Forum › Afterschool Stabbing discussion

Viradynastyicon1
joined Jul 1, 2014

Nice to see Bayonetta getting a steady pay check.

I had to log in to say this is probably one of my fav comments in a thread ever.
Maybe it's cause I just woke up, but I laughed too hard.

2x2-shinobuden-m001
joined Dec 14, 2014

I was kind of more interested in and rooting for the friend she hangs out with, who is probably an ex-gf.

Nezchan Moderator
Meiling%20bun%20150px
joined Jun 28, 2012

Orangey posted:

I would quite like one day in a student-teacher manga for the bff to actually be like "um no don't do out with a student, you could get fired" instead of always pushing for the two to get together.

From my understanding that sort of thing isn't actually illegal in Japan so you'd be unlikely to see that happen.

Doesn't matter if it's illegal, it would be a huge scandal and schools don't want that. They'd definitely fire her.

Plus there's the age issue. The Children Welfare Act makes sex with a child under 18 illegal, with some exceptions that almost 100% wouldn't apply here.

44716723_p17
joined Aug 9, 2015

The flustered face the teacher makes on page 19 is just too cute! Ahhh!

Akari-mizunashi-transparent%203
joined Oct 10, 2014

That kiss was great!

Breakdanceanomicon
joined Jun 13, 2015

Nice to see Bayonetta getting a steady pay check.

My thoughts exactly.
On the last page, I read "Why don't you get off me for now" as "Why don't you get me off for now" and was extremely disappointed to find out that it was not the case. It really looked like it was heading in that direction!

joined Jan 8, 2014

Age gap, student/teacher, all good stuff....
But the best was the moe-gap when the serious teach got all flustered and blushed ^_^

Charon-sml
joined Feb 14, 2016

I would quite like one day in a student-teacher manga for the bff to actually be like "um no don't do out with a student, you could get fired" instead of always pushing for the two to get together. It always seems to be the classic "we're both girls, you're going through a phase' but it would be nice if the teacher could just believe that they were genuine but y'know, just doesn't wanna lose their job.

This was cute enough, but I don't think I've seen anything different here from the usual student-teacher though

You've read the bits of Dear My Teacher that have been translated here, right? Because if not, get on that.

Obnoxious%20vi
joined May 27, 2015

I just wanna say the art in the flashbacks was real nice, the speech bubbles looked painful. Mikazuki kind threw me though, her mutant fish-yes are huge even by manga standards, I mean that's some 90s anime shit!

last edited at Feb 18, 2016 3:19PM

Cromartie%20highscool
joined Jun 7, 2014

and here I thought there would be actual stabbing

2641afdd-9dc4-4327-a1c3-a5b558c33522
joined Mar 12, 2014

Orangey posted:

I would quite like one day in a student-teacher manga for the bff to actually be like "um no don't do out with a student, you could get fired" instead of always pushing for the two to get together.

From my understanding that sort of thing isn't actually illegal in Japan so you'd be unlikely to see that happen.

Doesn't matter if it's illegal, it would be a huge scandal and schools don't want that. They'd definitely fire her.

Plus there's the age issue. The Children Welfare Act makes sex with a child under 18 illegal, with some exceptions that almost 100% wouldn't apply here.

Wayyyy back when I was in school, we had a student-teacher scandal, and while our teacher wasn't fired for it, she was off for a heck of a long time. It never looks good no matter where you are, I think, even if it is legal.

I do like the idea of student-teacher, but I just wish mangas went into more angst/guilt/detail with it, instead of the standard. There's so much that could be gone into with it!

2641afdd-9dc4-4327-a1c3-a5b558c33522
joined Mar 12, 2014

I would quite like one day in a student-teacher manga for the bff to actually be like "um no don't do out with a student, you could get fired" instead of always pushing for the two to get together. It always seems to be the classic "we're both girls, you're going through a phase' but it would be nice if the teacher could just believe that they were genuine but y'know, just doesn't wanna lose their job.

This was cute enough, but I don't think I've seen anything different here from the usual student-teacher though

You've read the bits of Dear My Teacher that have been translated here, right? Because if not, get on that.

Yeah I have, though didn't that essentially have the "youre going through a phase" bit too? Along with her friends pushing her to go out with her student hahaa.

I think the only one who is going to stand in the way is the sensei's old crush, who is someone I don't think the mangaka wants us to take sides with.

Teenager%20drasil
joined Feb 18, 2016

and here I thought there would be actual stabbing

You know I am still kinda confused about that! I think it is symbolic but still odd on how it shows up in the story!

I thought like she was stabbed FOR REALZ...! O_O

1318
joined Jul 20, 2011

cute!!! that kid is cute!!! makes me wanna buy cats. >.<

Even better, go to a shelter and adopt one.

Top%20tier
joined May 13, 2015

and here I thought there would be actual stabbing

same i was scared to read at first

Profile_ing
joined Sep 20, 2014

Does anybody else think that this one's very interesting in art choices? It really isn't the most pleasing but it manages to bring a certain feeling across in its details and - for lack of a better word - shot composition.

You really FEEL the girl's desperation in the tight grip she has on teacher-san. Same goes for that determined look she shoots her in home room. And the wordless portrail of teacher-san's memories and that metaphorical dagger also give this manga a sort of artsy vibe.
Then it almost went into porn territory with its amount of body fluids, but hey.

Also a minor detail I enjoyed was teacher-san's torn stocking on page 23. Just pointing it out.

Charon-sml
joined Feb 14, 2016

Yeah I have, though didn't that essentially have the "youre going through a phase" bit too? Along with her friends pushing her to go out with her student hahaa.

(RE: Dear My Teacher)

I only read it as "you're going through a phase" in the context of Mikoto (the student) having a crush on Kaoru-sensei. While it's true that the previous romantically-interested student (whose name escapes me) eventually moved on and got married in a het relationship, I'd say it's pretty crucial to understanding the work to start from the angle that Mikoto's serious in saying that her romantic interest in women won't change, even if Kaoru-sensei regards the affection Mikoto shows her as inextricable from their current roles and the power dynamic between them. If that weren't true, I don't think she'd rebuke the previous love interest's claims that she'll feel differently in the future so This is what makes the story that's been translated so far so interesting to me; it's entirely possible that there will be a context in which the two of them could enter a relationship together, even though I think it's fair to say it would be grossly irresponsible for them to be engaging in a relationship while Mikoto is a student.

Like the manga seems to be saying "sure, it's entirely possible that your sexual preferences will change over time (and for people looking for a specific life trajectory it may be easier to mold them to suit) but that's not true for everyone and it's certainly not true that it's better that they do". Which is a pretty significant and thoughtful idea that I rarely see in works like these!

Klz1234699998m
joined May 15, 2012

I honestly see it quiet sad...I mean..I think that the teacher and her "friend" are actually dating so it means that in a way the teacher is double timing the student....At some point the student will be stabbed for sure about that.....

Nezchan Moderator
Meiling%20bun%20150px
joined Jun 28, 2012

I honestly see it quiet sad...I mean..I think that the teacher and her "friend" are actually dating so it means that in a way the teacher is double timing the student....At some point the student will be stabbed for sure about that.....

I think it's more likely the other woman is either a fuckbuddy, an ex she's still on good terms with, or a simple drinking buddy who also happens to be gay.

joined Jul 8, 2013

I honestly see it quiet sad...I mean..I think that the teacher and her "friend" are actually dating so it means that in a way the teacher is double timing the student....At some point the student will be stabbed for sure about that.....

I think it's more likely the other woman is either a fuckbuddy, an ex she's still on good terms with, or a simple drinking buddy who also happens to be gay.

Idk, I kind of agree with the first person. I was TOTALLY under the impression that the teacher was dating the blonde or at least having sex with her. The blonde was incredibly flirtatious with her, not to mention handsy, with how she kinda just stroked her fingers on her chest, and seemed to be even going on actual dates (I think they were at a restaurant at one point and the chapter literally started with what looked like the end of a kiss). I really thought that the teacher only said they weren't dating so that the student would think she was not interested in women or to convince her not to spread any scandalous rumors.
And even if it was just a fuckbuddy. The first person's concerns still apply. There's no indications that they stop doing it together so we don't really know if she's still sleeping with her or not.
In other words, the biggest fucking flaw in this oneshot was that we GOT LITERALLY NO CONTEXT AS TO WHO THE BLONDE EVEN FUCKING WAS. And thanks to that this series' ending COMPLETELY changes in tone lol.
Otherwise, this is actually some of my favorite art I've ever seen in manga and if this mangaka could make some more yuri, I'd be fucking ecstatic.

Avatar_eb43cd282953_128
joined Oct 13, 2014

Nice to see Bayonetta getting a steady pay check.

think jeanne will get jealous?

Anime-anime-boy-black-and-white-boy-favim.com-1570867
joined May 7, 2014

Sweet & Nice

Cryssoberyl Uploader
Booklet1-high-pink-experiment
Zefiberyl Translations
joined Apr 11, 2011

Mostly very enjoyable. As HKX said, the "kiss scene" was a bit of a mood whiplash with the ecchi sound effects and saliva. Still, cute on the whole, and what a beauty Sensei is. Thanks Yuri Project.

last edited at Feb 23, 2016 10:37PM

S
joined Dec 9, 2015

The title feels like a foxnews article

Pretty much was one... a sensual title with an okay story. While I do hope for the best, I feel that its a doomed relationship.

To reply you must either login or sign up.