Forum › Luminous=Blue discussion

joined Jul 26, 2019

And a yuri with a dull end one more!!!!!
Final totally rush...New deception after rabbit and tsurezure biyori…cupidon is on earth ….

7056534
joined May 7, 2017

In her previous tweet, Iwami said the sales weren't good

I wonder if all that drama route is one of the motives leading to this story's demise, good to see I'm not the only fed up with cheap crappy drama, can't say I feel bad since it was such sweet start ... hope lessons have been learned from this

Eivhbyw
joined Aug 26, 2018

In her previous tweet, Iwami said the sales weren't good

I wonder if all that drama route is one of the motives leading to this story's demise, good to see I'm not the only fed up with cheap crappy drama, can't say I feel bad since it was such sweet start ... hope lessons have been learned from this

I think you fail to understand how this works. It's the opposite. The start of this was too slow and people didn't get drawn in. Drama is what usually makes series gain more attention and sales (e.g. Citrus). This one turned up the pace a little too late.

The only thing anyone will learn from this is to add more drama. Whoops.

Avatar
joined Oct 22, 2018

The only thing anyone will learn from this is to add more drama. Whoops.

Mervuedammit.

shadesofgreymoon
Swxj4ro
joined Jun 5, 2016

Ugh, harem/triad ending. This series deserved better.

last edited at Sep 18, 2019 3:53AM

joined May 12, 2019

For the raws doesn't seems like a tried ending, ror me Kou is just a friend supporting their relationship, so she is in the marriage, like a friend not a bride

last edited at Sep 18, 2019 10:05AM by Nezchan

46-75
joined Jun 25, 2019

mind use spoiler please. Btw i never seen brides both kiss a "friend" at their marriage while holding the flower.By what i gather from the chapter, it's a polyamory ending

last edited at Sep 18, 2019 6:16AM

joined Jul 26, 2019

I liked the atmosphere and the drawings of this manga but with hindsight, the plot with néné was not at all realistic... no excuse can justify turning your back on your girlfriend for a smile.... people didn't have to hold onto that.
For the drama side there were a lot of them in this one so it was not what was missing and for a yuri to work is not necessary like the demonstration bloom into you or whispering you a love song...

Eivhbyw
joined Aug 26, 2018

For the drama side there were a lot of them in this one so it was not what was missing and for a yuri to work is not necessary like the demonstration bloom into you or whispering you a love song...

The beginning was too slow. I didn't say there was no drama at all. And Bloom Into You has plenty of drama...

joined May 12, 2019

mind use spoiler please. Btw i never seen brides both kiss a "friend" at their marriage while holding the flower.By what i gather from the chapter, it's a polyamory ending

/ u are right, I just noticed the 3 rings. What a lame ending, it would he better if it were a 2 ending, even if it was not Nene x Amane. So fucking rushed and the art it's so good, such a shame an ending like that

last edited at Sep 19, 2019 12:50PM

46-75
joined Jun 25, 2019

mind use spoiler please. Btw i never seen brides both kiss a "friend" at their marriage while holding the flower.By what i gather from the chapter, it's a polyamory ending

/ u are right, I just noticed the 3 rings. What a lame ending, it would he better if it were a 2 ending, even if it was not Nene x Amane. So fucking rushed and the art it's so good, such a shame an ending like that

Funny enough i didn't spotted the rings before you say it. I didn't say i hate this end, it's just really unexpected.

Yuu
joined Mar 28, 2015

At least author didn't pull a Happy End because their series was axed.

Avatar
joined Oct 22, 2018

At least author didn't pull a Happy End because their series was axed.

Given this and several similar comments here I've encountered over the last 11 months, I'm led to believe that I'm lucky that I haven't read "Happy End"...?

shadesofgreymoon
Swxj4ro
joined Jun 5, 2016

At least author didn't pull a Happy End because their series was axed.

Given this and several similar comments here I've encountered over the last 11 months, I'm led to believe that I'm lucky that I haven't read "Happy End"...?

Happy End was an incest story between two sisters that had one sister suddenly marry a returning male childhood friend rather than stay with her sister like they'd promised pretty much all their lives. Predictably, people here were pretty bitter and salty...

Avatar
joined Oct 22, 2018

At least author didn't pull a Happy End because their series was axed.

Given this and several similar comments here I've encountered over the last 11 months, I'm led to believe that I'm lucky that I haven't read "Happy End"...?

Happy End was an incest story between two sisters that had one sister suddenly marry a returning male childhood friend rather than stay with her sister like they'd promised pretty much all their lives. Predictably, people here were pretty bitter and salty...

So, in short, it would've been bad from my point of view anyways. Thank.

Img_0215
joined Jul 29, 2017

Unlike Luminous=Blue, that was one of those “there’s no good way out of this one” situations. And by God, there wasn’t.

joined Jul 26, 2019

For the drama side there were a lot of them in this one so it was not what was missing and for a yuri to work is not necessary like the demonstration bloom into you or whispering you a love song...

The beginning was too slow. I didn't say there was no drama at all. And Bloom Into You has plenty of drama...

Yeah, nice drama about touko's past because we clearly knew that yuu and touko together from the beginning would be at the end and there is a lot of humour in the majority..... there are many examples of yuri without big drama that have had many chapters like kaze san, or otome no teikoku or even tadokoro san or currently whispering which during a survey in a Japanese site arrived fourth before citrus +.... You need drama but not in too large quantities...
On this one it started directly on drama during the first chapters and it didn't seem to take but it was far from uninteresting in the background.

For me the real drama is the unrequieted love or haru and Midori now we can talk about real drama.

last edited at Sep 19, 2019 11:56PM

Eivhbyw
joined Aug 26, 2018

Yeah, nice drama about touko's past because we clearly knew that yuu and touko together from the beginning would be at the end and there is a lot of humour in the majority..... there are many examples of yuri without big drama that have had many chapters like kaze san, or otome no teikoku or even tadokoro san or currently whispering which during a survey in a Japanese site arrived fourth before citrus +.... You need drama but not in too large quantities...
On this one it started directly on drama during the first chapters and it didn't seem to take but it was far from uninteresting in the background.

For me the real drama is the unrequieted love or haru and Midori now we can talk about real drama.

So your idea of drama is simply different. Very limited in fact. To deny that manga like Kase-san have drama is just ridiculous. Stuff like Tadokoro-san thrives on different things, like excessive fanservice and over-the-top characters.
I think Whispering you a love song has other strenghts too, like an impeccable artstyle and a competent writer.
I find it funny how you claim this one had obvious drama right from chapter one, but deny those other series have real drama. Double standards much?

Of course yuri manga can be successful without drama, but drama will always be the go-to source for conflict and attention.

last edited at Sep 20, 2019 2:03AM

Pikachuwhat
joined Mar 13, 2014

Reading these spoilers and poly sounds like a shit ending tbh

46-75
joined Jun 25, 2019

What bother me it's we got poly end here and we got no orgy in Skeeter Rabbit

joined Jul 26, 2019

Yeah, nice drama about touko's past because we clearly knew that yuu and touko together from the beginning would be at the end and there is a lot of humour in the majority..... there are many examples of yuri without big drama that have had many chapters like kaze san, or otome no teikoku or even tadokoro san or currently whispering which during a survey in a Japanese site arrived fourth before citrus +.... You need drama but not in too large quantities...
On this one it started directly on drama during the first chapters and it didn't seem to take but it was far from uninteresting in the background.

For me the real drama is the unrequieted love or haru and Midori now we can talk about real drama.

So your idea of drama is simply different. Very limited in fact. To deny that manga like Kase-san have drama is just ridiculous. Stuff like Tadokoro-san thrives on different things, like excessive fanservice and over-the-top characters.
I think Whispering you a love song has other strenghts too, like an impeccable artstyle and a competent writer.
I find it funny how you claim this one had obvious drama right from chapter one, but deny those other series have real drama. Double standards much?

Of course yuri manga can be successful without drama, but drama will always be the go-to source for conflict and attention.

I was however clear it was not at all the same level drama between an unrequited love and bloom into you, nothing to see, if you were sad on the majority of the manga it is that you are hyper sensitive....
I'm not limited at all sorry because I read all kinds of manga and for yuri his share of ecchi has pure drama...... I know perfectly how to make the difference thanks.

For luminous it is not that the manga is started too softly because I read several of them that started with the drama side except that for this one the mystery about why nene wanted a amane took too long to be explained, and the explanation with hindsight is ridiculous.

last edited at Sep 21, 2019 12:09PM

Eivhbyw
joined Aug 26, 2018

I was however clear it was not at all the same level drama between an unrequited love and bloom into you, nothing to see, if you were sad on the majority of the manga it is that you are hyper sensitive....
I'm not limited at all sorry because I read all kinds of manga and for yuri his share of ecchi has pure drama...... I know perfectly how to make the difference thanks.

For luminous it is not that the manga is started too softly because I read several of them that started with the drama side except that for this one the mystery about why nene wanted a amane took too long to be explained, and the explanation with hindsight is ridiculous.

It's asinine to equate drama with sadness in the first place.
You are limited in your perception of drama, not what you actually read.

The whole thing was ridiculous from the start, but that never stopped other series before.

last edited at Sep 21, 2019 3:09PM

46-75
joined Jun 25, 2019

The whole thint was ridiculous from the start, but that never stopped other series before.

Is it here where we talk about Citrus and Nez come to stop it ?

The wait for the translation after seeing the raws is killing me.

last edited at Sep 21, 2019 1:32PM

Avatar
joined Oct 22, 2018

The whole thint was ridiculous from the start, but that never stopped other series before.

Is it here where we talk about Citrus and Nez come to stop it ?

laughs in off-topic

joined Jul 26, 2019

It's asinine to equate drama with sadness in the first place.
You are limited in your perception of drama, not what you actually read.

The whole thing was ridiculous from the start, but that never stopped other series before.

It is well what I say at the beginning is not the lack of drama that is the cause of the failure of this manga, it is its use and that the cause is anything but realistic with nene.

To reply you must either login or sign up.