It's not for misunderstanding the story. It's for
1) deciding to look at the pages of a story without understanding the language,
Buying the book helps support the author.
2) coming to an almost comically incorrect conclusion,
Happens to the best of us
3) assuming it's somehow the absolute truth and not just a mistaken impression,
They apparently read a review which planted a false impression in their head. Again, it happens.
4) coming here to share this impression with others, and
This is a public forum for discussing the manga. The poster included labelled spoiler tags.
5) reporting it as if it were fact (as you can see in their earlier post, no mention of being unable to actually read the book, just insisting that whatever they got from looking at the pictures is the truth).
They honestly thought it was the truth, why is this a problem?
Misunderstanding something is forgivable. But I think anyone who foists their obvious misunderstandings upon others and promotes them as facts should be called "dumb". Also, the poster included this in their second post:
I still don't see why you think the comments were so bad the poster deserved to be insulted. And I would not call posting spoiler tagged comments on a forum "foisting."
major spoilers assuming i'm not a dumbass and wrong
I'm merely confirming what they already suspect about themselves.
Didn't you say earlier in this post you didn't like them "reporting as fact?" Now it's bad that they acknowledge they might be wrong? Which they did multiple times by the way. Take a glance at their forum history and you'll see they're a generally fine citizen on this site.
last edited at Aug 30, 2017 6:47AM