 3, 2014

Yoh molested Misa and then Ren molested Yoh, now when will Misa molest Ren?

last edited at Sep 24, 2022 1:21PM

LaPucelleOnGirls
La%20pucelle%2004
joined Apr 12, 2021

This is the most KISAMA he can do ;(

DoctorStrangelove
System-shock-shodan-featured
joined Mar 22, 2018

Fucking hell what is wrong with this author?

Tongtong.exe
joined Apr 27, 2021

Yeah, I know, these tropes were already stale by then. But as a reminder, it got published in a purely shoujo magazine (and as far as MU can be trusted, it's the only yuri series they ever published) and in the end, it doesn't go the way people think it will. Some people are biased because they read up until chapter 9 in Spanish, but there are 13 chapters total.

Just out of curiosity, is it really 13 chapters? I read the raws on cmoa and they only had until 12, did I miss a chapter? Seemed like a definite ending though...

Yuu
joined Mar 28, 2015

ChikyuuNeko posted:

Yeah, I know, these tropes were already stale by then. But as a reminder, it got published in a purely shoujo magazine (and as far as MU can be trusted, it's the only yuri series they ever published) and in the end, it doesn't go the way people think it will. Some people are biased because they read up until chapter 9 in Spanish, but there are 13 chapters total.

Just out of curiosity, is it really 13 chapters? I read the raws on cmoa and they only had until 12, did I miss a chapter? Seemed like a definite ending though...

I went to cmoa by curiosity.

Chapter 13 is at the end of Vol 3.

It's a "bonus story". If you go on cmoa.jp and use the reader to look at the table of content of vol3, it's there.

last edited at Sep 24, 2022 1:57PM

joined Sep 7, 2021

Someone who has finished reading the manga. Spoil it for me. I wanna follow but I don't wanna waste my time if the story fails to deliver. I don't particularly care if it goes yuri, poly or het, as long as it doesn't become comedically ridiculous doing so.
Save for the typical angst I can't get a read on how the story intends to go about things.

Kirin-kun Uploader
Oip
Rehashed Scans
joined Mar 21, 2021

To complete the answer it's about 20 pages long and it's kind of an epilogue

Jesus
joined Sep 3, 2022

Short hair girl molests her friend, short hair boy forces himself on short hair girl, they totally match, I ship both.

Shinobu%20cain%202
joined Aug 19, 2015

I was kinda starting to ship MC with the guy. Partly because being in love with Misa feels so suffocating (for now at least) and that molestation scene did turn me off a bit. But then Ren goes and does that too and it also ticked me off. So it's like okay why are you peeps like this?

Still, I kinda wanna see what happens. I'm just feeling the cringe for now.

joined Sep 12, 2021

Ren sucks but man was that kabedon hot.

joined Nov 8, 2018

I was here to see yuri not that.

Tongtong.exe
joined Apr 27, 2021

ChikyuuNeko posted:

Yeah, I know, these tropes were already stale by then. But as a reminder, it got published in a purely shoujo magazine (and as far as MU can be trusted, it's the only yuri series they ever published) and in the end, it doesn't go the way people think it will. Some people are biased because they read up until chapter 9 in Spanish, but there are 13 chapters total.

Just out of curiosity, is it really 13 chapters? I read the raws on cmoa and they only had until 12, did I miss a chapter? Seemed like a definite ending though...

I went to cmoa by curiosity.

Chapter 13 is at the end of Vol 3.

It's a "bonus story". If you go on cmoa.jp and use the reader to look at the table of content of vol3, it's there.

Thanks, didn't see that. Really sucks though, I purchased the series as individual chapters which seems to not include the extra... Well, guess I'll have to wait until it's translated here then

joined Apr 16, 2022

Well, I for one am still quite enjoying this manga; I think it's interesting how Misaki is ensconced in a love triangle with two toxic, sexually assaulting love interests. I certainly understand why people don't like it but this sort of melodrama is entertaining too sometimes.

Lojsdbe
joined Sep 16, 2019

Everyone keeps talking about the kiss at the end there, and while, yes, that is beyond icky and creepy, are we just going to ignore all the other shit Ren did this chapter? Like, first we’ve got that whole “make amends” shit that sounds like it came right out of a porn opening. Then you have him going “Oh, she doesn’t want to join the student council? Well then I’ll FORCE her to join the student council,” and (ab)using the powers of his position to make that happen. And let’s not forget the fact that, as he is holding Yoh down, he feels the need to bring up (well, imply, but the same principle applies) that he’s a sadist.

I’m not trying to justify Yoh’s whole nighttime molestation thing, but I think it’s safe to say that this dude is well-beyond being an absolute creep. He’s just, blegh. I’m think that I’m going to put this one aside for awhile. At least until it gets closer to the ending.

last edited at Sep 24, 2022 5:08PM

Img_3750
joined Feb 3, 2021

Everyone keeps talking about the kiss at the end there, and while, yes, that is beyond icky and creepy, are we just going to ignore all the other shit Ren did this chapter? Like, first we’ve got that whole “make amends” shit that sounds like it came right out of a porn opening. Then you have him going “Oh, she doesn’t want to join the student council? Well then I’ll FORCE her to join the student council,” and (ab)using the powers of his position to make that happen. And let’s not forget the fact that, as he is holding Yoh down, he feels the need to bring up (well, imply, but the same principle applies) that he’s a sadist.

I think most people are able to look past a lot of the scummy behavior because it can be forgiven to an extent. Hell, even the “make amends” shit. What people have a much harder time forgiving is him forcing himself on her, especially after she made it very clear she didn’t want it, and that’s why that’s what they are focusing on.

Img_0215
joined Jul 29, 2017

Everyone keeps talking about the kiss at the end there, and while, yes, that is beyond icky and creepy, are we just going to ignore all the other shit Ren did this chapter? Like, first we’ve got that whole “make amends” shit that sounds like it came right out of a porn opening. Then you have him going “Oh, she doesn’t want to join the student council? Well then I’ll FORCE her to join the student council,” and (ab)using the powers of his position to make that happen. And let’s not forget the fact that, as he is holding Yoh down, he feels the need to bring up (well, imply, but the same principle applies) that he’s a sadist.

I think most people are able to look past a lot of the scummy behavior because it can be forgiven to an extent. Hell, even the “make amends” shit. What people have a much harder time forgiving is him forcing himself on her, especially after she made it very clear she didn’t want it, and that’s why that’s what they are focusing on.

Right—if a serial killer shoplifts a murder weapon, exceeds the speed limit on the way to the victim’s house, and runs over a puppy while parking before proceeding to decapitate the victim, most people are going to say, “Eww—serial killer!”

joined Sep 24, 2022

Gross. Dropped.

To reply you must either login or sign up.