Forum › Posts by Zesc

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023
Hwxnrt2bsaaumf_-orig

^ You can send tag suggestions that have nothing to be added or removed though. Besides inexistent pairing, it's also useful for when there's an image that is a pre-/sequel to another one and they should be linked.

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023

So Willema went from attempting to kill Prince Sapphire to going on a date with her, in less than 34 pages. I would have liked for them to have taken their time with that.

This. Willema just does a 180 between the end of Ch 2 to the beginning of Ch 3. Feels like there a whole off-screen scene we've missed.

It isn't even a typical shounen "I defeated you so now you're my friend" because technically, Willema won.

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023

Is the term "Dark Lord" gendered in the original? If not I'm entertaining the idea of the older magical girl actually having become the Dark Lord.

Zesc
Kill Me discussion 15 Nov 18:09
Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023

Amazing.

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023

I actually really liked how Satori's mind-reading is shown here.

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023
Hwvu9lqwwaal744-orig

As president of the student council it is her duty to selflessly oblige to her classmate's requests.

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023
Hwyadxoxyaaskm5-orig

^ Obviously, HR is just short for Hera, though she got an enormous backlog to smite, most of which is her husband's fault.

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023

So they split genderflipped Patrick Bateman into two halves, with the osessive-anxious one thinking they're playing 5D chess, the career-focused socially alienated one thinks they're playing poker, and only the Kouhai correctly identified what's actually played as calvin ball?

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023

Re: the woman-king thing: Isn't this just an artefact of english being weird as heck? At least in every other language I can pass judgement on, the terms for a male and female monarch are identical save for usual grammatic gender, e.g. König -> Königin in german, مَلِك -> مَلِكَة in arabic or kráľ -> kráľovná in slovak. Or, for romance languages (in my case french) reine / reina / reinha / etc. which are basically just direct consequence of the latin regina.

(Tbf I'm not sure if 여왕 is still used in contexts where you don't have to stress it's a female monarch, but even then it's literally just "woman-king" and I suppose 남왕 for a "man-king" would be understood, but is just uncommon.)

So not to go all Sapir–Whorf on y'all, but I think this is simply a linguistic difference that doesn't exist in languages that didn't inexplicable choose to distinguish the proto-germanic term for "crone" a gendered royal title. It's like pointing out how most countries do not distinguish between slander and libel; both these hangups aren't unviversal but very particular to the british.


But somehow I spend even more time thinking about the snake. Why is it there? How did it got here? What is it doing on the roses? Does this take place in australia? Who screwed up to let it get this far to the prince(ss)? And does it count as "taking out the competition" when it was beheaded by Willema the assassin? So many questions...

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023
Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023

EDIT: I wrote this back when we were on forum page 3 in direct respons to girlswhokiss and then walked my dogs. I haven't catched up on anything since

I'm not from the USA and you shouldn't assume everyone speaking in english is from there, or any other anglophone country.

I never did that though? It's mostly about the (apparently now deleted, but still quoted by swapbats) comment which, for some reason, had to point out that Miyuki isn't "white", which displayed an ethnic understanding of "white" as racial term rather than skin colour that more or less only comes from North America.

it doesn't make sense to say people who are mixed or visibly from a different ethnicity aren't going to be stereotyped and discriminated

Thank goodness everybody in this thread has been reasonable so far and not said that?

This isn't even the first time this author has designed a character like this, they have another work about a 40 years old woman who meets another woman (29 years old) in an online game where they start to date, and her character is a buff brown woman while the other's is another small light skinned woman, so this is something that sticks out in an unpleasant way even if there was no ill intent.

Checking that manga I'm kind of eh on that one. Like, it's a non-human fantasy character (possibly an Oni, who are historically drawn with skin in many colours which we just can't tell in B&W). Even if we assume it to be ethnically-coded there's still the massive baggage of how modern fantasy races are derived to unravel which may or may not absolve sono. (That's is a very interesting discussion by the way, but I have to admit to not know enough about that, especially when it comes to the japanese adaption of many western fantasy tropes.)

Since you, girlswhokiss are together with arka the only ones to explicitly state to have found this work racist (in contrast to having a more general discussion about the undeniable colorist stereotyping), I just want you to point them out: What in particular is wrong about having a physically strong and tall women be dark-skinned? Especially since sono's aforementioned track record of drawing way more light-skinned buff girls? Just because a certain combination of traits can be (and frequently is) used with racist connotations mustn't mean it necessarily is racist. (Just imagine banning crime thrillers from having dark-skinned suspects and culprits.)

Being attentive to societal issues is a good thing, but please please please uphold the presumption of innocence. There's thousand of black-man-steals-your-wife NTR hentai out there more deserving of being brigaded.

last edited at Nov 7, 2026 3:19PM

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023
Hunaywaamaaijrh-orig

^ Well, you see, Roka committed the unforgivable sin of being a useless lesbian and just pining and yearning instead of asking her crush out.

Meanwhile Iroha did absolutely nothing and just got her pre-destined girlfriend literally dropped out of the sky in front of her.

Clearly, the moral lesson of this fable should be obvious and we are doubtlessly in the right to mocking Roka.

last edited at Nov 17, 2026 9:07AM

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023

The colourism/racism debate should probably consider that sono just really, really likes buff women and frequently draws them. So this isn't a case of "dark skin therefore big" but "big and just happens to be dark skinned".

I agree that there's a stereotype where muscular/tomboyish/outdoorsy women to be frequently drawn with darker skin, but I can't tell whether those are conscious stereotypes, subconscious stereotypes, or a fetishization of a certain appearance symptomatic of childhood exposure to a societal stereotyping (which is a whole other can of worms), or simply an exaggerated tan. Likely a mix of all four.

I also think you shouldn't conflate US-style racism with japanese racism as those aren't culturally analogous.

last edited at Nov 7, 2026 12:19PM

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023

Well this was weird. Weird pacing (not sure I followed with what was a flashback and what wasn't), weird drama, and really weird censoring. I absolutely love the Nanbaka school of gender expression, but to me this kind of fell flat.

This got serialized, huh? So, will it be a longer retelling of their story, or take place after both got buff, or..?

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023
Hv9d1h_aqaankv_-orig

Poke having fake ears but not real ones is opening a whole lot of questions.

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023

@ ponytail.girl at the one hand, I did not initially realize that the original posts were all by you (if there's no profile picture I treat everyone as kind of anons, my bad) and therefore reacted more harshly on what I considered a more common take. So, uh, sorry, I guess. At the other hand

Honestly, I got a bit set off by being accused of transphobia and told to read weird obscure creepypastas, so thaaaat's a signal that it's time for me step out.

What?

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023

Plenty of bollocks here that I won't even quote.

Magical Girl-ing here is pretty clearly a stand-in for the (not always, but dominantly) female experience of having a caretaking role thrust upon you and being expected to selflessly fulfill it until you're such a burnt-out husk you can't even imagine doing anything else. Childhood is the stage where you're still find yourself, and the regression here therefore representative of an opportunity to define yourself anew after being denied an identity for so long.

And even if we pretend theme and allegory don't exist or matter, I still fail to see how anything done here is creepy. They are, after all, not the sort of men in urgent need of castration. By that same logic I could pull out a mirror and ask you what sort of perverted looser consumes magical girl media well into adulthood; that's kinda sus, init?

Stop trying to read secret depravity into something moving and absolutely wholesome. Go write some "[Childhood hero] is actually in purgatory" creepypastas instead or smth.

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023

I guess there must be people out there who see a fresh corpse and think "well, this is the best place to have lunch"

Well, a million ants can't be mistaken, as they say.


The fucked up part is that everyone is laughing and happy because a girl died so they will not have class xd

That's called realism.

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023
Hh8m-gvxqae-msw-orig

^ They're in the previous one.

Zesc
Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023

With tapas shutting down next year, is there any exclusive baekhap worth reading? There's like ~3 dozen titles but those I recognize are also (legally) available elsewhere.

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023
Thing

^ 4 years and a remake latter, these are Chiharu and Ruka.

Zesc
Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023

Not just is p. 11 duplicate (feels like there could be a p. 10 missing?), but I also noticed that p. 1-24 are only 1280p wide, whilst the remainder is 2000p.

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023
Hvwygi0xaaaoxcp-orig

^ Kronii is so much into herself, the sight of her own enormity can effectively stun her long enough to make a getaway.

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023

Excuse me but I have to question Junna's reasoning here: if she has moral qualms about turning magical girls into concubines, then why did she work for the organization which habitually does that in the first place? (So far no conscientious objection to attacking civilians from her though #IDFthot)

Somebody here implied she used to be enslaved herself due to also wearing a blindfold, but she apparently still followed them after breaking free? Que?

Where are you getting that she still followed them after breaking free? It doesn't seem like she broke free until she got defeated by the magical girls at which point she very much stopped working with the evil org.

Subscribing to Bielna's "blindfolded ⇔ mind controlled" theory (imho a very sound hypothesis), there are multiple instances of her having operated as Evil General without. (At first I wanted to link the end of ch. 25, but that one's probably in the present.)

Besides, the dude seemed to address her as an equal (unless something got lost in translation) and where all concubines act as little more than henchwomen; no leap to assume she's been working as General on her own volition for some time.

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023

Excuse me but I have to question Junna's reasoning here: if she has moral qualms about turning magical girls into concubines, then why did she work for the organization which habitually does that in the first place? (So far no conscientious objection to attacking civilians from her though #IDFthot)

Somebody here implied she used to be enslaved herself due to also wearing a blindfold, but she apparently still followed them after breaking free? Que?