Forum › The Guy She Was Interested in Wasn't a Guy At All discussion

Hanasakukawaii_small
joined Mar 20, 2014

Mitsuki you're literally dating--it's okay to grin about your girlfriend ya doof!

Are they dating though? They sure don't act like it.

1453e55cc3ab545974cae651c20afaf3
joined May 28, 2021

Mitsuki you're literally dating--it's okay to grin about your girlfriend ya doof!

Are they dating though? They sure don't act like it.

We didn't get a '' will you'' moment yet, but they're definitely acting like a couple. They might be taking their time I guess, with the exams coming up and all that.

Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

Just love.

BeanBeanKingdom
Ms_icon
joined Nov 3, 2018

Are they dating though? They sure don't act like it.

You think they just casually kiss?

Img_1317
joined Jan 19, 2015

scrolling through pictures of gf while giggling and grinning and heehee-ing... so real

ancientquicksand
Happiness%20rides%20a%20broomstick%20-%20ch.14%20-%2019_1_1.1
joined Nov 1, 2024

This is such a cute panel!!! ^_^ Especially with the detail of Mitsuki's nail design being painted by Aya, really lovely touch!
https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/the_guy_she_was_interested_in_wasnt_a_guy_at_all_ch130#4

I was caught up looking at all the photos and somehow totally missed that! Thanks for pointing it out.

joined Aug 21, 2023

Are they dating though? They sure don't act like it.

You think they just casually kiss?

What's a few casual kisses between homies?

last edited at Jun 17, 2025 12:42PM

91b
joined Aug 12, 2019

Are they dating though? They sure don't act like it.

You think they just casually kiss?

What a few casual kisses between homies?

don't forget. they did hold hands together.

Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

Mitsuki you're literally dating--it's okay to grin about your girlfriend ya doof!

Are they dating though? They sure don't act like it.

We didn't get a '' will you'' moment yet, but they're definitely acting like a couple. They might be taking their time I guess, with the exams coming up and all that.

They were literally making out during an at home date like 4 chapters ago.

joined Jan 14, 2020

Mitsuki you're literally dating--it's okay to grin about your girlfriend ya doof!

Are they dating though? They sure don't act like it.

https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/the_guy_she_was_interested_in_wasnt_a_guy_at_all_ch126#2 and next page.

kuroyurihime00
Ebk63ajwkaeu2_4_1
joined Aug 1, 2020

I'm so excited for how the song is gonna turn out
(^-^)

last edited at Jun 15, 2025 9:16PM

Img_5712
joined Jan 3, 2022

Mitsuki you're literally dating--it's okay to grin about your girlfriend ya doof!

Are they dating though? They sure don't act like it.

We didn't get a '' will you'' moment yet, but they're definitely acting like a couple. They might be taking their time I guess, with the exams coming up and all that.

They were literally making out during an at home date like 4 chapters ago.

Which makes it even weirder why Mitsuki is calling herself gross— for all we know, they kissed at prom, then went back to the group to hang out and dance (without talking), and whenever they hang together 1 on 1, they dont really seem to have any convos on what “they” are.

I mean, a few chapters after the prom, Aya talks about how a week passed since they kissed and they were meeting for the first time since then, and they were awkward at first (which makes it fr seem like after they got done kissing, they checked their phones and left without having a convo)

With how Mitsuki talks here, “i really do like you…” it doesn’t seem like they’re dating at that point

Also, obviously, they’re still referring to each other on a first name basis— even here instead of deciding to call Aya by her first name, she instead picks her mom (And Aya obvi wanted to be the one on a first name basis with Mitsuki, yet she hasn’t voiced that yet?)

And in this chapter Mitsuki basically admits that they been smooching on a regular basis

And yet, despite that, Aya is clearly insecure/doubting her self worth (or something along those lines, the right words are escaping me atm) and idk, if they had made it clear what “they” are, she might’ve fallen back on that? Idk maybe thats a mute point—

Oh, and even in their thoughts/POV, do they refer to each other as “my girl/girlfriend” or anyway thats different from how they thought of each other before the kiss + when the new girl (i forgot her name) said that Mitsuki was talking about Aya’s music and talks about her all the time, she was like “for real? For really real?” Like, genuine shock and stuff— but if they had made it clear they were dating, she wouldnt be so surprised— an “oh, really?” Or smthn… idk i just feel like the reaction is a bit tooooo much; like they’re not in the dating phase, but the “they have a crush on each other but haven’t said anything yet” phase

All that yapping to say;

It seems like they didnt make things clear to each other; even IF they kissed, that doesn’t necessarily mean they know or even think they’re dating— and knowing FOR SURE is WAYYYYYYYYY better than just assuming and having some doubt— and they really are treating each other the exact same as how they used to, them kissing regularly being the only thing thats different, which, them acting the same wouldnt be an issue if they made it clear they’re dating, but because they didnt have the talk yet, they’re being intimate like that while “still friends” (if that makes sense?)

Kissing is fine, but thinking about her and smiling makes her gross? Mitsuki’s thoughts imo paint the picture that they haven’t made things clear yet, and are in a grey area

joined Apr 2, 2023

I think you're giving way too much weight to the word "gross" in the context of what was going on. Mitsuki is just not used to getting overwhelmed with these kinds of feelings and caught it spilling out visibly. It's likely a face she's not used to seeing on herself often. She's not actually grossed out at anything she's done with Aya or looking at those photos. She's actually getting creatively wound up by thinking about it all.

Aya has shown being insecure about fitting in with Mitsuki's family who all are fluent in English so she's throwing herself into English studies. She's also not creative in the way Mitsuki is and Hime and Narita have their own things too. She's self-imposed goals for herself that she's not meeting and is missing out on having fun in her senior year which is making her feel an artificial distance growing. It's all self inflicted, but not that unusual when you're at an age where everyone is deciding what to do with their lives and some of them are more outwardly talented in something you rank highly. In this case English and music.

Yuibless
joined Jan 30, 2017

Ah yes, an "unseen force". It wasn't all of their friends trying to get these idiots to finally hook up.

Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

I think you're giving way too much weight to the word "gross" in the context of what was going on. Mitsuki is just not used to getting overwhelmed with these kinds of feelings and caught it spilling out visibly. It's likely a face she's not used to seeing on herself often. She's not actually grossed out at anything she's done with Aya or looking at those photos. She's actually getting creatively wound up by thinking about it all.

Aya has shown being insecure about fitting in with Mitsuki's family who all are fluent in English so she's throwing herself into English studies. She's also not creative in the way Mitsuki is and Hime and Narita have their own things too. She's self-imposed goals for herself that she's not meeting and is missing out on having fun in her senior year which is making her feel an artificial distance growing. It's all self inflicted, but not that unusual when you're at an age where everyone is deciding what to do with their lives and some of them are more outwardly talented in something you rank highly. In this case English and music.

Yeah, it seems like they're really overthinking things.

Though do we know if they're third-years? I thought they were second-years for some reason.

Img_5712
joined Jan 3, 2022

I think you're giving way too much weight to the word "gross" in the context of what was going on. Mitsuki is just not used to getting overwhelmed with these kinds of feelings and caught it spilling out visibly. It's likely a face she's not used to seeing on herself often. She's not actually grossed out at anything she's done with Aya or looking at those photos. She's actually getting creatively wound up by thinking about it all.

Aya has shown being insecure about fitting in with Mitsuki's family who all are fluent in English so she's throwing herself into English studies. She's also not creative in the way Mitsuki is and Hime and Narita have their own things too. She's self-imposed goals for herself that she's not meeting and is missing out on having fun in her senior year which is making her feel an artificial distance growing. It's all self inflicted, but not that unusual when you're at an age where everyone is deciding what to do with their lives and some of them are more outwardly talented in something you rank highly. In this case English and music.

Yeah, it seems like they're really overthinking things.

Though do we know if they're third-years? I thought they were second-years for some reason.

they’re seniors in high school so prolly?

Tho good points were made, I STILL think them not actually communicating clearly to each other that they’re dating is gonna be a plot point

BeanBeanKingdom
Ms_icon
joined Nov 3, 2018

Yes, the series started when they were second years and they moved on to the third.

Kirin-kun Uploader
Oip
Rehashed Scans
joined Mar 21, 2021

The characters profiles state that they were 17 at the start of the story;

And it's explicitly said that they're now 3rd years in chapter 41.

People have goldfish memory or what?

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

The characters profiles state that they were 17 at the start of the story;

And it's explicitly said that they're now 3rd years in chapter 41.

People have goldfish memory or what?

Chapter 41 was 2 years ago, I barely remember a lot of things that happened 1 year ago lmao

Hell with this year alone I'm reminded of the Tintin meme I recently saw, It's been one hell of a year, Captain It's Only June. Which I feel in my soul and my bones.

Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

I mean, this very page has already demonstrated that people don't even remember what happened 4 chapters ago...

Surprise(2)
joined Jun 17, 2021

Mitsuki you're literally dating--it's okay to grin about your girlfriend ya doof!

Are they dating though? They sure don't act like it.

All of the other characters are treating them like they're dating, so I have no idea why the comments are doubting it, you get this far into a story that has to be subtle because there are only a few pages per chapter, and you want them to waste time going "wait are we dating?" "yes, we're dating".

They're dating.

To reply you must either login or sign up.