Forum › The Guy She Was Interested in Wasn't a Guy At All discussion

Ezgif.com-gif-maker%20(1)
joined Jun 6, 2020

Considering the title and their thoughts, I'm assuming a certain girl spent the whole summer like 'fuck, am I gay?'

joined Mar 15, 2015

Looking forward to the series ending in chapter 20 with understanding smiles and abundant levels of (future, not shown) friendship.

Don't jinx it plsss, i need at least 50 more chapters of that sweet, delicious gay panic (and subsequent flirting and being an adorable idiot couple)

I'm personally hoping that the manga is about a third of the way through. I'd like to see them talk things through, develop a friendship and eventually become lovers. Ending in Chapter 20 isn't nearly long enough to resolve this current situation, considering how short the chapters are.

I'm also on the side that believes that Mitsuki had no obligation to tell Aya. Perhaps she should if they were to become closer, but as it stands now, they're merely classmates who happen to be acquainted by chance outside of school, so there's no need to be anything more than that if Mitsuki doesn't want to be. Since Aya didn't make her feelings clear, nor did she even let on that she knows Mitsuki is the record store clerk, Mitsuki has no way of knowing what's going on in Aya''s head.

Purple Library Guy
Kare%20kano%20joker
joined Mar 3, 2013

I’m gonna say meh on that.. there are tons of instances where people, even young people get interested in something from a begone era… Like jazz or classical or ska… plus for the last 5-10 year’s you’d see teens in the us wearing “vintage” themed tshirts spattered with Beatles, Led Zeppelin and AC/DC logos… also the ironic part of this in connection to grunge retro is grunge and a lot of the music of the first half of the 90s was filled with retro throwbacks.. grunge is just punk mixed with 70s heavy rock like Black Sabbath, Blue cheer and Death, then when grunge died you had a swing fad followed by a 2nd ska revival and then you had the whole Brit pop thing which was again rooted in 60s and 70s stuff.. also.. aerosmith was huge at that time…. My guess because of the retro love mixed in the current bands of that time like the black crows and G&R (who sound like aerosmith most of the time anyway).. things cycle around over and over again..

I agree.

I'm not sure if I said this before, but it seems like an odd objection given that clearly the MANGAKA is interested enough in that kind of music to put people who like it in their story, and the MANGAKA seems to be exactly the kind of person it's been objected it's implausible that they could be into that music. In short, if the mangaka can like it, so could the characters--so not only is it plausible, we have an actual real-world example.

last edited at Sep 4, 2022 1:24PM

St1
joined Feb 17, 2013

Considering the title and their thoughts, I'm assuming a certain girl spent the whole summer like 'fuck, am I gay?'

No? She spent the whole summer fuming and avoiding Mitsuki who she was mad and upset with.
THAT is the only thing I got clearly. And Now it seems she's had enough of being mad and wants to get over it- presumably to just friendship at first.

The title is just refering to she knows mitsuki is that boy- but she didnt bring it up and neither did mitsuki

last edited at Sep 4, 2022 2:31PM

F4x-3lwx0aa0tcu31
joined Apr 20, 2013

Also! We Got Blink 182 and Red Hot chilli Pepers this time around!

georgeoswalddannyson
joined Aug 21, 2019

Kind of a weird chapter, feels like there's a page of transition missing

43353v3
joined Jun 7, 2020

^ I agree.

Mitsuki_25_1_40
joined May 7, 2022

Considering the title and their thoughts, I'm assuming a certain girl spent the whole summer like 'fuck, am I gay?'

Both did, probably.

Kind of a weird chapter, feels like there's a page of transition missing

Downsides of being a twitter short

Ugh, enough of The Discourse. I want more aesthetic talk and critical analysis on the level of Green777's take on Jerkbag (which was excellent and literally the original reason I made this account). There's already so much damn drama in the story itself—drama hogs, are you not engorged??

Here, more meat for you (anything to get you to shut up and stop inserting your own social hang ups with others' genders in someone else's story):

  1. You have a time machine. You've been sent back to the early 2000s. Do you warn Muse that they're going to turn their 2022 album into a NFT, or....do you just....take the shot?

  2. Why hasn't anyone created fan art of our lovely, two, young lesbians in other genre styles?? I want to see death metal aus, disco aus, math rock, anythiiiiing!!

  3. Why the frick hasn't Phoenix released an album in so long?! Also, where y'all get new music from? Birp! on yt has been my interest lately.

  4. Praise be our art and aesthetics goddess, Agu. (This is not a topic of debate.)

  5. Why didn't Smashing Pumpkins get back together with D'Arcy instead of Billy?? Like damn, he's been transphobe trash for a while.

  6. Freebie. Hit us with a new-to-you song you just found this week. I found this today: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IGkemcoNcJ0

last edited at Sep 4, 2022 2:51PM by

Jas
joined Aug 26, 2014

Love this series to pieces, but the small uploads are very frustrating/ annoying. I’d rather wait longer and have a full chapter uploaded

F4x-3lwx0aa0tcu31
joined Apr 20, 2013

Sadistic-Demon posted:

Love this series to pieces, but the small uploads are very frustrating/ annoying. I’d rather wait longer and have a full chapter uploaded

I mean that's entirely up to you, you can come back monthly and have "enough" content, you just need to control yourself.

joined Feb 1, 2021
  1. You have a time machine. You've been sent back to the early 2000s. Do you warn Muse that they're going to turn their 2022 album into a NFT, or....do you just....take the shot?

I would try to warn the world about NFTs, and about Donald Trump becoming president, and about the Chicago Cubs winning the World Series, but no one would believe me as all these things would sound too ridiculous to be true. So, to hell with it, let's go back to 1936 and try killing Hitler instead.

In%20your%20butt
joined Jun 21, 2021

Love this series to pieces, but the small uploads are very frustrating/ annoying. I’d rather wait longer and have a full chapter uploaded

Honestly, we should be happy that we do get 4 pages of this quality and polish p much every week. That's a lot of work.

Yuu
joined Mar 28, 2015

And in five years, they will become ROOMMATES!

Utena%20rose%20white%20200x200
joined Mar 28, 2014

I didn't understand the first couple of bubbles on the first page. Who's speaking about who, in what context?
Do I read correctly from those that Aya didn't talk to Mitsuki at all throughout the vacation (ch.19 p2) but she kept meeting/talking to Onii-san? Otherwise this doesn't compute with me at all. I meah how else would Aya holler about not wanting to go to school tomorrow?

last edited at Sep 4, 2022 3:45PM

joined Nov 28, 2011

Kind of a weird chapter, feels like there's a page of transition missing

Page? Felt more like an entire chapter was missing

Sena
joined Jun 27, 2017

The time skip ... really doesn't help the coherence of that chapter. I don't know. Maybe it's meta, like "feel the disjointed feelings of the two girls as a reader", that sorta thing ;)

Userpic-128-white
joined Jul 21, 2015

The translation of the latest chapter title feels EXTREMELY liberal to me. Is that really the vibe of what the author meant? I'm not seeing it

X2(edited)2
joined Jan 2, 2022

People who are saying it ending in chapter 20, that's a joke, right? The author hasn't said anything about it ending, right? Please no.

Yuu
joined Mar 28, 2015

kaelynn posted:

The translation of the latest chapter title feels EXTREMELY liberal to me. Is that really the vibe of what the author meant? I'm not seeing it

And what's your take, o mighty translator?

joined Apr 16, 2022

I personally think the chapter title translation is extremely clever, definitely a lot more fun than a literal translation ("A new semester for those who can't ask") would be.

smellsliketeenspirit
Screen%20shot%202022-07-04%20at%206.37.52%20pm
joined May 29, 2022

Kind of a weird chapter, feels like there's a page of transition missing

Page? Felt more like an entire chapter was missing

Same. How did we get from the beginning of summer break and planning for the cultural festival to awkward silence and school starting again. There needs to be more explanation and substance.

Avatar92pg
joined Dec 13, 2020

When did Aya holler about not wanting to go to school tomorrow?
I must have missed one of the previous releases. Chapter and page plz?

joined Sep 12, 2021

The translation of the latest chapter title feels EXTREMELY liberal to me. Is that really the vibe of what the author meant? I'm not seeing it

I think it works. It at least keeps the part about not asking which was definitely in the Japanese title.

Yuu
joined Mar 28, 2015

The translation of the title is "liberal" (as in, not literal), but I also think it's a clever double meaning by the translator: Aya doesn't ask, Mitsuki doesn't tell.

Plus a reference to the "Don't Ask, Don't tell" policy that used to be in effect in the US army for gay people.

So, it works really well actually.

last edited at Sep 4, 2022 5:45PM

To reply you must either login or sign up.