SO this is going to be a 23 chapters series or do we have to boycott?

You meant volumes, right?

A sequel for starters would be nice, though.

Aaaawww why?!
Where is the rest of chapter?
This feels incomplete!

her reactions were so gay i was so surprised there was no confession... or at least a galpal promise to keep doing stuff together...

this was so great tho :'D

This was adorable. Please may it be a sequel.

About the "subtext or yuri" debate, well... Dynasty Scans has nobody to blame but themselves after that not lizard's tag scandall.

you mean that salamander scandal right?
PTSD INTENSIFIES

Either it's been published in a yuri magazine, or the author specifically tagged it yuri.

So Yuri

This is really good for a first chapter.... It IS just the first chapter, right? Right guys...?

This is subtext and should only be tagged as yuri if Hanigare is changed. Boooom!!!!!!!!

Frankly, I've come to decide that DynastyReader's mistagging on stuff like subtext and yuri is part of it's charm.

KOUTA posted:

Aaaawww why?!
Where is the rest of chapter?
This feels incomplete!

Agreed. It was cute and all but it really did feel incomplete.

It was very nice :) I think subtext/yuri boundary stories can be tagged either way depending on the tagger - I only think the yuri tag is required if it is blatant (like they kiss or confess) - if it isn't then I don't mind a subtext tag even if I think it felt stronger than that.

In this story for example at the end it really felt like they were about to realise they loved each other.. I'd bet good money they became a couple not long after this :) But its still ok as subtext since it hasn't gone there yet.

last edited at Jul 10, 2018 3:31PM

This DID feel incomplete! I loved everything about this, but we really do need a follow up story (and complete series with 4+ volumes plz). I want more!

I think the repeated image of the girl blushing while having her hand held, along with the tone of the rest of the story, is main text, not subtext, earning the yuri tag.

last edited at Jul 10, 2018 4:41PM

The girl with the single ponytail reminds me of Honoka Kousaka.

wait wait wait that’s it???? I need more supportive girlfriends-to-be come on

How about we just shoot both the yuri and subtext tags and everything is Gal Pals now?
There constant debates over

How about we just shoot both the yuri and subtext tags and everything is Gal Pals now?
There constant debates over

there is no discussion of sorts, it's tagging and their standards to assume one with underlying tones it's yuri and others with same underlying tones it's subtext (Hanigare????)

Although yes we didn't get a confession I thought that was such a great place to end the story, now if we could just have the same but from the other girls perspective this would be perfect!

They held hands. It's Yuri

S is for Story (S)

How about we just shoot both the yuri and subtext tags and everything is Gal Pals now?
There constant debates over

there is no discussion of sorts, it's tagging and their standards to assume one with underlying tones it's yuri and others with same underlying tones it's subtext (Hanigare????)

Idk man, everything seems to fit Gal Pals perfectly fine.

SO this is going to be a 23 chapters series or do we have to boycott?

Super Friends

I don't know, that seems like a bit of a Stretch to me.

S is for Story (S)

I like that. The "S" in "Class S" stands for story!

Okey. It's not yuri or subtext. It's girlship.

How about we just shoot both the yuri and subtext tags and everything is Gal Pals now?
There constant debates over

We should've just kept all the April Fool's joke tags. Lots of Friendship

SO this is going to be a 23 chapters series or do we have to boycott?

Super Friends

I don't know, that seems like a bit of a Stretch to me.

S is for Story (S)

I like that. The "S" in "Class S" stands for story!

Okey. It's not yuri or subtext. It's girlship.

How about we just shoot both the yuri and subtext tags and everything is Gal Pals now?
There constant debates over

We should've just kept all the April Fool's joke tags. Lots of Friendship

Class Story, Girlship and Lots of Friendship. I'm liking these new and innovative tag ideas.

As someone who plays the violin, this is a giant load of (cute) BS lol

I'll never not like QuietxGenki couples. Especially if its the quiet ones who are making the Genkis come to realize their gayness. Double points if the former themselves are oblivious while they are doing it. So this oneshot gets a gold star. Who cares if its not explicit, its just the right amount of fuzz

The lizard scandal? You mean the Stretch scandal, right? 'Cause hot damn, this doesn't come close to Stretch.