Forum › Howling Song for Husky Girl discussion

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

Oh no she has anime mom disease!

Img_20201116_114246_2-min_50-min%20(1)
joined Oct 14, 2014

Not the Japanese cold! Goodbye mother, you weren't even a threshold guardian.

I seriously think this would slap as an anime but would require way more resources than Crunchyroll would commit to it without first seeing a licensed edition sell like hotcakes (you know what to do, Yen Press/Seven Seas!)

joined Aug 21, 2017

bruh

In%20your%20butt
joined Jun 21, 2021

i'm still holding out hope that the mom doesn't get an easy pass. Kashikaze didn't try to redeem the shitty mom In 'Lonely Girl' either, so there's precedent at least.

The health emergency did feel weirdly sudden though

B2ca1c5e82d763703f6d4dc2ab77c6ff
joined Jan 9, 2026

"A song for you to howl"

Say that again?

Hotarusquibbly
joined Feb 12, 2025

No Miyuki you just have to say "bless you" and it will fix her dw abt it

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

i'm still holding out hope that the mom doesn't get an easy pass. Kashikaze didn't try to redeem the shitty mom In 'Lonely Girl' either, so there's precedent at least.

The health emergency did feel weirdly sudden though

Yeah...I've been really enjoying this series so far, even though it can be a bit simple I love the main duo, but god the mom about to reveal something only to suddenly be taken by the plot disease that silences you when you're about to say something important...is the kind of writing that really frustrates me.

Subaru
joined Jul 31, 2019

hair ball

053
joined Jun 8, 2022

Ah yes. 'I'mabouttodieandyouhavetoforgivemeoryou'reabadperson-itis'. Always fun to see, rather than people having to own up to their past actions. Or maybe I'm getting ahead of myself and this is just a one-off, induced by overwork or something. We can but hope.

Annotation%202020-07-02%20193122
joined Apr 19, 2018

The cheap cop-out gets cheaper

543633_50
joined Sep 10, 2022

Ah yes. 'I'mabouttodieandyouhavetoforgivemeoryou'reabadperson-itis'. Always fun to see, rather than people having to own up to their past actions. Or maybe I'm getting ahead of myself and this is just a one-off, induced by overwork or something. We can but hope.

I think she'll still own up, at least verbally. The real effect of stuff like this feels like generating as much quick empathy from the readers as possible. It's still a bit cheap because it's so abrupt, unless I'm forgetting hints that she's been very sick?

last edited at Oct 19, 2026 9:00AM

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

Ah yes. 'I'mabouttodieandyouhavetoforgivemeoryou'reabadperson-itis'. Always fun to see, rather than people having to own up to their past actions. Or maybe I'm getting ahead of myself and this is just a one-off, induced by overwork or something. We can but hope.

I think she'll still own up, at least verbally. The real effect of stuff like this feels like generating as much quick empathy from the readers as possible. It's still a bit cheap because it's so abrupt, unless I'm forgetting hints that she's been very sick?

I don't think there's been any hints lol

Chinchilla
joined Apr 28, 2022

I really continue to dislike her mom. She mentioned that Yuu is her daughter but has to point out that she didn't expect her to show up etc like she again thought hse contributed NOTHING.

I knew they were just gonna try and brush what her mom did off with an apology. I get now their is something wrong with her but she shouldn't just be forgiven so easily. Call me heartless with the way it ended I just don't feel Yuu should just forgive her all of a sudden.

Beatorokken
joined Feb 23, 2014

Wow it's exactly as bad as I thought it'd be!
I'm only not dropping this because the main pair is still very cute.

Tumblr_6092d594b3a92296a4d35bac1b1a474c_c2d1131f_400
joined Apr 4, 2022

guess thats that.
I wanted Haru's side of the reunion to be a little longer tho

Chinchilla
joined Apr 28, 2022

...So we just forgive her because she has cancer and said I'm sorry?

Yeah no. This was such a copout they really did brush off her leaving with a lame excuse like I knew they would. Yuu just instantly forgives her and her moms lame excuse about "I left my daughter behind so she wouldn't get jealous of her younger sister" That's the biggest load of bullshit I think I've ever heard.

And then you have her actually remembering Haru as a child and just gliding past that like it was nothing as well when that was the entire start of why Haru wanted to start singing in the first place..

This entire plot point was so so so stupid. I will just continue to dislike their mom from now this didn't redeem her AT ALL.

I love Haru and Yuu enough to keep reading this or I might have dropped it after this crap.

last edited at Nov 18, 2026 1:27PM

In%20your%20butt
joined Jun 21, 2021

if they really leave it at that then that's pretty bad. but Yuu hasn't forgiven her yet. She just said "don't die yet". I don't think that quite counts as reconciliation.

Just holding out hope that this isn't already the resolution to the whole shitty parent debacle.

last edited at Nov 18, 2026 1:23PM

Img_1133
joined Mar 24, 2025

I'm sorry, where's the part where they actually forgive her? What I saw was "why didn't you tell your daughters anything? You don't deserve to die, you have to make up for this by actually being in their lives for once."

Like Haru calls out her excuse immediately, and it's not like Yuu wants her mother to die or anything like that, nor does she say she understands or forgives her.

Sumatrapdf_i4v2vg0jsu
joined Jul 8, 2025

YOU DON'T RIP THIS OUT OF YOUR ARM LIKE THAT OLD LADY, NUH HUH

Also you have done a lot of bad things that I don't forgive you and nobody in this room should forgive you like that

Oh hey debut concert :D

Mari%20-%20gf
joined Apr 1, 2015

Small typo on page 19:
So eve while -> So even while

joined Jan 4, 2025

Haven't even read the latest chapter yet because apparently I stopped reading partway through the previous chapter. Didn't remember doing that but it makes sense because the entire audition felt so insanely rushed and sauceless that I couldn't really think anything other than "guess this was cancelled".

Clicking on the new chapter and being confused and then learning that I didn't actually finish the previous chapter and it actually already has them trivially win the audition (I thought it would take at least another chapter) and has the mom randomly collapse is like, wow, ok, guess I have even less interest now than when I stopped reading mid-chapter because that's even more rushed than I already thought. I'm gonna let it build up a few chapters ig, either it ends in a few or if not it'll hopefully go back to normal writing after this arc is over and I don't have to wait for it.

Purple Library Guy
Kare%20kano%20joker
joined Mar 3, 2013

Well, this sure isn't afraid of dishing up the melodrama, huh?

joined Nov 6, 2021

I'm sorry, where's the part where they actually forgive her? What I saw was "why didn't you tell your daughters anything? You don't deserve to die, you have to make up for this by actually being in their lives for once."

Like Haru calls out her excuse immediately, and it's not like Yuu wants her mother to die or anything like that, nor does she say she understands or forgives her.

For some odd reason people think caring enough to not want her to die means she's suddenly forgiven, which is dumb logic.

Prprcharlotte_8
joined Apr 1, 2013

I am surprised at how disappointed I am that the mother was "nice all along".

Neneko_11zon
joined Dec 21, 2025

Small typo on page 19:
So eve while -> So even while

Thank youu! Fixed!

To reply you must either login or sign up.