Forum › To you, the one I left behind discussion

sanshouowo Uploader
Output-onlinepngtools(4)
Homusaki Shikibu
joined Jul 10, 2021

Queen never cry

:)

Marlywalkwitmehiroki
joined Apr 4, 2020

Glad to see this uploaded here.

Furukawa Kagome
Img-thing
joined Jul 6, 2015

Queen never cry

:)

I guess I'm not the queen then :')

joined Jul 8, 2019

Dat last page - half-tempted to make a "Gothic era" joke for any historians out there, but I guess only two persons here would enjoy it. Oh, well, too late, With regards to Leonor.

Kuchisake
joined Sep 25, 2026

Historians will say they ware a good friends

2here3there
joined Mar 19, 2022

Historians will say they ware a good friends

I know this was meant as a joke so I do apologize for actually taking it more literally applied to the story, but I felt it was important to push back against this sentiment. I realize this joke functions as like a in-joke (honestly this joke helped recontextualize my feelings about history and this manga anthology, so in that way I appreciate your comment). I also figure this joke functions partly as criticism of historian institutions and institutions of power who often ignore that queer folk existed in the past. But for an anthology rooted in showing how sapphics have existed in all eras, and how that history lives on, to me the joke just seems a bit dismissive of those points.

The presumably historical newspaper Miku reads from does say "lover's suicide" which shows how people of the past did know about queer folk.
(Excerpt from the Wikipedia page about Class S culture.)

Although double suicides between women had been reported in newspapers since the late 19th century, a high-profile double suicide of two girls' school graduates in Niigata in July 1911 served as a major catalyst for public anxiety, bringing female "same-sex love" (dōseiai (同性愛)) into the spotlight of mainstream print media, such as the weekly newspaper Fujojo Shinbun [ja] (婦女新聞).[5] Educators and media commentators began actively pathologizing these relationships, introducing Western sexological frameworks to police female sexuality.[5]

The other point is that like, sure, historians exist as an institution, but it's not as if we work to preserve history. Instead of putting all the responsibility and power to those historical institutions, we can work towards perserving our presence in the world. Queer folk are our own historians, just like these two girls, Miku & Ayase, who in some way worked to preserve Kiyoku's & Ryoko's history.

Sorry again for writing so many words about a silly joke, but I do really like history and queer history so I have a fond spot for the folks I consider historians that are trying highlight queer history (shout out to the YouTuber J. Draper who has a lovely playlist about various pieces of queer history in the UK).

I really cherish this anthology inside my heart, so thank you for the translation.

last edited at Oct 15, 2026 10:42AM

Screen%20shot%202023-01-07%20at%2010.57.07%20pm
joined May 21, 2021

A hopeful conclusion to this anthology. May we live in better eras.

1pixel
joined Dec 3, 2010

...ಥ⁠_⁠ಥ

Hotarusquibbly
joined Feb 12, 2025

Really came for the throat with that ending didn't you :((((( fuck that's really really good

joined Jan 2, 2019

I value my mental health so I'm not reading this

last edited at Oct 15, 2026 11:36AM

E7970c69-edd3-4544-8de9-6a20ca0f7573
joined Aug 29, 2020

This was a good one. The young couple entering the dim archive of dark passions and retreating into a fleetingly bright ennui. How it feels to return home to my beautiful girlfriend reading the news after seeing my mother

Screenshot_20260501_000048_chrome(1)
joined Mar 24, 2015

...ಥ⁠_⁠ಥ

L...lit T___T

Images%20(1)
joined Dec 4, 2025

I look at the author and know i'm in for a deep one

(;´д`)ゞ

Download%20(8)
joined Feb 22, 2026

That ending... so sad :c making me tear up!

Enanano
joined Oct 16, 2020

this is why pride is so important until now
FUCK THIS IS SO GOOD

joined Mar 17, 2022

enjoyers of this oneshot must read the ends of a dream by sudou yumi

joined Feb 25, 2025

I get the idea and I think the one-shot is beautiful. But the grandma story takes more part of the one-shot, and the point is to see Heisei era. Even if the idea of Heisei era girls looking at the past is a good final for the anthology. I would have preferred if they actually showed modern oppression instead of past one to say the present is better.

joined Jul 31, 2021

The tags scared me, but what an unbelievably beautiful story

Nyarin
joined Mar 20, 2012

Losing My Religion plays.

Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

Even with the past tragedy, a beautiful chapter showing hope for the future. ^_^,

Img_3131
joined Nov 25, 2023

I get the idea and I think the one-shot is beautiful. But the grandma story takes more part of the one-shot, and the point is to see Heisei era. Even if the idea of Heisei era girls looking at the past is a good final for the anthology. I would have preferred if they actually showed modern oppression instead of past one to say the present is better.

i felt like the modern couple's dynamic was a little weak tbh, and if they had more going on it would've sold it better. as-is it feels like their relationship is just all off screen

last edited at Oct 15, 2026 4:50PM

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023

Oh wow the final entry in the anthology just kicked it out of the park, huh? Taking what was probably the most difficult era and turning into a poignant reflection on the entire anthology's theme, neatly tying everything together with one bittersweet bow.

Daz_kun_loves_yuri
joined Sep 17, 2026

I…I don't know what to say if was beautifly ssad.

Av2
joined Jun 5, 2025

skelly85 posted:

Historians will say they ware a good friends

I know this was meant as a joke so I do apologize for actually taking it more literally applied to the story, but I felt it was important to push back against this sentiment. I realize this joke functions as like a in-joke (honestly this joke helped recontextualize my feelings about history and this manga anthology, so in that way I appreciate your comment). I also figure this joke functions partly as criticism of historian institutions and institutions of power who often ignore that queer folk existed in the past. But for an anthology rooted in showing how sapphics have existed in all eras, and how that history lives on, to me the joke just seems a bit dismissive of those points.

The presumably historical newspaper Miku reads from does say "lover's suicide" which shows how people of the past did know about queer folk.
(Excerpt from the Wikipedia page about Class S culture.)

Although double suicides between women had been reported in newspapers since the late 19th century, a high-profile double suicide of two girls' school graduates in Niigata in July 1911 served as a major catalyst for public anxiety, bringing female "same-sex love" (dōseiai (同性愛)) into the spotlight of mainstream print media, such as the weekly newspaper Fujojo Shinbun [ja] (婦女新聞).[5] Educators and media commentators began actively pathologizing these relationships, introducing Western sexological frameworks to police female sexuality.[5]

The other point is that like, sure, historians exist as an institution, but it's not as if we work to preserve history. Instead of putting all the responsibility and power to those historical institutions, we can work towards perserving our presence in the world. Queer folk are our own historians, just like these two girls, Miku & Ayase, who in some way worked to preserve Kiyoku's & Ryoko's history.

Sorry again for writing so many words about a silly joke, but I do really like history and queer history so I have a fond spot for the folks I consider historians that are trying highlight queer history (shout out to the YouTuber J. Draper who has a lovely playlist about various pieces of queer history in the UK).

I really cherish this anthology inside my heart, so thank you for the translation.

Thanks for writing this!

Image_2023-04-26_102004495
joined Apr 23, 2023

Absolutely beautiful <3

To reply you must either login or sign up.