Forum › Whispering You a Love Song discussion

08f6612130a20845a480034c0567fbe1d8926209_hq
joined Apr 27, 2014

I am confused with all the names and new people...let us see... I like the pair with eh band music blondie and the black haired one that was a prodigy or something? I like the original pair, the last girls...the younger sister and the other one...I hope she will forget about her sister, I usually root for sisters together, but not like this.

Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

The support and love she needs right when she needs it the most. And hopefully much more in the end. ^_^

Img_20230402_152744
joined Aug 23, 2022

Imagine that the girl you have a crush tells u that you can't date her because she's in love with her sister...I think that's a big red flag.

So glad we are returning to Yori and Himari and this arc is finally over.

cakeEnthusiast
Capture
joined Mar 2, 2019

Imagine that the girl you have a crush tells u that you can't date her because she's in love with her sister...I think that's a big red flag.

well at least she was honest!

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

Imagine that the girl you have a crush tells u that you can't date her because she's in love with her sister...I think that's a big red flag.

well at least she was honest!

"And this is my girlfriend, I endearingly call her "sisterfister"."

sweetjalapeno15
Ne
joined Nov 21, 2017

I really hate the whole "well how do yk for sure it wont work out unless you confess/try ^^" shit especially with incest of all things like bro what...I for sure thought this was gonna drag on so that Miki would have to get rejected by Aki first thank god we skipped over that

Roody
joined Feb 11, 2022

Aya is a good girl

joined Jul 8, 2019

Imagine that the girl you have a crush tells u that you can't date her because she's in love with her sister...I think that's a big red flag.

well at least she was honest!

"And this is my girlfriend, I endearingly call her "sisterfister"."

Mo*********....

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

Imagine that the girl you have a crush tells u that you can't date her because she's in love with her sister...I think that's a big red flag.

well at least she was honest!

"And this is my girlfriend, I endearingly call her "sisterfister"."

Mo*********....

Morbius?

Dc4181ab-be73-4839-b684-7476d3ac05f5
joined Oct 24, 2018

The more I read, the more I hate this new development.
“Sasakoi is doing well but there are no new drama to exploit? Hey use this girl who had nothing going on with her own setting or character and did nothing to contribute to the story for the last 30 chapters and make her in love with her sister! The drama needs to be as sappy as possible to convince the readers that the manga is still good!”
So bullshit, drama of the week type of manga. I don’t even oppose to incest trope within fictional sphere but this new development with Miki-Aki sibling is so bullshit. Lack of substance, lack of build up, lack of screentime, lack of quality in writing characters. The only thing stay consistently good is the artstyle.

joined Feb 24, 2023

This is an odd complaint but does anyone else think the hair is like TOO detailed sometimes? Like it’s excellent and beautifully drawn but it’s SO dense in the panels I have trouble keeping track of which character is which sometimes because ts always flowing all over the place so it’s hard to make out distinct hair styles on characters

joined Jan 18, 2025

Sasakoi could do without some of the incest :(

joined Jan 14, 2020

either less incest or double down

SchroCatDinger
Takodachi_slime_bocchi_by_walkman0_dg1rfr9-pre
joined Feb 18, 2021

The more I read, the more I hate this new development.
“Sasakoi is doing well but there are no new drama to exploit? Hey use this girl who had nothing going on with her own setting or character and did nothing to contribute to the story for the last 30 chapters and make her in love with her sister! The drama needs to be as sappy as possible to convince the readers that the manga is still good!”
So bullshit, drama of the week type of manga. I don’t even oppose to incest trope within fictional sphere but this new development with Miki-Aki sibling is so bullshit. Lack of substance, lack of build up, lack of screentime, lack of quality in writing characters. The only thing stay consistently good is the artstyle.

so true, it came out of nowhere, we already have 2 pairings to care about

Index%20(6)
joined Mar 27, 2021

The more I read, the more I hate this new development.
“Sasakoi is doing well but there are no new drama to exploit? Hey use this girl who had nothing going on with her own setting or character and did nothing to contribute to the story for the last 30 chapters and make her in love with her sister! The drama needs to be as sappy as possible to convince the readers that the manga is still good!”
So bullshit, drama of the week type of manga. I don’t even oppose to incest trope within fictional sphere but this new development with Miki-Aki sibling is so bullshit. Lack of substance, lack of build up, lack of screentime, lack of quality in writing characters. The only thing stay consistently good is the artstyle.

so true, it came out of nowhere, we already have 2 pairings to care about

my thing is that sasakoi already has two side pairs we could focus on more, tachimari and hajimomo, both with similar cute and more serious potential respectively like the two previously established pairs, this whole siscon plot feels so forced and annoying

Img_20230402_152744
joined Aug 23, 2022

Imagine that the girl you have a crush tells u that you can't date her because she's in love with her sister...I think that's a big red flag.

well at least she was honest!

I think Aya was thinking the same and is taking me out that her conclusion after being weirded tf up was 'i can fix her' jsjsjsjsjsjsjs

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

Imagine that the girl you have a crush tells u that you can't date her because she's in love with her sister...I think that's a big red flag.

well at least she was honest!

I think Aya was thinking the same and is taking me out that her conclusion after being weirded tf up was 'i can fix her' jsjsjsjsjsjsjs

I definitely think that's hilarious as well. That's part of why I don't find myself very mad or annoyed by this arc I think, I just think it's overall very funny. Sure it's the weakest arc in the manga in my opinion, but oh well we're through it and moving on to hopefully better things lol

Eterna%20rinebow%20small
joined Oct 20, 2017

Meanwhile here I am, enjoying basically every chapter whether it's sloppy melodrama or a fluffy date. Unbothered, moisturized, in my lane, flourishing, etc. After 11 volumes of this series over 5 years, it seems pretty clear to me that either the author or the majority of Yuri Hime readers filling out the surveys have a preference for sloppy and at times ridiculous melodrama and it's not going to go away.

Imagine that the girl you have a crush tells u that you can't date her because she's in love with her sister...I think that's a big red flag.

I think girls who are just kind of weird deserve a chance at love too. It's not like Miki has shown any tendency for abusive behavior, lying, cheating, or anything else. The fact that she told Aya about it, despite how ashamed she is of it, is actually pretty mature and a good sign if anything.

Honestly, the constant finger wagging about the entirely one-sided incestuous feelings, which the character clearly wants to get over, is kind of getting old in general. I didn't want to say anything when it was first revealed because everyone is entitled to be shocked, but it's starting to feel like this is the audience's new chew toy after "Shiho's sins" became less relevant. Squeak, squeak, squeak.

last edited at Apr 27, 2025 3:05PM

Img_20230402_152744
joined Aug 23, 2022

Meanwhile here I am, enjoying basically every chapter whether it's sloppy melodrama or a fluffy date. Unbothered, moisturized, in my lane, flourishing, etc. After 11 volumes of this series over 5 years, it seems pretty clear to me that either the author or the majority of Yuri Hime readers filling out the surveys have a preference for sloppy and at times ridiculous melodrama and it's not going to go away.

Imagine that the girl you have a crush tells u that you can't date her because she's in love with her sister...I think that's a big red flag.

I think girls who are just kind of weird deserve a chance at love too. It's not like Miki has shown any tendency for abusive behavior, lying, cheating, or anything else. The fact that she told Aya about it, despite how ashamed she is of it, is actually pretty mature and a good sign if anything.

Honestly, the constant finger wagging about the entirely one-sided incestuous feelings, which the character clearly wants to get over, is kind of getting old in general. I didn't want to say anything when it was first revealed because everyone is entitled to be shocked, but it's starting to feel like this is the audience's new chew toy after "Shiho's sins" became less relevant. Squeak, squeak, squeak.

Incest is bad, incest is weird, incest shouldn't exist even if is one side secret attraction for your sister.
Let's not have this debate, please.

Also it was so unnecessary, like if author wanted to have a one sided dramatic and problematic love arc involving sisters you had Hajime, Momoka and the deceased sister/ex girlfriend right there...or if they wanted to explore Miki's character through love, why don't make best friend doomed yuri...why incest.

Screenshot%202024-08-04%20044759
joined Jun 21, 2021

Meanwhile here I am, enjoying basically every chapter whether it's sloppy melodrama or a fluffy date. Unbothered, moisturized, in my lane, flourishing, etc.

So with you on this one, I'm having a grand ol' time with this series

Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

Meanwhile here I am, enjoying basically every chapter whether it's sloppy melodrama or a fluffy date. Unbothered, moisturized, in my lane, flourishing, etc.

So with you on this one, I'm having a grand ol' time with this series

Very much the same.

Honestly, the constant finger wagging about the entirely one-sided incestuous feelings, which the character clearly wants to get over, is kind of getting old in general.

And this. It would be one thing if she actually acted on these, but seeing how she's trying to let go as well, there really is no reason to be so hard on her...

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

Honestly, the constant finger wagging about the entirely one-sided incestuous feelings, which the character clearly wants to get over, is kind of getting old in general.

And this. It would be one thing if she actually acted on these, but seeing how she's trying to let go as well, there really is no reason to be so hard on her...

Genuinely she deserves kindness and understanding. She's not some kind of inhuman monster and she deserves to be loved. Humans have many different kinds of complicated feelings and thoughts regardless of if they should exist or not, nobody is perfect and being human is a messy weird experience.

joined Dec 31, 2024

Also it was so unnecessary, like if author wanted to have a one sided dramatic and problematic love arc involving sisters you had Hajime, Momoka and the deceased sister/ex girlfriend right there...or if they wanted to explore Miki's character through love, why don't make best friend doomed yuri...why incest.

I kind of hold this opinion too. The whole incest thing, well, is what it is, but it didn't need to be included to explore the themes the author wanted. At the very least back when I started this series I didn't expect to see an incest plotline lol.

Eterna%20rinebow%20small
joined Oct 20, 2017

Incest is bad, incest is weird, incest shouldn't exist even if is one side secret attraction for your sister.
Let's not have this debate, please.

Someone saying they are bored of hearing the same couple of sentences repeated over and over, month after month, is not the same as disagreeing with the content of the sentences. If someone started to spam this thread with "vaccines work" and "5g is harmless", I would find it annoying, but not because I don't believe in vaccines or because I'm a 5G truther. In the same manner, commenting on the sheer volume of complaints that Miki Is A Disgusting Siscon, does not constitute an attempt at defending 'incest', or an invitation to debate. I hope I managed to clarify that for you.

Ah, and of course saying that Miki deserves love and kindness also does not constitute a defense of 'incest'. She has not committed any crime, and there is no reason to assume her inappropriate feelings for her sister (which she wants to get over) make her any more dangerous to Aya than the average girl from their school is.

last edited at Apr 27, 2025 11:11PM

Fate_grand_order_medb_tongue_out_good
joined Feb 24, 2015

I'm tired of seeing incest as a trope in manga/anime in general. I can't tell if it's always just for melodrama, or if authors/editors feel like it's a necessary addition to some stories. I don't care if it's Miki or some other character I'm just sick and tired of seeing it. It only tanks my opinion of a character/author/series.

To reply you must either login or sign up.