EDIT: I wrote this back when we were on forum page 3 in direct respons to girlswhokiss and then walked my dogs. I haven't catched up on anything since
I'm not from the USA and you shouldn't assume everyone speaking in english is from there, or any other anglophone country.
I never did that though? It's mostly about the (apparently now deleted, but still quoted by swapbats) comment which, for some reason, had to point out that Miyuki isn't "white", which displayed an ethnic understanding of "white" as racial term rather than skin colour that more or less only comes from North America.
it doesn't make sense to say people who are mixed or visibly from a different ethnicity aren't going to be stereotyped and discriminated
Thank goodness everybody in this thread has been reasonable so far and not said that?
This isn't even the first time this author has designed a character like this, they have another work about a 40 years old woman who meets another woman (29 years old) in an online game where they start to date, and her character is a buff brown woman while the other's is another small light skinned woman, so this is something that sticks out in an unpleasant way even if there was no ill intent.
Checking that manga I'm kind of eh on that one. Like, it's a non-human fantasy character (possibly an Oni, who are historically drawn with skin in many colours which we just can't tell in B&W). Even if we assume it to be ethnically-coded there's still the massive baggage of how modern fantasy races are derived to unravel which may or may not absolve sono. (That's is a very interesting discussion by the way, but I have to admit to not know enough about that, especially when it comes to the japanese adaption of many western fantasy tropes.)
Since you, girlswhokiss are together with arka the only ones to explicitly state to have found this work racist (in contrast to having a more general discussion about the undeniable colorist stereotyping), I just want you to point them out: What in particular is wrong about having a physically strong and tall women be dark-skinned? Especially since sono's aforementioned track record of drawing way more light-skinned buff girls? Just because a certain combination of traits can be (and frequently is) used with racist connotations mustn't mean it necessarily is racist. (Just imagine banning crime thrillers from having dark-skinned suspects and culprits.)
Being attentive to societal issues is a good thing, but please please please uphold the presumption of innocence. There's thousand of black-man-steals-your-wife NTR hentai out there more deserving of being brigaded.
last edited at Nov 7, 2026 3:19PM