Forum › You Started This, So You Better Finish It discussion

Capture%20d'%c3%a9cran%202023-07-16%20161106
joined Jul 16, 2023

I'm in despair, my baby got rejected :(
I hope she doesn't become juste a physical replacement and find true happiness...

Kuroko-railgun
joined Jul 21, 2024

Look at all these chapters that just dropped on the 21st! ^_^

Sandra2
joined Mar 22, 2013

Noooo. She got rejected. :O

Hmmmmmm, I've been thinking. Could she and Sui be the same person?? I mean it is really unlikely. But... they do look alike a little on the image with the four woman. I mean, that's really unlikely I guess. It's probably just me, clinging to the last straw, that this is not a love triangle. -.-

last edited at Jan 21, 2026 10:06PM

Ava-min
joined Dec 8, 2022

Noooo. She got rejected. :O

Hmmmmmm, I've been thinking. Could she and Sui be the same person?? I mean it is really unlikely. But... they do look alike a little on the image with the four woman. I mean, that's really unlikely I guess. It's probably just me, clinging to the last straw, that this is not a love triangle. -.-

I don't think so. I did have the same thought after reading the 1st chapter at some point, but there are just too many elements that don't fit. I do think that there is some connection between the two though.

My current theory is that they are sisters or similarly related, and look very closely alike because of that - which might also explain why Sui canceled the date at the last second: She needs some time to console her sister who has been crushed from the rejection. Still feels like a very soap-opera kind of coincidence, but more believable than the two of them being the same person - at least to me.

Book%20and%20cloakhbq1
joined Aug 1, 2011

Melon posted:

Noooo. She got rejected. :O

Hmmmmmm, I've been thinking. Could she and Sui be the same person?? I mean it is really unlikely. But... they do look alike a little on the image with the four woman. I mean, that's really unlikely I guess. It's probably just me, clinging to the last straw, that this is not a love triangle. -.-

No, no, that's the other OL series with complicated relationships.

Yuu
joined Mar 28, 2015

Tbh, there may be some twist there.

Ren, in chapter 2, when she learned that Sui is a college student, remarked that Sui looked older than that, to which she answered "I hear that a lot" and "Guess I look older than I am".

It just may be idle banter and not mean anything, or Chekhov's gun that Sui is indeed older than she pretends to be and is the colleague's old flame she trains herself to seduce.

Also, on the cover page, there's the sentence, "The reason I fell in love, the reason I feel this way, it's all because of you, right?" which could then apply to at least 3 of the women.

last edited at Jan 22, 2026 7:16AM

joined May 3, 2025

The anxiety about how much to text your crush is just adorable.

Cs4_cover
joined Jul 13, 2015

Is sensed actually it will be a cuadricular relationship.
I mean, the boss is probably seeing a girl that mc know, maybe Sui

last edited at Jan 22, 2026 7:50AM

Yuu
joined Mar 28, 2015

I noticed something else. The female colleague has piercing marks on her ears, but doesn't wear earring. It's not random: the marks are present on all the panels we see her ears.

If you look at the page with the "hidden" fourth woman, she wears prominent earrings.

Imo, chances are:

  • Sui is older than she pretends to be.
  • The 4th woman is Ren's colleague.
The%20snilling%20sneeler
joined Mar 9, 2022

tbh tongue piercing girl was definitely jumping the gun, but oof. my heart sank for ren; rejecting one cute girl just to get rejected yourself by your crush...

5688-1340606550
joined May 11, 2013

So they did exchange names at some point, Ren just couldn't even be bothered to remember hers...ouch. I still really like tongue piercing though, hope she gets another chance soon.

Sui changing her mind about the date does line up really neatly with Ren telling her colleague to just "roll with it" so I'd be willing to believe she's the 4th woman. She doesn't have wavy hair but Touma gives a lot of care and attention to her characters' appearance so it's more likely to me that she just styles it differently outside of the office or something like that.

Images
joined Jun 11, 2020

God I'm liking this manga even more each chapter, yes girl go get her outside of the rental service (a character being named Suichan is flashing an image of hoshimachi suisei in my head constantly tho lmao)
That poor girl from the one night stand lmao, shot down instantly
After being in Tokyo the fucking shrine in shinjuku in ch3 was such a surreal thing to see in a Yuri manga!!! Like!!! I'VE VISITED THAT SHRINE LESS THAN A MONTH AGO!! Now it's blessed by Yuri, peak

D05536d6-01d1-4527-9102-4cc772fad5ed
joined Jul 6, 2020

I noticed something else. The female colleague has piercing marks on her ears, but doesn't wear earring. It's not random: the marks are present on all the panels we see her ears.

If you look at the page with the "hidden" fourth woman, she wears prominent earrings.

Imo, chances are:

  • Sui is older than she pretends to be.
  • The 4th woman is Ren's colleague.

Good eye! The hair color seems to match as well, but the color image shows the hidden fourth woman having wavy hair which doesn't match right now, but definitely isn't a dealbreaker either. It seems to me like the colleague probably is the fourth woman here

joined May 9, 2017

I noticed something else. The female colleague has piercing marks on her ears, but doesn't wear earring. It's not random: the marks are present on all the panels we see her ears.

If you look at the page with the "hidden" fourth woman, she wears prominent earrings.

Imo, chances are:

  • Sui is older than she pretends to be.
  • The 4th woman is Ren's colleague.

Good eye! The hair color seems to match as well, but the color image shows the hidden fourth woman having wavy hair which doesn't match right now, but definitely isn't a dealbreaker either. It seems to me like the colleague probably is the fourth woman here

The story with her coworker happened 3 years ago, and it was with their superior, which we can easily assume is older than her. Even if Sui pretends to be younger than she is, that would be quite the stretch.

Edit: two other things that don't add up to me.
* Sui seems to be genuinely flustered by everything that is happening during her date with Ren. She is either pretending to be an inexperienced maiden, or she just is (which I think is it).
* She seems to have colored hair (to be fair, she doesn't on the cover, but she clearly doesn't have the same hair color in the manga, as we can clearly see a fading). If she is an office worker, that is very unlikely. It's more logical for a college student.

I'm not sure I believe in most theory being written her, but I do enjoy reading them though!

last edited at Jan 22, 2026 7:27PM

Webp.net-resizeimage%20(1)
joined Apr 19, 2012

I'm a big fan of Ren, she's just so honest with herself lol

last edited at Jan 23, 2026 1:02AM

Book%20and%20cloakhbq1
joined Aug 1, 2011

I noticed something else. The female colleague has piercing marks on her ears, but doesn't wear earring. It's not random: the marks are present on all the panels we see her ears.

If you look at the page with the "hidden" fourth woman, she wears prominent earrings.

Imo, chances are:

  • Sui is older than she pretends to be.
  • The 4th woman is Ren's colleague.

I feel like I've missed an important page or I'm misinterpreting something in this conversation. Where do we see enough of either of the hidden characters to know one of them wears prominent earrings? I keep thinking of the spread on pages 2 and 3 of chapter 1, but that can't be it because we only see the hair of one character and the arm of the other.

Yuu
joined Mar 28, 2015

Omega Deuse posted:

I noticed something else. The female colleague has piercing marks on her ears, but doesn't wear earring. It's not random: the marks are present on all the panels we see her ears.

If you look at the page with the "hidden" fourth woman, she wears prominent earrings.

Imo, chances are:

  • Sui is older than she pretends to be.
  • The 4th woman is Ren's colleague.

I feel like I've missed an important page or I'm misinterpreting something in this conversation. Where do we see enough of either of the hidden characters to know one of them wears prominent earrings? I keep thinking of the spread on pages 2 and 3 of chapter 1, but that can't be it because we only see the hair of one character and the arm of the other.

There's an ad for the series at the bottom of the first page of this thread, courtesy of the scanlator.

last edited at Jan 23, 2026 2:34PM

Clorica
joined Aug 31, 2025

insanely unimportant detail can someone PLEASE explain to me wtf is going on with the weight machine shes using to work out on pg 9 of chapter 2 im no expert on gymming but the pulleys and how they connect to the stack and each other genuinely make no sense to me. not that it matters bc its such an irrelevant detail but im just so so curious what is going on with it

joined May 9, 2017

insanely unimportant detail can someone PLEASE explain to me wtf is going on with the weight machine shes using to work out on pg 9 of chapter 2 im no expert on gymming but the pulleys and how they connect to the stack and each other genuinely make no sense to me. not that it matters bc its such an irrelevant detail but im just so so curious what is going on with it

This is a fairly standard machine to work on the pectoralis group muscle. I've seen some in Japan, but looking up online, those machines are also in other countries.

X2(edited)2
joined Jan 2, 2022

God this manga is gonna break me. I don't need to see my unrequited loves painted so harshly.

Clorica
joined Aug 31, 2025

This is a fairly standard machine to work on the pectoralis group muscle. I've seen some in Japan, but looking up online, those machines are also in other countries.

i think i kinda see it now. im assuming its kinda like a chest press motion instead of a pec fly motion. ive never seen a machine like this, but its neat to know it actually is a real thing i just havent heard of

thanks for the context !

Thomasina Pontier
342713096_945190890232560_6363820535049258469_n
joined Mar 18, 2023

Ren thinks too much and too hard...

Eterna%20rinebow%20small
joined Oct 20, 2017

This has the vibes of a realistic dating sim, to me

joined Feb 25, 2025

sex time please

Thomasina Pontier
342713096_945190890232560_6363820535049258469_n
joined Mar 18, 2023

Predictive formula so far. Nevertheless entertaining. S3x next?

To reply you must either login or sign up.