Forum › The Guy She Was Interested in Wasn't a Guy At All discussion

joined Mar 1, 2026

I loved this chapter! I love Shuu-chan (i relate to her) <3, it's so cute that she's short too (shorter than Aya?). hoping to see more of her, and i like the use of "red" too , it came across even though the colour wasn't actually being used (very clever!)

The more opaque storytelling I really enjoy when it's a chapter like this one. But this way of storytelling in crucial moments is really unsatisfying if it's not done masterfully (and honestly, i didn't feel it was earlier - though i can see the audience is divided on that). You know, when you tell a story there's a "contract" you have with the reader and in this case the contract is not fulfilled, so I felt cheated... but i do think Sumiko-sensei is always trying to push herself and do something new, and the fact this isn't traditional publishing means less editors to gatekeep you, so overall it's a great thing.

last edited at Mar 15, 2026 11:28AM

Pov_youre_a_triple_mugger
joined Feb 19, 2016

Dudes will see Chekov's Gun being placed on the table and be like "omg I can't believe they didn't just start shooting it immediately this writer is so washed"

Things are being set up, this series has always been a slower burn. We're what, three chapters into the new volume? The last one was 40 chapters, give it time. Enjoy the art and writing and the feeling of wondering what comes next. Chew your damn food and enjoy the flavor

543633_50
joined Sep 10, 2022
  • Aya's hickey, on her neck, is red.
  • The "Sold Out" message, on Japanese vending machines, is a red light.
  • Aya's hair is "red". In the top right panel of page 4, Aya's hair flutters right in Shu's field of vision.
  • Maybe her lipstick is red too (hard to tell).

So, the color "red" represents everything that makes Shu think of Aya and frustrates her, for unstated reasons.

Where is your pfp from?

Kirin-kun Uploader
Oip
Rehashed Scans
joined Mar 21, 2021
  • Aya's hickey, on her neck, is red.
  • The "Sold Out" message, on Japanese vending machines, is a red light.
  • Aya's hair is "red". In the top right panel of page 4, Aya's hair flutters right in Shu's field of vision.
  • Maybe her lipstick is red too (hard to tell).

So, the color "red" represents everything that makes Shu think of Aya and frustrates her, for unstated reasons.

Where is your pfp from?

It's a character from the Horimiya manga.

Basically, the only "lesbian" character, who's in love with Hori.

last edited at Mar 15, 2026 12:10PM

Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

Something new is starting.

543633_50
joined Sep 10, 2022
  • Aya's hickey, on her neck, is red.
  • The "Sold Out" message, on Japanese vending machines, is a red light.
  • Aya's hair is "red". In the top right panel of page 4, Aya's hair flutters right in Shu's field of vision.
  • Maybe her lipstick is red too (hard to tell).

So, the color "red" represents everything that makes Shu think of Aya and frustrates her, for unstated reasons.

Where is your pfp from?

It's a character from the Horimiya manga.

Basically, the only "lesbian" character, who's in love with Hori.

I knew she was familiar. Love that manga and I know who you’re talking about. Thanks. Surprised I didn't clock that sooner.

last edited at Mar 15, 2026 12:20PM

Sun%20jing%20dy-scans
joined Aug 12, 2019

So lay doooooooowwwnnnn
the threat is real
When her siiiiiiiiiiiggghhtt
goes red again

last edited at Mar 15, 2026 9:05PM

Img_5712
joined Jan 3, 2022

Saw the title and thought someone was gonna snap

Glad it didn't happen. Kinda confused on this chick's deal tho. Is she pissed off cuz she has feelings but she knows Aya is taken so she can't do anything about it which is why she kinda takes it out on Aya (the muttering and stuff)

Maybe I'll get it once we learn more? Idk

joined Apr 13, 2025

My prediction is that Shu thinks poorly of Aya because she knows she has a girlfriend, but she was making out with that mysterious rocker dude with the bolo tie and black nail polish who picked her up when she was drunk.

Pride and Prejudice and Rock and Roll.

Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

My prediction is that Shu thinks poorly of Aya because she knows she has a girlfriend, but she was making out with that mysterious rocker dude with the bolo tie and black nail polish who picked her up when she was drunk.

Pride and Prejudice and Rock and Roll.

I dunno, people in Japan aren't likely to advertise their orientation since there's still a lot of prejudice to contend with if you're out. If she doesn't know Aya's significant other is Mitsuki, she's probably not going to be aware that it's a woman, and she'd have no basis to assume, even if she mistook Mitsuki for a guy, that "he" isn't her "boyfriend."

The most likely causes in my estimation are either latent homophobia, or a crush that she doesn't know how to resolve so it's pissing her off.

I suppose it could also be that she's also gay, but not interested in Aya that way, but jealous that Aya got her girl and Shu hasn't got anybody.

joined May 9, 2017

My prediction is that Shu thinks poorly of Aya because she knows she has a girlfriend, but she was making out with that mysterious rocker dude with the bolo tie and black nail polish who picked her up when she was drunk.

Pride and Prejudice and Rock and Roll.

I dunno, people in Japan aren't likely to advertise their orientation since there's still a lot of prejudice to contend with if you're out. If she doesn't know Aya's significant other is Mitsuki, she's probably not going to be aware that it's a woman, and she'd have no basis to assume, even if she mistook Mitsuki for a guy, that "he" isn't her "boyfriend."

Most Japanese people are just very private with their lives, regardless of their sexual orientation. Aya had no problem displaying herself with Mitsuki in highschool, because everyone knew them, so I don't think this is the issue there. My guess here is that she never really talked about Mitsuki as a girl, because the subject didn't come out.

last edited at Mar 16, 2026 11:48PM

joined Nov 22, 2021

Meh. Regardless of the characterization, Chu is a sociopath. They see Aya's mere presence as "provoking" and are distressed by the mere sight of her. Currently their response is shitty, mean comments, but the question is where this will escalate. Will Chu physically lash out at Aya to remove the "provocation"?

I've personally known a few Chu-chans in my life, and it never ends well. Not sure which direction the author plans to take this character, but if it's "change for the better," it's not going to be easy or quick to reform a sociopath. Good luck with that!

In%20your%20butt
joined Jun 21, 2021

Meh. Regardless of the characterization, Chu is a sociopath. They see Aya's mere presence as "provoking" and are distressed by the mere sight of her. Currently their response is shitty, mean comments, but the question is where this will escalate. Will Chu physically lash out at Aya to remove the "provocation"?

idk that seems like quite the jump to conclusions about a character who's so far just internally expressed vague feelings of discontent/annoyance for reasons as of yet unexplained.

And that one comment no one actually heard she muttered under her breath, to herself.

last edited at Mar 17, 2026 12:24PM

joined Nov 22, 2021

Meh. Regardless of the characterization, Chu is a sociopath. They see Aya's mere presence as "provoking" and are distressed by the mere sight of her. Currently their response is shitty, mean comments, but the question is where this will escalate. Will Chu physically lash out at Aya to remove the "provocation"?

idk that seems like quite the jump to conclusions about a character who's so far just internally expressed vague feelings of discontent/annoyance for reasons as of yet unexplained.

And that one comment no one actually heard she muttered under her breath, to herself.

Disagree. I'm not a native Japanese speaker so can't comment on the meaning of "provoke" here, but if it's the same as the western meaning then Chu sees Aya's mere existence as being an attack on them personally.

If someone existing is a provocation/attack, what are Chu's options to resolving that?

Dumshork
joined Mar 19, 2022

We currently have no idea what Shu's deal is, so I think it's best for everyone to just take a couple steps back, get holstered, and take a few deep breaths. Throwing around baseless accusations at characters we don't even understand yet isn't going to help anything.

Img_0215
joined Jul 29, 2017

We currently have no idea what Shu's deal is, so I think it's best for everyone to just take a couple steps back, get holstered, and take a few deep breaths. Throwing around baseless accusations at characters we don't even understand yet isn't going to help anything.

I think this is a pretty good reminder. If we recall the introduction of Narita (“Jerkface”), he looked at first like (and was regarded by many readers, including me, as) the worst of the worst kind of unpleasant guy character in yuri stories. But of course he turned out to be more than just a “good guy,” but an absolute angel facilitator of the MC’s relationship. Other characters who looked like trouble when introduced (the hostile guy at school who messed with Mitsuki’s notebook, the producer’s daughter) turned out to be OK, or even better.

So yeah, let’s see where this goes before pronouncing sentence on Crabcake-chan.

last edited at Mar 17, 2026 7:34PM

joined Sep 1, 2021

she's just jealouuus, arent we aaaall?
she wants a gf so bad

last edited at Mar 18, 2026 8:32AM

Aoi%20nagisa%20-%20s
joined Aug 17, 2012

Ah, it looks like Shu may be, perhaps unintentionally, reminding Aya that she and Mitsuki communicate best through\with music.

Chocolate Cake
Cat_avatar
joined Jul 1, 2025

Haha, what a song choice. Although even at the 1 minute mark/chorus, it doesn't seem noisy enough to get that startled—unless you play it an obnoxious volume. (And while we're at thematically relevant works, have we had a NIN mention yet?)

joined Apr 13, 2025

I note that Shu is missing her hairband. The one that zigzags like Mitsuki’s tattoo.
What does it mean?

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

Please don't blast people's ears with music suddenly. That's a major thing for me, simply ask the person if it's okay to share a song and play it at a reasonable volume.

JuniperPengold
Hotarusquibbly
joined Feb 12, 2025

sending my psychic mind rays that make you cheat on your girlfriend to aya

Firefox_02_22_04_52-502
joined Oct 17, 2025

i think shu is cute i like grumpy girls, but if aya cheats on mitsuki even emotionally, the yuri fandom part of twitter might just implode on itself for real lol

Internet_lied
joined Jul 15, 2016

Guys, relax, this is just a minor relationship bump, which has happened before. Whenever Aya has doubts about her relationship with Mitsuki, she retreats into herself and suffers in silence. Seeking solace outside would be entirely out of character for her.

Pfp2
joined Mar 26, 2025

^^ some (many?) green yuri fans just can't stop being unnormal about green yuri

last edited at Mar 22, 2026 7:12AM

To reply you must either login or sign up.