In this case, cliche simply refers to an element of an artistic work that is not original and not interesting. It can also mean when such an element is used too often and is indicative of bad artistry, or that it is so often used that it loses its original meaning or impact. I'd also say it depends on the quality of the original. Something that is done exceedingly well may become cliche in only its second usage.
A use of a transfer student can be a trope of romance manga, but by itself can not be cliche without considering how and why it is being used. This is true even if transfer students have been used "1545359603th" times.
As for the transfer student, I can not recall many Yuri stories where the character changed schools, because she was discovered as a lesbian. And I find it interesting where in chapter three we learn that this fact of her character is going to play an important and meaningful role. It also doesn't appear that the author is using the transfer student trope in a watered down way, nor to force interest.
Otherwise, I really like this.
last edited at Jan 2, 2018 11:27AM