Forum › Posts by Heavensrun

Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

I think Kamiya may have just straight up told her. "I asked her out and she turned me down because her heart's set on you." The scene it the classroom kinda feels like Yuzu is finally reevaluating. I think Kamiya has boiled over with frustration just like the rest of us, and has decided to just go full cupid.

Heavensrun
Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

I'm kinda surprised actually, with how they were going, that they actually did talk so relatively directly about romance. I expected them to fully bury it until long after they're adults, so that implicit promise of "look we'll date later after we've made sure we don't cause any parodoxes with this flashback" has interesting implications for their present day 'friendship'. Maybe they've just been on the dl for as long as the kid has know them both lol

Also the relatively casual way it was brought up, with neither reacting like their shared romantic interest is news, possibly implies they had an offscreen fling beforehand.

I'm fairly certain they haven't. I think after the rejection in the flashback, Youji tried to let her feelings go, but Youzi's pushing is influencing her. I think Youji has been holding her feelings back for fear of being rejected again, and Weiwei has been holding back because she doesn't know if Youji is still into her that way.

When Youzi first suggests Ren Wei as a love interest, Youji says something like "Don't invest real feelings in your ships", I think that's because she's trying to supress her own feelings at this point. But Youzi's pushing is having an effect on both of them.

Heavensrun
Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

i want to cry ueueueueu

If it helps, in the present day, I'm pretty sure we're on the cusp of a development.

Heavensrun
Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

Yessss finally!

This is so bittersweet, pretty much exactly what I thought. I'm surprised Youji actually got to say it, I thought they'd part with their real feelings unspoken.

You've both got acclaimed careers now, Ren, just get your girl already. Screw the haters! Youzi needs her moms!

(I wish there was a book of this)

last edited at Nov 25, 2024 10:47AM

Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

Wait, didn’t we think Freckle-chan was going to invite Koga to the prom?

I was expecting something exactly like this, A meet&greet with her record co dad. But I was expecting Aya to misunderstand and think it was a prom invite and be super down about it.

Although I try to stay out of the plot-prediction business*, I find it hard to believe that the story is going the “no prom at all” route after going to the trouble of setting it up. Maybe a “leave the producer’s party early and hit the prom together” twist.

*Because the pay is so low even when you get it completely right.

I'm sure, at least, that Aya is lying about having a family thing. She's trying to minimize the prom because she knows it's a good opportunity for Koga, but she's heartbroken on the inside. Aya's gonna be miserable about it, and Koga's going to find out or otherwise pick up on that and there'll be some kind of grand gesture to make up for it.

Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

(laugh) He's the worst principal I've ever seen and I love him.

(Actually, he's not even close to the worst I've seen, he's just kinda bad in a sort of likable way)

last edited at Sep 29, 2024 3:05PM

Heavensrun
Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

I think it would be pretty absurd to end on a tragedy in a manga with as cutesy and soft of a title as "My Cute Little Kitten". So I'm guessing it's all psychological and temporary they just need to finally properly talk

I mean, yeah, but what makes this frustrating is that the characters are being recklessly obtuse. When somebody passes out in the bath, that's not a little issue with her sleep cycle. That's an immediate medical concern, and the fact that mangaka seems unaware of that is very concerning.

Heavensrun
Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

She fell asleep IN THE BATH, TAKE HER TO A FUCKING DOCTOR.

Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

She made the whole school gay for her for real lmao.

The groundwork was already there with the whole prince thing a little while ago, the glowup just cemented it.

Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

Well I had a conversation(?) with the author on Twitter and she basically told me why this scene between Karin and Riri happened. It's all good now lmao.

I would post it here if I knew how to make spoilers.

Or don’t? We don’t need the additional commentary when we can just wait for the next chapter. Personally, I want more of Karin and Riri. Karin’s great, she’s honest and open with her feelings and actions. And I think she could help Riri be more open and honest about her own feelings.

I mean, the whole point of spoiler bars is that you don't have to read it if you don't want it, but it's still there for people who do.

To post spoilers w/ blacked-out text, just put double equal-signs "="x2 before and after the text you want to block out.

I'm always curious to hear the author's thoughts on why they write a scene the way they do. I'm interested in people's processes for writing.

last edited at Jul 31, 2024 1:09PM

Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

I have no idea what posses someone to turn into a anime villian like this and arbitrarily decides to ruin the life of someone they don’t know and had zero prior interactions with like that just seems like completely psycho shit to me, but bullying is just sorta like that I guess

They might not mean it that way. It's already been brought up, but I doubt the last page is literally happening, she's just upset that they're judging and putting labels on her metaphorically and it's causing a panic attack. Whether or not they're being intentionally mean or just careless is hard to say without a larger pattern of behavior. They wrote the lyrics on the board, was that to shame or embarass her, or was it just because they were working on translating a song in a language they don't understand fluently? They're needling her with commentary, is that because they want to put her down or are they just being thoughtless? Doesn't really matter to her trauma, though. I do hope Aya comes to the rescue, but this is something Koga needs to learn to deal with if she's going to keep putting herself out there as an artist.

Heavensrun
Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

Well that's certainly unsettling.

I'm almost mad at Rena. I mean, collapsing from exhaustion after a period of emotional stress, You can think "Maybe that's a one-off," and the fact that she was about to call an ambulance when she finally woke up means she at least recognized how scary that situation is. Finding her asleep on the floor, five hour nap, that's mildly concerning.

But the INSTANT she fell asleep in the tub, they should've resolved to see a doctor the NEXT DAY. Faffing about after that is bordering on negligence.

last edited at Jun 23, 2024 10:42AM

Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

Love rival incoming perhaps?

Doubt it. If I had to bet, I'd say she's more likely to go from crush to fan to shipper.

Heavensrun
Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017
Gmpn6daauaad8vo-orig

Eh, I've drawn plenty of non-canon pictures of my characters, it's not always about your intentions for the character's actual story.

Not to say it's meaningless, but I wouldn't take it as concrete proof either.

Heavensrun
Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

Kinda lost me with this chapter. I'm sorry, I can't easily imagine a world where an employee of a store you sometimes go to showing up at your home isn't just the biggest red flag ever. That's stalker behavior! Not okay! It's a gross misuse of the trust involved in giving a store your address, presumably just for deliveries or sale notification purposes.

When the other employee was looking the guy up, I was like "Oh, maybe they're going to call him or something" but nope, he just straight up gave her the guy's address.

If somebody I met once from a retail outlet I frequent showed up at my house to apologize because they thought they pushed too hard on the sale floor, my first thought would be "What the fuck do you think you're doing NOW?" My second thought would be "Do I need to call the police?"

Heavensrun
Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

So... this is basically all sponsored content now? Someone should teach the artist to be a bit more covert about this.

It's a little unfortunate, but since we're getting all chapters for free the artist's only source of income is through sponsored chapters + income from physical release sales. Besides, she's currently working on a 106-page chapter for university arc (2), so I'd reckon a guess that from now on we'll get huge long b/w chapters for plot, and short-sometimes-sponsored colored pages in the meantime.

Good to know University (2) is being worked on. Do you know if there's been any kind of a projected date for that?

Heavensrun
Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

Remember kids, when you are in a shitty workplace just keep working hard and one day you too will be rewarded! ^^#

Actually, the moral seems to be more along the lines of "If your job sucks, look for an opportunity to move to a better one."

Her tasks were all shitty, until she actively went after an employer that she knew was cool and would treat her decently, and now things are better.

Heavensrun
Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

She got rid of her glasses that made her ugly and incompetent, she's much more beautiful without them... hate that trope so much.

I don't see where you got the idea that they're doing that trope? Just because she's not wearing glasses later doesn't mean her glasses before had anything to do with her attractiveness, her competence, or anybody's perception of either of those things. In fact the narrative makes it pretty clear that she's perfectly competent and is doing her best in an overworked position. She probably just got contacts because they're convenient. Honestly if I could get the things in and out of my eyes I'd wear them too. Glasses are a pain in the ass.

Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

I dunno who the bubbles were but it definitely wasn't either of their first times lol

That's the fakeout. It's the two of them, but they aren't having sex. They're talking about going on a brothel tour. And the suggestive "squeeze" is Sempai grabbing Asumi's hand as they walk to the airport terminal to head to the next stop.

Heavensrun
Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

Yessss, finally. This is one of my absolute favorites, it's been so long since last update, I was a bit worried.

(of course as always, thanks to the uploader/translators)

last edited at Jun 2, 2024 1:07PM

Heavensrun
Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

Do they say that was a summer festival in that chapter? There are other festivals that are during the Japanese school year, including a couple in spring, to say nothing of possible local events. Festival activities are kind of the same for a lot of festivals, so unless they specifically called it out as a summer festival, I think there's wiggle room there. Very good chance there's other contradictions, though.

At least the translation doesn't explicitly call it a summer festival, but I doubt people wear yukata for festivals in early spring.

It mainly depends on the weather, from what I understand. If its warm enough, people will wear yukata for a spring festival.

There's another good one with HonoEli. Honoka went to Eli's home for the first time on Christmas. Soon after there's a chapter where they're celebrating Halloween together at her home.

Yeah, I definitely think the Halloween one would seem to come after the Christmas one. If you really want to make it work, the Christmas one doesn't explicitly say Honoka has never been to Eli's, just that she hasn't met Ed and Ian yet. She's freaking out, but that might more be because of the prospect of a party than the pressure of going to her house for the first time. She is obviously assuming that there will be people there besides them and the host family. And you don't see them interact with Ed and Ian during that scene, the Ed x Ian scene after could be later.

But it's a big stretch. They definitely seem much closer in the Halloween one, it's clearly meant to be later in their relationship.

Heavensrun
Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

there goes my favorite couple T-T

I'm really hoping it's a temporary fakeout. Like she's gotta return for the summer but comes back when school starts again.
.... Actually I've never thought about it before, how does an American foreign exchange student to Japan deal with how the US and Japan have different starting times for the year? Do they only come over in June and miss the first semester of the Japanese school year?

You book a stay for a given length of time that you decide on in conjunction with the school. There's an application process and you specify the period of time you intend to stay, typically a 3 month semester or a full year. You're on the host country's time, so I think you typically plan to follow their schedule when there. Your school at home accommodates your departure and return, specifics might depend on your school or even your personal situation. Exchange students tend to be overachievers, so some students might even just choose to study abroad specifically during the summer semester and not miss much of the normal school year at home.

Given the range of holidays we've seen her participate in, Eli was there for at least two semesters, maybe the full year. I don't think we know if she's there for the march->august semester.

Heavensrun
Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

Somehow the person with the most characterization is the dude? (Did I missed it or does one of the girl not even have a name?)

I'm not opposed to the concept, but this just felt kind of bland.

I mean, it's just a very brief little one-shot that the author dropped on their pixiv.

Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

Man, this one really hit me. Her music helped the kid make friends with the other kids i'm not crying your crynig

Heavensrun
Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

Yeah, I've suspected for awhile that the timeline for all these relationships is jumbled up. I think all the holiday events are taking place concurrently, we just see them way out of order.

That would make a lot of sense. It's pretty much the only logical way of doing a very long running manga in a school setting, unless you go the comedy route and none of it really matters a la yuru yuri.

Mind you, the timelines still doesn't make sense. For instance, Honoka first meets Ed and Ian when Eli invites her to their home for Christmas. The next time they meet is during the summer festival.

Do they say that was a summer festival in that chapter? There are other festivals that are during the Japanese school year, including a couple in spring, to say nothing of possible local events. Festival activities are kind of the same for a lot of festivals, so unless they specifically called it out as a summer festival, I think there's wiggle room there. Very good chance there's other contradictions, though.

As I said above, the school year ends in March. The previous chapter confirms Eli won't stay in Japan long after the school year ends, since it's set a month before her leaving and Kaoru still hasn't graduated.

As far as I can tell, the time rules of this manga are something like this:
1. Chapters can take place whenever in the school year. Despite this, each storyline advances linearly. For instance, Chie and Ai are not dating in any chapter that appeared before ch. 105 and are dating in all chapters that appear afterwards, unless the chapter is clearly marked as a flashback.
2. To avoid really blatant paradoxes, no character is allowed to celebrate the same holiday or other event twice.
3. Entrance exams and running out of time with their romances because of graduation are not usually a concern to any of the third years. EliHono is the only couple on a deadline, at least for now.

Honestly if I had time I'd be interested in trying to see if I can zero in on a particular timeline, or zero in on explicit contradictions, but as a general rule I think this tracks.