It has become my belief that in the green world of Sumiko, homosexuality or heterosexuality don't really exist as concepts.
It has NEVER been mentioned that Mitsuki or Aya are lesbians, or that two girls being together is something odd or to feel guilty about. Aya has never been upset or conflicted that Mitsuki turned out to be a girl, only that she had lied to her.
Sumiko has carefully avoided dipping into the topic of homosexuality. Their classmates have been surprised when Aya and Mitsuki said they were dating, but weirdly, the taste in music was an heavier topic than homosexuality (!)
There was no real "gay panic", just "crush panic" that happens all the time in manga to characters attracted to each other.
Homosexuality is the elephant in the room for the readers, but it's like it doesn't exist in-universe.
So the relationship between Aya and Mitsuki, as written by Sumiko, isn't queer or straight.
It's a relationship, period. With its ups and downs as we can see in this arc.
+
Mitsuki is butch coded. Aya is femme coded. But they're not "lesbians" in the "real world" sense. Which is why so many people see them not as a lesbian couple, but as a typical straight couple with a twist.
I think I can understand your frustration a little bit. Correct me if I'm wrong but I wanted to summarize: their homosexuality is "floaty", where every other element in the story has a sense of realism and friction - the drama, characters' ideals, how Sumiko depicts the indie music scene, etc, it's only their sexuality and the nature of their relationship that doesn't carry that "reality".
I think this is what makes the series have such widespread appeal. Because lesbian and butch are not said explicitly in the story except for a specific illustration where the words are there (correct me if I'm wrong on this - I don't feel like going through all 100 chapters), it's easy for people to project onto Mitsuki or Aya. (Or they even erase Mitsuki's masculinity.)
Honestly, it's a frustration I feel too. I do believe Sumiko's intention with this story through and through was to depict a wholesome butch/femme lesbian relationship without the difficulties of homophobia, I think it's a tad cynical to speculate otherwise. I think if every queer creative had to factor in bigotry to their work to make it realistic or serious that would be an unfair expectation and limitation.
But I also think an arc that explicitly depicts the realities of a butchfemme relationship in Japan would do wonders for this work especially because of the audience it has created. Maybe if we never went into an adult arc, it would be a critique I hand waved away because Green Yuri was just a wholesome schoolgirl romance, but it's clear Sumiko is fine with delving into more mature topics with these two. So I think it's a fair critique.
NGL, very inflammatory way to word what you said but I absolutely understand considering my own feelings.
last edited at May 17, 2026 12:54PM