Forum › Would You Cry If I Died? discussion

4118232
joined Dec 27, 2019

I love you dark intrusive thoughts yuri manga!!!

Are the deaths literally, or just imagine? or one of them literal?

Imagined in both cases. The manga's gimmick is that she keeps imagining incredibly morbid scenarios, and that the exact construction and presentation of those scenarios is heavily trope-referential. What I enjoy about the manga, and I assume what some others also do, is that it's very self-aware without getting cocky about its self-awareness. Rather than using something like fourth wall breaks, that just tell you that the mangaka knows what they're writing, it shows you that they know what they're doing by hammering out five or six classic tragic yuri tropes in the span of a couple pages, each one distilled to the point that we only see the essential beats of it. It's subtle, but it's really only possible to make art like this, IMO, if you're very, very experienced with the genre you're riffing. I appreciate when an author plays with a genre they clearly love like this.

Hi quality post that I agree with.

joined Feb 25, 2025

I wouldn’t call these classic yuri tropes (they are not even common in the genre itself) but classic japanese tropes that are “mangafied” from novels

Icon_tinymila
joined Jan 30, 2017

lmao what?

Screenshot%202025-12-01%20231647
joined Nov 2, 2013

killing myself in front of you to forever change the trajectory of your life type shit

Internet_lied
joined Jul 15, 2016

Even though the intrusive thoughts hypothesis is more likely, my pet theory is that the deaths are all real: she is basically resetting the timeline every time her girlfriend dies.

"would you love me if i was a worm" type protag

That question has already been decisively answered, by the way.

joined Feb 25, 2025

Oh I am curious now is this translated from korean or is it originally in korean? Last one being less likely but some korean authors adopt japanese pseudonyms so asking just in case

last edited at Aug 30, 2026 3:49PM

joined Apr 16, 2022

I love how they both think the same thing, "I don't want to live in a world like this," whenever the other one isn't around

Book%20and%20cloakhbq1
joined Aug 1, 2011

This has nothing to do with the actual manga, but I feel compelled to ask why its chapters always show up on the front page in reverse order. I don't think I've seen that with any other upload.

Untitled
joined Dec 16, 2014

Maladaptive Daydreaming the manga

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023

Oh I am curious now is this translated from korean or is it originally in korean? Last one being less likely but some korean authors adopt japanese pseudonyms so asking just in case

I can see why somebody would make that mistake, but the SFX in ch. 3 isn't actually Hangul.

Tag%20rock%20snake
joined Aug 16, 2014

Chapter 3 is interesting to me because we get an outside look at how heavily the short haired girl disassociates when she gets lost in her daydreams.

The%20scientist%20edit
joined Mar 9, 2013

On one hand it's cute and kinda funny.

On the other it's kinda sad when you realize that they're possibly the only thing anchoring each other to the real world. At least they have each other...

JuniperPengold
Hotarusquibbly
joined Feb 12, 2025

This manga's really good at communicating punchy, powerful feelings of loss in just a few panels. It doesn't even need to make anything tragic actually happen, either, which speaks to the quality of the art. That one-two punch of her standing up at the edge of the roof, then being suddenly gone, only leaving her bag and her shoes to demonstrate that she didn't jump off, she just disappeared... really good!!
Anyway, I'm a HUGE fan of theropod dinosaurs,

JuniperPengold
Hotarusquibbly
joined Feb 12, 2025

Oh I am curious now is this translated from korean or is it originally in korean? Last one being less likely but some korean authors adopt japanese pseudonyms so asking just in case

I can see why somebody would make that mistake, but the SFX in ch. 3 isn't actually Hangul.

Yup, for anyone wondering, it may look to the unfamiliar eye like hangeul 와와와와와와(wawawawawawa), but it's actually the katakana ピピピピピピピピピピピピ(pipipipipipi)

joined Feb 25, 2025

Oh I am curious now is this translated from korean or is it originally in korean? Last one being less likely but some korean authors adopt japanese pseudonyms so asking just in case

I can see why somebody would make that mistake, but the SFX in ch. 3 isn't actually Hangul.

You are absolutely right. I read it very fast and saw bad

Yup, for anyone wondering, it may look to the unfamiliar eye like hangeul 와와와와와와(wawawawawawa), but it's actually the katakana ピピピピピピピピピピピピ(pipipipipipi)

Exactly what I saw lmao. The little circle being connected to the line/strip (idk the proper name) and line being more straight than normal made me confuse them

last edited at Aug 30, 2026 7:44PM

08f6612130a20845a480034c0567fbe1d8926209_hq
joined Apr 27, 2014

Humm why would anyone think such things..is she depressed? what is going on??? O_o

joined Jul 26, 2023

As someone with severe OCD and dissociative issues… this is painfully relatable LMAO

carmen_monoxide
joined Mar 27, 2025

least dramatic closeted lesbians

Screenshot%202026-08-22%2011.54.15%20pm
joined Aug 21, 2026

Codependency the manga???
also we just not talking about how scary she looks
https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/would_you_cry_if_i_died_ch03#4

25b298caf54a27761d774ba0b95ef848
joined Aug 29, 2025

i'm guessing the one girl is already dead and the other is like having delusions to cope with it

Bocchi2
joined Sep 2, 2022

So the other one is depressed too haha that's so good.

only leaving her bag and her shoes to demonstrate that she didn't jump off, she just disappeared... really good!!

Taking shoes off before jumping to death is a thing in Japanese media. Idk about in real life.

Hotarusquibbly
joined Feb 12, 2025

So the other one is depressed too haha that's so good.

only leaving her bag and her shoes to demonstrate that she didn't jump off, she just disappeared... really good!!

Taking shoes off before jumping to death is a thing in Japanese media. Idk about in real life.

Ahhh, I wasn't aware! Thanks for the correction. The panels still have a bit of that disappeared vibe though, since they don't show any of the action itself, only the before and after.
As for whether it's real or not, I would guess that's not really a factor here. Since, as I said in an earlier comment, this manga's gimmick is basically to take a well-worn, tragic yuri trope, remove all the fluff to leave only its essential steps, and then push those essential panels to melodramatic extremes. If girls in the stories take their shoes off before they jump, then the stock tragedy this girl's mind produces will feature her taking her shoes off, of course.

last edited at Aug 31, 2026 12:48AM

joined Aug 11, 2022

Eh, kind of pretty normal and relatable to decent number of people...People who hadn't had at least a few times of thinking about suicide or imagining their own deaths (Though most 'normal' people won't ever want to admit it) have either lived very happy sheltered lives or just has brains wired differently.

At least these two have each other to lean on to handle the harsh realities of life.

Would be amusing if long hair girl actually had the ability to travel back in time and the imaginary deaths did actually happen but judging from all the scenes and panels that seems very unlikely.

last edited at Aug 31, 2026 1:23AM

joined Jan 14, 2020

"Let me be your museum... I'll put your skeleton on display."

joined Aug 3, 2025

. . . this is like a cry for help via penciled high school girls /o\

That being said, I remember being a kid and thinking stuff like this. It would be in the middle of the night, and I would suddenly imagine what would happen to me if my parents died, and would burst into tears.

Woof. Thank God that stopped. Sometimes, being a kid is no fun at all.

To reply you must either login or sign up.