@Moedred: Fate canon and not canon kind of becomes trivial with the various timelines, all the in universe rule breaking, and how an anime adaption can depict something that's exclusive to it. Maybe Gudako isn't canon in that one anime, but for me she's canon to my timeline and play-through of the game, especially as I experience the exclusive CGs made for her. Plus she's canon to the Shimosa manga as another example. So I wouldn't say what one anime adaption depicts is the end all be all as the "true" canon, especially with how the anime are hit or miss in some ways. Plus Extra is weird, and the anime is...very weird lol
Also I'm not you're saying you're this type of person or anything, just that I dislike the canon argument overall because I've also seen some incel guys on social media try to argue that Gudako isn't canon, and how the game is about Gudao and his girls. To which I just cringe, groan.
@ObsessiveFingerLicker: Carnival is a comedy series, so I don't count it as a serious adaption. The couple of FGO comedy episodes Gudako shows up in is a short FGO Carnival lol