Forum › Posts by erana

erana
joined Jul 8, 2019

You actually cannot force someone to seek help. You cannot call the professionals to take the person to the ward (or sectioned) unless the person harming herself or planing to harm others.

"Take to the ward".
Getting help is no longer taking one to straightjackets. We're in the XXI century, not the XIX. You have the "I" on the wrong side of the second "X". Which belief is one of the reasons that most hurt the efforts to give help to those who need it. Instead of hamfisted attempts to force one to get help,

I've found that plainly stating to the one in need of help that those who think that way,s if we we're in the XIX century, are just plain wrong, that "just like physical health goes from a headache to brain cancer, and believing everyone who goes to the doc is a terminal patient beyond salvation, mental health is NOT just 'being crazy'", and "you know that better than the ones who think so, don't you?". WIth that argument (or similar ones) I've actually managed to get several of the people of my bitter experience to seek help. Severe depressions. Plural. One case of schizophrenia. Teenagers (plural) whose parents refused to beliee ADHD or ASD were real things... Others, I've had no success. But reallt do you think I should have not tried to give help to he ones that TOOK the help, just because others didn't?

And of the ones nobody (including me) tried, at least one commited suicide. Having a failure to get a loved one to seek help may or may not weight on one's conscience: having a death due to failue to even TRY to help, fuck me, but it does.

This shall be my last comment in this regard. Sorry, but no words ever shall beable to convince me that I sould not have tried. Please DO try if you find that it needs trying.

erana
joined Jul 8, 2019

OMG Kaede is insane, literally.

Yep. I wonder, do we have a tag for that?

joined Jul 8, 2019

One of the few cases where the throuple endng is the only realistic option. I mean, just look at those two idiot's relationship.

erana
joined Jul 8, 2019

Nothing else needs to be said other than Kaede needs professional fucking help. My. fucking. god.

I may NOT be the actual Erana of QFG fame, the one leaving gardens of peace behind her to tend the physical and mental health of the heroes, but I'll be damned if I don't follow up on our post with the obvious (but often unstated) real life lesson:
Everyboy, from bitter experience. If you, or a loved one, need professional help, GET THAT HELP.

last edited at May 8, 2026 2:58PM

erana
joined Jul 8, 2019

I profusely apologize for the double post, but I want to keep this separated from the previous "joke" post:

Certainly comphet has been a major issue throughout this story,

I've made no secret that I like my yuri like I like my Dwarven Fortress FUN: hard-won against difficulty. Winning against the heteronormative character should be something to cheer for, if anything. God knows it is often not the case IRL.
Not trying to convince anyone, just stating the point.

last edited at May 6, 2026 7:40AM

erana
joined Jul 8, 2019

OK, on re-reading, show of hands: how many of you did scream in desperation at your screen "GET THE BLOODY HINT, YOU MORON!!!" at the last page of chapter 18? Because I just did it again.

last edited at May 6, 2026 7:33AM

erana
joined Jul 8, 2019

Regarding the very first chapter of this one... their doubts about what is and isn't marriage..
allow me to quote no other than Eric W. Schwartz.

erana
joined Jul 8, 2019

Mildy curious as to what happened with Tomohiko

He fled from the wedding to join the Shinsengumen in Hakuoki. Plainly.

joined Jul 8, 2019

I'd wish to add, if making more than one post isn't stepping out of line, two tag suggestions - CUSTOM tags, and the works that inpired them.

Insane amounts of title (which was created for I Became a Slave in Another World (pien) and to make matters worse, My Master is a Black-Hearted Elf Queen! (But She’s Super Hot. (note: v. impt.)) I’m Pretty Useless, So I’m Getting Barked At Left, Right, and Centre, but the ORC I’m rooming with is full of good vibes, and the ELF in the Village is pretty cute too. So on the whole, I have to say that I'm actually quite enjoying myself here.)

Insane amounts of scanlators (whih was created for It's Probably Love(?) which featured twenty-three (23) scanlator tags)

I would add other legendary custom tags like Insane amounts of hand-holding or Lots of ruffling, if I were actually positive of which work they were made for. If anyone knows it, feel free to.

last edited at May 4, 2026 6:27PM

erana
joined Jul 8, 2019

Still going strong

Let me tell you, the story of those two reminds me of a personal experience of mine. The experience of casually, not throuh deliberaty gossiping, learning of two stranger's private life; of finding their situation to be cute; of also casually learning years later than they are still together; and of feeling a small pang of joy in it (you know, the whole Bhudist concept of Mudita, or "taking joy in other's happines", thing.

Around two decades ago, a New Year morning, walking on my way home (and yes, that was right next door from my city's quite famous LGTB district. ), I saw two girls of which I couldn't help to notice that all their clothing, attitude, smiles and body language (let alone handholding) screamed "this could be a romantic comedy movie's 'happy ending - she confessed on New Year and got a yes' scene". Of which, at the time I only tought "yep, that's cute", and thougt nothing more of it - beside the aforementioned "this looks like a movie - must be the New Year effect" thing. Yet I've been casually catching glimpses of those two girls (now, considerably older, too) basically every other New Year for two decades, always together, always smiling, always handolding. Movie, sequels, whole franchise :-) Of course each time I see them I can't help to think for a second "good for them!" Why not? Even if I don't even know them.

I'm not interested in Husky and Medley's private life.I'm not even curious about them. I don't keep tabs, I won't try to read their tweets (or whatever the fuck you call them now), I'm not invested in THEM even if I've just suggested this classic comic for featured chapters. But finding that they are still together, decades later, like the two movie-like girls of so many new years above... yep. Mudita moment, right here.

last edited at May 1, 2026 8:00PM

joined Jul 8, 2019

Since Mayuri above has ninja'ed me on "Isn't the moon beautiful?" and "Trying out marriage with my female friend" ... :-D

Series:
Hero-san and Former General-san
Cat maid and Mistress
Sisterism

Artists:
Yoshitomi Akihito
Zanka

and, really, REALLY, let newcomers to yuri learn of the gem of the genre
Husky and Medley

last edited at Apr 30, 2026 5:36PM

joined Jul 8, 2019

god I wish that were me

Just to clarify: you mean the onee-san, to be able to play with the cute doggo, right?

joined Jul 8, 2019

Hate to be the post that breaks the 888 comments, but we REALLY need the mangaka to start answering at least SOME question before piling even more ones onto us. This is not a "the mangaka is not doing a good job" post, it's a "really this is awesome yet it's starting to be a wee bit overwhelming" post.

last edited at Apr 26, 2026 6:15PM

joined Jul 8, 2019

I strongly apologize for the double post, but I don't want to mix this answer about "the actual story" with the previous one about "keeping the characters alive post-story".

Like most fourth-wall-break stories, this was a lot of fun but made no goddamn sense even on its own terms. The k-drama W was a lot like these last few chapters, for instance. I do recommend that show, but you really have to turn off your brain.

Hope this doesn't spoil it for anyone, but the ending just begs for a dark reading. Notice how, as soon as the author is "safe", Tsukino suddenly reverses something she's insisted on the whole time? And then the final strip is a happier version of one that Hinami "herself" drew? Looks to me like the in-comic author desperately trying to give Hinami a happy ending so she'll leave him alone -- and outright sacrificing Tsukino's free will to do it.

Don't think so. Remember that Tsukino reversed on being straight before the author was able to write her doing that reversal. And remember how she HAD previously given actualconsideration of acepting Hinami's propositions. I mentioned it before to be a case of "if it's you it's OK", but the line I just wrote can also work if we move the word "before" to the end it is also a case of Tsukino being OK with Hinami before the end. She did that on her own free will. Among other things, because at the point she did it, there was nobody with the power to make her do anything against her own will; the author was still incapacitated, and Hinami has no power over her outside of their manga world.

joined Jul 8, 2019

awww. the true happy ending we hope for. goodbye Hinami and Tsukino. the holidays and the absurd craziness behind the scenes with the author have come to an end but a new chapter have begun for these two. we will let our minds think and write out our own chapters of what they're up to afterwards.

Yeah, let's. Just remember - how many tales have kept, say, Robin Hood alive for centuries? (or if you want yuri,the Amaterasu / Ama-no-Uzeme ship) Remembered charaters never die.

And they had lots of beautiful babies popping up in manga and anime anywhere!

This. Cameos and sequels also do count.

last edited at Apr 26, 2026 10:58AM

erana
Ouija Board discussion 25 Apr 12:48
joined Jul 8, 2019

OK, then

joined Jul 8, 2019

Am I the only one bothered by the fact that it stopped at 364 and not at 365

You're not the only one. I was surprised at the [END] after chapter 364, it was so close to perfection.

That's because it means the 365th is YOURS to write. And as long as their strory is being witten, they are alive.

last edited at Apr 25, 2026 10:45AM

joined Jul 8, 2019

Delicious "if it's you it's OK".
And this, boys and girls, is why those saying they refuse to read yuri stories with heterosexual characters (like Tsukino) will never know of such glory as the power of the purest kind of love finally wining them over for the glorious, "if it's you it's OK", most epic kind of yuri.
All hail Hinami's dogged perseverance for her love.
Shes batshit crazy, but I'll give her that.

joined Jul 8, 2019

31st will be a blank page with the in-world mangaka's obituary

joined Jul 8, 2019

Lily wants to print this first chapter off and eat it. That was a weapons grade start to a series... ;;

Amen

joined Jul 8, 2019

If yesterday we had the unnamed ex-GF of "A New View of Things" doing a Valeria and coming back fom the dead to save the MC ("Do you want to live forever?"), today we have right here Nina-chan going all Grace Jones doing a full-blown Zula's "Grab her and take her" on Mao-senpai.

That's two days in a row that yuri manga characters choosed to actually DO something instead of following the course of "yuri characters never ever acting upon their feelings" - and they did so by bloody enacting Conan tropes in the name of yuri

[Anvil of Crom intensifies]
That means it's time for a prayer:
Crom, I have never prayed to you before in the Dynasty Scan forums. I have no tongue for it. All that matters is that today (and yesterday), two stood against (the customs of) many. Valor pleases you, so grant me this one request. Grant me YURI! And if you do not listen, to HELL with you!

last edited at Apr 15, 2026 2:38PM

joined Jul 8, 2019

28th of December is also "Dia de los Inocentes" (Spanish version of Fools' Day) - so we can't rule out that she was actively pranking the good Doctor

joined Jul 8, 2019

well, Valeria returned sword in hand asking if Conan wanted to live forever, and ex-GF chan retuned as a moth to apply lesbian physics to rescue the MC. Simple as. It's not sad, it's legendary.

joined Jul 8, 2019

Silly girl. You need to be called Minerva X for that to work

last edited at Apr 12, 2026 8:45PM

joined Jul 8, 2019

waiting for what holidays are 24th an 25th of December instead of Christmas Eve and Christmas, just for amusement value,

One unexpectedly the expected, one to go

And its a twofer