Forum › When I Am in Love discussion

captainwangatang
Dash
joined Jun 6, 2012

my dad is oedipus and my mom is electra so i'm mixed

joined Oct 22, 2020

my dad is oedipus and my mom is electra so i'm mixed

HAH

cherryraspberrypie
joined May 27, 2026

Poor Sumire... She'll feel better once she sees Makoto on the news.

last edited at Jul 31, 2026 9:30PM

joined Mar 3, 2026

anyone know who's the illustrator

Img_3131
joined Nov 25, 2023

this was awesome. huge props to the translators too, anything in novel format is a lot of work

Img_5712
joined Jan 3, 2022

Mannn I was rooting for Sumire too...

The "When I am in love, I am beautiful" line at the end there reminded me of an earlier line; "beautiful people in love are poisonous"

And I just realized that MC was conflating being love with becoming beautiful. Maybe it's cuz I've never experienced it first hand myself, but I wonder if MC actually was in love with Marie?

With the focus on beauty and looks what if MC just got it wrong? And really, she's only obsessed with Marie because she's the one who helped her become beautiful like she had always wanted to.

And again, maybe it's just cuz I've never fallen for anyone, but it seems kinda narcissistic to turn being in love with someone else into smthn about yourself by suggesting that being in loves makes you beautiful. It turns love into this pure(?) thing where you seek out another person and become happy together into this symbol/measure of your own worth.

maybe it's just cuz I'm dumb but her immediately resorting to murder doesn't make sense to me unless she isn't actually in love with Marie, esp cuz she said she didn't mind if her feelings weren't returned. Idk how you go from that mindset to poisoning your own father just cuz you can't live with a woman during your uni years. The same woman who said y'all could still hang out too?

Idk how you go from being called AI cuz you only care about if smthn is good for you or not to actively acting in against what's best for you?

Poor Sumire... She'll feel better once she sees Makoto on the news.

She might feel better in hindsight but she'll def be mortified or sad in the moment. There's no way you can see your crush on the news for murder and not be a little disheartened

All I got from that is gay yearning strong enough to forget you shouldn't kill someone with daffodils because it's too obvious.

maybe she's counting on plausible deniability? Like, if she grew chives in the garden too she could argue that she grabbed the wrong plant? But she'd also have to explain the rubber gloves if she normally doesn't wear them when making that dish.

joined Sep 28, 2022

I actually kinda related to the main character of this for much of the story which made the ending have real whiplash for me lol

Firefox_02_23_23_58-070
joined Oct 17, 2025

And I just realized that MC was conflating being love with becoming beautiful. Maybe it's cuz I've never experienced it first hand myself, but I wonder if MC actually was in love with Marie?

I think the MC inherently has a twisted idea of what love could be. Maybe she genuinely was in love with Marie, because Marie was helping her see a side of herself that she couldn't bring out before, and because Marie was the first adult in her life that seemed to actually care for her as a person. It could be true as well that she was using Marie too, she was her manic pixie dream girl for lack of a better term.

Idk how you go from being called AI cuz you only care about if smthn is good for you or not to actively acting in against what's best for you?

Well, the MC is clearly not a reliable narrator. She's so obsessed with Marie that it's clouding her judgement in everything. She already doesn't have a healthy idea of what love is, and she harbors resentment for her parents who have been neglectful all her life. It makes sense that she's apathetic to the idea of murdering her father, who she views as having torn the family apart (yes, they were both cheating, but the dad was the one who went a step further to end the family arrangement) and had the gall to try to make a new, happier life for himself in her own childhood home without her. Her hypocrisy and shortsightedness is intentional, because all these combinations of emotions without a healthy outlet are driving her to the extreme.

Screenshot%202026-08-05%20101016
joined Oct 24, 2018

Well, the MC is clearly not a reliable narrator. She's so obsessed with Marie that it's clouding her judgement in everything.

This. I like how you can tell how deep this girl's love delusion goes with her endless narration about what a good and perfect woman Marie is when clearly, that's not the case. There is no morally good woman who would tell her cheating partner's kid that her mom is also in an affair (which, she didn't show any proof nor someone in her place should tell the kid this information), say Sumire was being jealous of Makoto without taking their relationship into consideration or get into the affair with an older man who has a minor daughter in the first place. Makoto was also so blind in love that she put all the blame for kicking her out of the house on her father without taking what Marie said about this matter into account. Like yes, the father initiated the idea but Marie was agreeing and onto it as well. It's just that she wanted Makoto to live alone rather than living with her mother.

__akiyama_mizuki_project_sekai_drawn_by_ririru__aef7569108d461f730828c198e920bc8_1_1_1_1_1
joined Mar 9, 2024
  • Be in school's gardening club.
  • Talk about how daffodil is similar to chives but is poisonous.
  • Poison people with daffodil, and expect not to be found out.

... duh

Kiddyland_sailor_waddle_dee
joined Dec 16, 2018

Read this from author's Bookwalker in jp before not surprised to see it eventually show up here. For anyone shocked at the author of eupho producing something like this, it actually seems to be more in line with her other works as they can get pretty dark.

JuniperPengold
Hotarusquibbly
joined Feb 12, 2025

That was such a fucking turn for the story to take in the last page LMAO
I don't like it even but I do respect it. I kind of love it. Pulling the "kill a man and steal his wife" gambit when the man is HER FATHER

I don't even know if it was a turn... I think she laid it on thick reminding us about the daffodil poisons, but it was definitely setup from the start. Chekov's gun and all that, if the author is telling us about the daffodils's poisons and then the kimchi fried rice using chives.... The daffodils are definitely going into the kimchi.

You could really feel her descend into madness though, completely oblivious to Sumire's despair...

It's not that the technical steps of the process were underexplained, it's that her character and the tone were not set up well to flow naturally into that twist. Yes, she's selfish, in a way that is very realistic and does not, on its own, lead to murder. Yes, she dismisses and resents her parents for understandable reasons, but there are far more mental things someone has to sort through to commit a premeditated murder beyond just, "Do I dislike the victim?"
The tone throughout is somber, contemplative, low-energy, and, despite the discussions of familial collapse and poison, not terribly dark. This contributes a lot to the murder ending feeling hamfisted. It's not a natural conclusion to the art. It's just sudden.

last edited at Aug 3, 2026 9:46PM

Kohaku%20avatar%20500px
joined Jul 10, 2016

There's a few errors in the first sentence. You wrote "Mum", but then the rest of the sentence reads like you wrote "Mom".

If you're going to use "Mum", the sentence should read more like "WURRR, WELL OI GUESS DA'S BEEN CHEATIN' ON MUM, HE 'AS." And yes, in all caps. British English has many subtle notes to it that people often forget.

Please remember this for next time, and thank you for your work.

Eterna%20rinebow%20small
joined Oct 20, 2017

I mean it's exactly what I would expect from Takeda Ayano honestly, she clearly has the proclivity for this kind of stories.

the way Kumiko thought about and acted around some of her female bandmates was not that far off from this

Kuroko-railgun
joined Jul 21, 2024

Cover art guessing by the art style looks like it's done by Kuwabara Tamotsu?

joined Oct 1, 2024

You people are forgetting they're Japanese people, and Japanese society would rather let a murderer go scott free than allowing such scandalous murder to disturb society.
So Makoto won't even be accussed and the police will claim that dad died due to an allergic reaction to the food. Marie will know deeply inside but she will refuse to accept the truth because she's too vapid to entertain the notion of a parricide.

joined Mar 31, 2025

Her dad was a bum lol good for her good for her

JuniperPengold
Hotarusquibbly
joined Feb 12, 2025

You people are forgetting they're Japanese people, and Japanese society would rather let a murderer go scott free than allowing such scandalous murder to disturb society.
So Makoto won't even be accussed and the police will claim that dad died due to an allergic reaction to the food. Marie will know deeply inside but she will refuse to accept the truth because she's too vapid to entertain the notion of a parricide.

Idk what alternate reality you're living in where the Japanese criminal justice system is so afraid to dish out punishment. But the tone of this comment moreso suggests to me that you're just trolling?

last edited at Aug 5, 2026 11:34PM

__akiyama_mizuki_project_sekai_drawn_by_ririru__aef7569108d461f730828c198e920bc8_1_1_1_1_1
joined Mar 9, 2024

^ That definitely is a troll. See their comment history.

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

^ That definitely is a troll. See their comment history.

Yeah BSC has an....interesting history lol

MrEngenious Admin
Puff
Dynasty Scans
joined Oct 8, 2010

You people are forgetting they're Japanese people, and Japanese society would rather let a murderer go scott free than allowing such scandalous murder to disturb society.
So Makoto won't even be accussed and the police will claim that dad died due to an allergic reaction to the food. Marie will know deeply inside but she will refuse to accept the truth because she's too vapid to entertain the notion of a parricide.

This is not an acceptable comment to be making. While you don't frequently post, you have a few that verge on weirdly extremist takes like this. I'm going to request that you stop this kind of shitty posting.

To reply you must either login or sign up.