Also read the last chapter, pretty disappointed, it kinda feels like Tsukasa is unhappy. I just wish the author didn't put that epilogue scene where Tsukasa's boyfriend was mentioned in chapter 19, so I can keep hoping for Tsukasa x Washio. This manga could have been good.

Okay, I don't mind about drama, not even bad development but forcing Tsukasa having a someone as a boyfriend was big mistake, since until the end the manga was defending the ''group of three'' and then just pushed that stupidicy is clearly awfuld, literally they say that her friend are not more important in the future.
Not even the yaoi part get resolve, putts.

My eyes! The goggles do nothing!

Ugh. What was this manga even about? No resolution, nothing changed since the beginning.

that was even worse than I imagined.
He didn't even bother making a clear ending for any of the people involved in this trainwreck.
a status quo that kept up from the beginning to the ending, amazing, it's like a harem but even worse because it had no excuses to do so.

last edited at May 25, 2017 6:36PM

thank god this is finally over

Honestly, I would have much rather read a manga about the yaoi ship(which was actually really good btw) then read this. I'm really glad it's over.

Meh, I'm just gonna head-canon that Tsukasa, Kotooka and Washio all got together in the end and lived happily as 3 girlfriends forever

Okay this ending is disappointing. I guess we're just supposed to imagine what happens after.

What a crappy ending... I can tell some stuff got resolved but none of the important stuff feels like it was.

the ending was disappointing due to the manga getting axed by the publisher, not due to author intent. i'm honest to god mad about this ending thinking about how good it could've been if the author was allowed to finish it however they'd originally planned

God, I ended up hating almost everyone in this manga. And I quite liked them in the beginning
Also, what a crappy ending. Disappointed

the ending was disappointing due to the manga getting axed by the publisher, not due to author intent. i'm honest to god mad about this ending thinking about how good it could've been if the author was allowed to finish it however they'd originally planned

He had 23 chapters to go somewhere and didn't.
Particularly long chapters, even.
There was no excuse for him to do this crap.

Well, I guess it was good for my well-being that I didn't bother to read Volume 5. After the relatively brief hiatus between 4 and 5 and the revelation that it was canceled, I was pretty sure it'd have a crappy ending, and, lo and behold, it did... It's a shame, this could have really been something great if it wasn't dragged on for so damn long... and, wow, to add insult to injury, the "bonus chapter" is just more yaoi and some random stupid pictures. I mean, I enjoyed the yaoi more than the yuri in this thing, but this is yuri for God's sake, at least let the alleged main characters get a page in the last chapter. I wonder if this is how yaoi fans felt during the three-chapter yuri arc and the various other yuri chapters and whatnot... though, in that case, the yuri added to the story and had an actual point as opposed to this crap. Plus, Prunus Girl had a great, conclusive ending, while this apparently doesn't... this definitely needs a continuation but, let's face it, it probably still wouldn't go anywhere meaningful. I mean, I certainly would not be opposed to more Prunus Girl either, but that's because I actually like the story as opposed to here where I just want SOMETHING to happen.

So.... secrets are good now? I'm confused.

ENTIRE MANGA: Secrets are destructive and bad!

LAST CHAPTER: Actually secrets are totally ok never mind

last edited at May 25, 2017 7:28PM

It's such a shame this was cancelled and had to end like this... It was shaping up to be one of the best yuri here.

That was cute. The bonus chapter. Would be nice if there's a Subaru x Asakura spinoff where we see them getting together for real. But that won't happen.

Implication Tsukasa didn't confess because of "friendzone" was so cringey, I couldn't handle it. Way to completely ruin your manga even when you went for non ending.

This chapter shows that, once again, this mangaka is an immensely talented writer who just couldn't quite get their story told in less chapters than they had planned.

I mean, sure, but part of being a good writer is knowing how to plan your story so that it's presented concisely and effectively. The fact that they couldn't wrap things up within 23 (huge, 50 page) chapters doesn't exactly speak well of their talent, to be honest. Like, how long did they want this story to be, exactly? Especially given that I got tired and felt like the story was going in circles back in chapter eight, and I'm still not sure that things have significantly changed since then.

Maybe the author had some notion that they were going to write a 30-volume saga on the scale of Kimi ni Todoke or Skip Beat or whatever, but I just can't see that ever happening with this story as it's been written, axe or no axe.

A bonus chapter... It's yaoi
Geez, I wonder why this yuri love triangle got axed

I don't know how I do but I really love the series all Dynasty hate xD
All have secrets, for that we lie, for that we go to nowhere, screw all, making people cry but, even with that, we can't stop lying in something, more in adolescence.
It's sadly how the author put what he/she wanted to do in the character pages ;^; how bad this got cancelled but, even when I love it, I suposse for all the hate I read, this didn't sell good x'D how bad.

This chapter shows that, once again, this mangaka is an immensely talented writer who just couldn't quite get their story told in less chapters than they had planned.

I mean, sure, but part of being a good writer is knowing how to plan your story so that it's presented concisely and effectively. The fact that they couldn't wrap things up within 23 (huge, 50 page) chapters doesn't exactly speak well of their talent, to be honest. Like, how long did they want this story to be, exactly? Especially given that I got tired and felt like the story was going in circles back in chapter eight, and I'm still not sure that things have significantly changed since then.

Maybe the author had some notion that they were going to write a 30-volume saga on the scale of Kimi ni Todoke or Skip Beat or whatever, but I just can't see that ever happening with this story as it's been written, axe or no axe.

^ This. Pretty much. It's good that they try to thoroughly flesh out the characters' thoughts and emotions, but that should be accompanied with substantial developments in the plot, the characters, & their relationships as well. The BL part of this series did that & that's why it is more engaging to read. The yuri was pretty much stomping at the same place the entire time. Instead of sorting out the girls' feelings, they were just introducing more secretceptions between them. & by the end of 23 long chapters, their feelings for each other and relationships w/ one another only come off as shallow rather than anything remotely engaging.

last edited at May 25, 2017 8:47PM

DAMN such trolling T_T now i really want more off all this.. BUUU T^T

The story should have been only about the love triangle and the 3 girls. I don't dislike guys in yuri stories but these two were main characters and at some point the story really seemed to be more about them than about the yuri love triangle. Plus I found them very boring, I couldn't give a fuck about Subaru's crossdressing , his somewhat incestuous feelings towards Tsukasa and the whole thing with Tsukasa/Asakura/Subaru. I really liked the first chapters, it had great potencial but then the characters became annoying af, the no ending and the implied het with Tsukasa just made this much worse.

last edited at May 25, 2017 9:18PM

This chapter shows that, once again, this mangaka is an immensely talented writer who just couldn't quite get their story told in less chapters than they had planned.

I mean, sure, but part of being a good writer is knowing how to plan your story so that it's presented concisely and effectively. The fact that they couldn't wrap things up within 23 (huge, 50 page) chapters doesn't exactly speak well of their talent, to be honest.

Did you really feel like this didn't wrap things up with the three main girls? It is very clear what's going to happen: Kotooka and Washio end up together when they grow up, and Tsukasa is straight and dates boys, and they all still are friends.

They had the annoying "let's enjoy our ambiguous youth before these memories fade like dew on the morning grass," but that's a manga thing... freaking Sasameki Koto ended with that. I'm really bugged Kotooka didn't come out to her friends as gay, but this story seemed totally wrapped up.

Now the boys, that was a big ol' "what the hell is even going on?" there at the end.