Forum › The Guy She Was Interested in Wasn't a Guy At All discussion

Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

In case some people didn't catch the reference, the chapter title and Aya's dream are both references to Orihime and Hikoboshi, the Star crossed couple at the heart of Tanabata (July 7).

Yep, this story was pretty cute. Aya beckoning her across, and Mitsuki struggling to join her until music literally becomes their bridge was very sweet.

Thomasina Pontier
342713096_945190890232560_6363820535049258469_n
joined Mar 18, 2023

I think we begin to understand what is wrong with Mitsuki. hSe things that her guitar is the only means to unite her with Aya. By stop playing the guitar, the relationship will end sooner or later. We do not know if Mitsuki really has given up on playing (highly unlikely, she is just having a artistic crisis), but by delaying making a decision as long as possible, including avoid telling Aya, can avoid the potential break up (in heer mind). Aya was with her not because of only the guitar.

Electric%20(1)
joined Jul 15, 2020

but what if i die

Kuroko-railgun
joined Jul 21, 2024

it's like a mini version of Aya and mitsuki
https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/the_guy_she_was_interested_in_wasnt_a_guy_at_all_ch172#2

never mind just got to page 4...

last edited at Jul 19, 2026 2:00AM

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

Time to throw hands!

Also I was wondering if we’d see more from the series delving into the sexuality of it, and potentially tackle homophobia, looks like this chapter answers that question.

F681487268e9a137ba6d004c990be0e7
joined Jan 27, 2026

I'm not disappointed with the chapter, just annoyed that they haven't resolved the issue with Mitsuki and Aya yet, and now they've decided to focus on yet another character? Ahhughghggghhh, with each passing chapter I can't help but think the series has lost its way. I'm sorry. I keep reading it out of obligation, but I don't even know if I like the characters anymore. The reason I was staying was to see the main couple's problem resolved, because it's already problematic enough. Well, I'll have to wait another week...

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

I'm not disappointed with the chapter, just annoyed that they haven't resolved the issue with Mitsuki and Aya yet, and now they've decided to focus on yet another character? Ahhughghggghhh, with each passing chapter I can't help but think the series has lost its way. I'm sorry. I keep reading it out of obligation, but I don't even know if I like the characters anymore. The reason I was staying was to see the main couple's problem resolved, because it's already problematic enough. Well, I'll have to wait another week...

I think this chapter has things to explore…which is why I also feel like unless it ties into the main couple’s current situation it should have come after the resolution there.

EternalSongbird
joined Feb 4, 2019

Oh boy...I think Aki bout to come how with bruises for getting into a fist fight over his big sisters...YOU SHOW 'EM BOO.

_warningm_edited
joined Jan 15, 2021

Time to throw hands!

Also I was wondering if we’d see more from the series delving into the sexuality of it, and potentially tackle homophobia, looks like this chapter answers that question.

Nah. While I approve of, Hell I'll agree with the sentiment of defending his sister and her girlfriend, but he'll get more mileage from just quietly withdrawing from their friendship. Not cutting ties but just putting distance between them. 'Cause the question will come up as to why, and he says "You think my sister is weird for dating a girl, if I don't mind it that means I'm weird too. You really want to hang out with a weirdo?"

Yeah, it's wishful thinking a kid would understand social dynamics like that, but I can hope.

last edited at Jul 19, 2026 2:51AM

Thomasina Pontier
342713096_945190890232560_6363820535049258469_n
joined Mar 18, 2023

Finally we have homophobes showing up in the manga.

"Awhile back I have Mimtuki playing the opening theme on the guitar..." I wonder if that means Mitsuki is actually toying about the guitar once and awhile quietly for awhile (Aki probably has no idea Mitsuki has stopped performing, asked, and Mitsuki played seeing no harm done to herself). Another clue is now given about the central problem of the arc.

last edited at Jul 19, 2026 3:00AM

Img_20260111_021247
joined Oct 6, 2014

Time to throw hands!

Also I was wondering if we’d see more from the series delving into the sexuality of it, and potentially tackle homophobia, looks like this chapter answers that question.

Nah. While I approve of, Hell I'll agree with the sentiment of defending his sister and her girlfriend, but he'll get more mileage from just quietly withdrawing from their friendship. Not cutting ties but just putting distance between them. 'Cause the question will come up as to why, and he says "You think my sister is weird for dating a girl, if I don't mind it that means I'm weird too. You really want to hang out with a weirdo?"

Yeah, it's wishful thinking a kid would understand social dynamics like that, but I can hope.

I feel like that's a bit of an immature way to handle relationships and friendships. Why put distance instead of communicating first?

Also, kids are at the peak where they're learning more about the world and, more often than not, the things they see as "weird" are a reflection of what they hear in their households. The worldview can be a bit limited but that doesn't make them immediately bad.

SmallFriendlyScorpion
Not%20a%20single%20thought
joined Apr 25, 2020

it's like a mini version of Aya and mitsuki
never mind just got to page 4...

unless...
you can't tell me that boy's got featured thus and there won't be some character development for him.

could be though that all the other kids' reactions are solely for Aki to have a moment defending his sis and think about the challenges he didn't know she'd be facing

Azraelle Kindori
R_u0rtlk_400x400
joined Mar 29, 2025

No,,, not the kid...

Electric%20(1)
joined Jul 15, 2020

I will be the first to try and be positive, but I actually want to drop an honest prediction before the next chapter. Aki is being exposed to homophobia, which in turn will lead to him asking Aya if she should be with Mitsuki even though it's weird. From that point, we either get an honest-to-god conversation about their relationship that ends with them reaffirming their affection, or we get Good Luck, Babe. I don't like my own thoughts

X2(edited)2
joined Jan 2, 2022

I love this. Aya and Mitsuki have kind of established a haven of positivity around them but this is still modern Japan and people are pretty casually homophobic. I'm curious if Aki will be influenced by the kids at school, if he'll pretend to agree with them to have an easier time, or if he'll get ostracized for standing up for his sister. No matter which way it goes, the girls will find out since they spend a fair amount of time together. I'm also curious how his brother will react.

Kuroko-railgun
joined Jul 21, 2024

it's like a mini version of Aya and mitsuki
never mind just got to page 4...

unless...
you can't tell me that boy's got featured thus and there won't be some character development for him.

could be though that all the other kids' reactions are solely for Aki to have a moment defending his sis and think about the challenges he didn't know she'd be facing

Indeed unless
Maybe just maybe if Aki will stand up for his sister in the next chapter, the boy who said, "I guess it's not normal," would realize how serious this is to him and eventually become more understanding.

joined Jan 14, 2020

No one else thinking Aki is a bit gay for Riku?

joined May 9, 2017

No one else thinking Aki is a bit gay for Riku?

I did think that. That's why he was a bit distraught by his reaction.

Chinchilla
joined Apr 28, 2022

Why are we tackling another issue when we still haven't wrapped up the other issue that's been dragging on for months at this point smh

Aoi%20nagisa%20-%20s
joined Aug 17, 2012

Why are we tackling another issue when we still haven't wrapped up the other issue that's been dragging on for months at this point smh

I think we have ... sort of ... maybe ...

The symbology of the Vega And Altair chapter shows them apart on separate islands, trying and failing to reach each other (Aya's broken ladder/bridge) and then them coming together via the Zebra and music.

Thus it can be implied that they have resolved their issues, but have left the details out of exactly how.

SmallFriendlyScorpion
Not%20a%20single%20thought
joined Apr 25, 2020

Why are we tackling another issue when we still haven't wrapped up the other issue that's been dragging on for months at this point smh

I think we have ... sort of ... maybe ...

The symbology of the Vega And Altair chapter shows them apart on separate islands, trying and failing to reach each other (Aya's broken ladder/bridge) and then them coming together via the Zebra and music.

Thus it can be implied that they have resolved their issues, but have left the details out of exactly how.

aren't they depicted quite young compared to their college selves in that one? I personally interpreted it as a cute callback to how they first got together via their shared love of music, then flash-forwarded to them together in the morning. the juxtaposition is used to imply that the love is still there in their currently slightly troubled relationship. bottom line is I don't think that chapter says "they have resolved their issues"

543633_50
joined Sep 10, 2022

I love this. Aya and Mitsuki have kind of established a haven of positivity around them but this is still modern Japan and people are pretty casually homophobic. I'm curious if Aki will be influenced by the kids at school, if he'll pretend to agree with them to have an easier time, or if he'll get ostracized for standing up for his sister. No matter which way it goes, the girls will find out since they spend a fair amount of time together. I'm also curious how his brother will react.

Yeah and whether this will come back to Aya and Mitsuki. How would they react to something like this?

joined Dec 7, 2022

No one else thinking Aki is a bit gay for Riku?

I was thinking that too lol

I also think maybe Riku agreed with the other boys to fit in / not get teased himself. He said "Who is Mitsuki, AGAIN", which seems like Aki has mentioned Mitsuki to him before. And Riku himself wasn't shocked when Aki explained Aya was dating Mitsuki.

My wild guess is that Riku is aware of and OK with Mitsuaya and is just trying to fit in with homophobes despite it meaning his friend is thrown under the bus.

And my extra wild guess is there are subtle feelings between Aki and Riku and those feelings are low key mutual lol.

1453e55cc3ab545974cae651c20afaf3
joined May 28, 2021

At that age, that definitely checks out. Sadly, it doesn't get much better for a while, and it only gets worse in junior high (^^) I'm in my early forties now and I still carry more of that psychological trauma than I'm willing to admit... The innate social homophobia is just a very real part of life; it's nice that this tries to tackle it.

X2(edited)2
joined Jan 2, 2022

Why are we tackling another issue when we still haven't wrapped up the other issue that's been dragging on for months at this point smh

Because that's the way the author wants to handle it? It's a very normal thing in writing. Just because an issue is brought up doesn't mean it needs to be addressed immediately. And as someone else said, maybe on a different site?, sometimes life comes at you fast and lots of issues pop up at once. It's a normal thing in real life too.

To reply you must either login or sign up.