You could just as easily read it as "being forced to present as a gender that you don't identify with leads to unhappiness." Sapphire presents a certain way because the patriarchy itself demands it, not unlike what most trans people have to deal with.
The thing is that. That kind of thing doesn't exist in a vacuum. The way patriarchy treats cis people and trans people is different.
Your argument is basically that a transphobe could disingenuously read their gross worldview into the work. Which...yes? You can disingenuously read just about anything into just about anything. As evidenced by the fact that this is literally a disingenuous complaint that someone could make a disingenuous complaint. This is just concern trolling, and while that does seem to be a favored pastime on this site lately, being this brazen about it kinda gives the game away.
I'm not actually concern trolling, and you kind of missed my point.
For context: I spend a lot of time reading various dogshit crossdressing manga. A very, very common trope in "girl dresses as boy" ones is that the girl crossdressing in them doesn't actually want to present as a guy and wants to be a real girly girl and is only a boy because of Tragic Circumstances. This often comes along with some...extremely bigoted assumptions about gender and how it works. From "you have to be a girl if you want to date a guy" (Hana-Kimi, a bunch of others) or "all women will find their happiness in traditional feminity and heterosexual marriage to a man and being removed from that hurts them" (too many to count if I'm being honest)
These literary constructs track with common stereotypes about transmasculine people, often to a tee. Transmascs are secretely unhappy, transmascs are only that way Because of Misogyny, you'd be so much happier if you detransitioned etc.
So when I saw Princess Knight do this I went "here we go again...it's that shitty trope... I am so sick of this...I am so sick of having everyone around me say that transmascs are really self-hating and would be so much happier as women and then go read a manga where a cis girl laments about how terrible being a boy is and see everyone praise it as trans-coded"
It's likely it's just me overreacting, especially considering what's been said about the latter chapters. But I truly despise this trope with a passion.
That sort of makes me find jumping to those conclusions dumb. This series literally has a relatively respectfully written trans girl in it.
I did not know this, since there are only two chapters out in English. This makes me look more kindly upon the series, and think it actually has something interesting to say about gender.
I kind of just went "fuck this trope I hate this trope it's literally everywhere I keep trying to find a manga where they don't do that but the number of such can be counted on a hand" without knowing much else about the manga beyond the two chapters I read.
last edited at Nov 13, 2026 5:26AM