Forum › Posts by ponytail.girl

ponytail.girl
joined Aug 3, 2025

It really does read strangely.
If the mom had said:
"My life was falling apart. I could barely take care of myself, let alone two children." - sad, but understandable
"Your dad/family member wouldn't let me take you both." - makes sense, sounds plausible.
"I couldn't offer you a stable home, and I was afraid of dying in front of you. So I had to pick one child, the one who was a better singer" - makes. . . Okay no that still doesn't make sense and would be super messed up LOL

The mom straight up telling her daughter: "You were less talented. I didn't want you to make you anxious because of your lack of talent. So I picked your sister, and left you."
is just CRAZY!

ponytail.girl
joined Aug 3, 2025

Page 2: so the doctor's just going to violate patient privacy and blab everything, huh?

Page 3: whoa whoa is the doctor conniving a bunch of MINORS into pressuring their MOM about a life-changing, career-ending surgery?? So he doesn't have to do his own **** job??

Rest of the chapter: . . . I read it. Still don't get it. This chapter makes less sense the more I think about it lmao. Also, the mom looks like the same age as her kids. . . which is very disorienting.

ponytail.girl
joined Aug 3, 2025

Ohhh
I was wondering if Karin got the necklace from an ex, or from Hiro's dad.
Thank you for the explanations!

ponytail.girl
joined Aug 3, 2025

Why did Hiro get the urge to throw Karin's necklace?
Seemed like a massive dick move, and kind out of nowhere.
Did I miss something from a previous chapter?
I confess, I lost the story thread after the break between updates. ^ ^;;

joined Aug 3, 2025

AJDHRJE WHY DOES THIS NOT HAVE THE COMEDY TAG LMFAO
THAT THIGH --> STRAIGHT TO ER SCENE MADE ME BURST OUT LAUGHING

ahem
Also #goals

joined Aug 3, 2025

Ren really is a shitty person. Like she's leading Chitose on she says "Oh well I turned down her confession" yet on this date she didn't reiterate that and then even told her she could rent her again.

And then she has Mizuki who she can't stand but also enjoys being around how she can feel both at the same time is beyond me tbh. And now she shows up while you're on a rental date with the exact same girl she should have turned down in the first place.

Ren is a garbage human being.

One person's trash is another person's treasure!
At this point Ren could turn out to be a serial killer and I'd still root for her, her internal life is so layered and interesting.
Supporting women's rights and supporting women's wrong, especially when they're hot, messy, and intelligent \o/

joined Aug 3, 2025

Tongue-piercing girl endgame PLEASE

ponytail.girl
joined Aug 3, 2025

LMAO
these comments are darker than the manga
Funny as heck too.

ponytail.girl
joined Aug 3, 2025

it's funny to read the comments because there are clearly two separate interpretations that don't seem to mesh well together, the first is the literal "how are these women going to survive looking like children" and the second is the allegorical "wholesome ending for people who grew up too fast". I read the second one. I wonder if people who had childhoods where they "grew up too fast" tend to read the second one.

I think that's a great point!
Honestly, I got a bit set off by being accused of transphobia and told to read weird obscure creepypastas, so thaaaat's a signal that it's time for me step out.

Enjoy the discussion, y'all.

ponytail.girl
joined Aug 3, 2025

Plenty of bollocks here that I won't even quote.

Magical Girl-ing here is pretty clearly a stand-in for the (not always, but dominantly) female experience of having a caretaking role thrust upon you and being expected to selflessly fulfill it until you're such a burnt-out husk you can't even imagine doing anything else. Childhood is the stage where you're still find yourself, and the regression here therefore representative of an opportunity to define yourself anew after being denied an identity for so long.

And even if we pretend theme and allegory don't exist or matter, I still fail to see how anything done here is creepy. They are, after all, not the sort of men in urgent need of castration. By that same logic I could pull out a mirror and ask you what sort of perverted looser consumes magical girl media well into adulthood; that's kinda sus, init?

Stop trying to read secret depravity into something moving and absolutely wholesome. Go write some "[Childhood hero] is actually in purgatory" creepypastas instead or smth.

If they HAD been trans, it would have been heartwarming. Fighting for humanity for decades so they could have the body they were meant to have?
That's heartbreaking, and touching, and bittersweetly sad.

But roleplaying as kids?
If this was an allegory for trans-hood, it was a bad one, cause it's dipping into an area of fiction that IS commonly presented as uncanny.
Benjamin Button. Marvel comic book villains like Topher and Abigail from the Runaways (sorry, that's a deep cut). A villain in the book "The Rook" (won't name because it's a spoiler and that's a great read).

Also, this still is an issue that isn't resolved: Makoto CHOSE to hide her real identity, and used her once-in-a-lifetime wish to become a child to spend time with Sayakawa. Without consulting her, without knowing her, without even having the kind of relationship where Sayakawa would tell Makoto she was retiring. They were not close. Makoto approached Sayakawa under false pretences, and DID NOT TELL HER the life-changing decision she made, just to possibly maybe get close to Sayakawa, and thus the underlying intense pressure behind their interactions.
Sayakawa CHOSE to become a child, under the (incorrect) assumption that this girl that was visiting her was a normal girl, putting a HUGE burden of responsibility and TIME on this random child: that is a lifetime's worth of obligation. Haunting.
It did work out.

But, and this is definitely my personal bias at this point: I think there would have been a beauty and a grace in their aging together, and meeting as adults, rather than reverting and trying to go back and experiencing a second, false childhood.

ponytail.girl
joined Aug 3, 2025

Hear me out
Health and physical well being? Definitely.
Fame? Absolutely.
A support network of appreciative friends and family? They deserve it.
Financial security and a pension and vacations to the Bahamas whenever they want? You go girl.

Pretending to be children and playing with other kids while actually being 30+ and probably suffering from PTSD from extreme, messed up magical girl stuff?
Ehhhhh
Ehhhhhh

ponytail.girl
joined Aug 3, 2025

Uhhh this was a bit creepy.
Both women regenerated into children, without even asking the other person if they wanted that?
Sawayaka didn't even know Makoto's real name. Makoto was obsessed with Sayakawa, but they weren't even close enough for Sayakawa to tell her she was retiring.

Now a woman in 20's and a woman in her 30's are pretending to be children and playing in a park.
Which is
uhhhhhhhhh
Not super comfortable.

I don't know. If this was supposed to be wholesome and self-actualizing for them, it really missed the mark for me.

joined Aug 3, 2025

The NTR and uncomfortable SA threat isn’t something I expected from this series…it felt more Sword Art Online v_v

Agreed. The "gonna make her my concubine!" really felt jarring, and out of nowhere.

joined Aug 3, 2025

Chapter 26 feels like it's in a different storyline.
Hane never was as overt as to call Junna her first love, right? And the even if it's a time skip, either forward or backward, the way Junna is acting all blushy and shy again (seemingly genuinely, not as an act) feels out of sync with her Dark Souls-parry against Hane's fireworks confession.
It almost feels like there were two pitches for the storyline, and the author decided to write both??

ponytail.girl
joined Aug 3, 2025

I like that Ai lied, and said she was thinking about stargazing instead of her ex.
lmao
Is that weird?
But I feel like that was the healthiest, realest thing. Sharing how she's lingering over her ex won't solve anything. It'll just hurt her girlfriend. Sometimes (a lot of times) a person doesn't need to share everything they're feeling in the moment. Like they don't need to discuss EVERYTHING with their partner. Sometimes, I think swallowing regret, "grass is greener on the other side" feelings is the most adult thing to do.
It's not very happy. More bittersweet. But not opening fresh wounds can be an act of kindness.

joined Aug 3, 2025

Working with people is hard.
Working with kids is REALLY hard.
It kindaaaaa feels like Ms. Shiratori isn't cut out to be a teacher. She could have the best design skills in the world, and great at explaining things, but if she doesn't know how to step back and have perspective, sh may just end up burning out and ultimately causing herself, and her students unnecessary turmoil. . .

joined Aug 3, 2025

I don’t really understand why people get so defensive or maybe judgmental is the better word when their invitation gets turned down. If girly doesn’t like going to gatherings, that’s on her. ¯\ (ツ) /¯

I feel like that's pretty common.
Like when someone invites me out, they're taking a risk and putting themselves out there. If I turn their invite down, it can feel like I'm rejecting them as a person.
Not very logical maybe, but very human. I can see how it would turn people off.

joined Aug 3, 2025

Her best friend and boyfriend pulled that horrible crap on her, and SHE has to move away?

No wonder she doesn't want to have, or connect with anything/one every again. T-T

ponytail.girl
joined Aug 3, 2025

. . . HOW DID THEY HAVE SEX SO FAST
XD

hot though. :peace sign:

joined Aug 3, 2025

Holy shit
Ren really is surrounded by pain-in-the-ass women LOL

It really is like Taylor Tomlinson (comedian) said: you're either in the "I have a good-personality" group or the "I'm a model" group.

ponytail.girl
joined Aug 3, 2025

. . . this is like a cry for help via penciled high school girls /o\

That being said, I remember being a kid and thinking stuff like this. It would be in the middle of the night, and I would suddenly imagine what would happen to me if my parents died, and would burst into tears.

Woof. Thank God that stopped. Sometimes, being a kid is no fun at all.

joined Aug 3, 2025

holy crap a kid is missing and she's STILL making it all about her
Mitsuki is failing the girlfriend test harder than a teenager at the DMV

joined Aug 3, 2025

@ the title: SAME

ponytail.girl
joined Aug 3, 2025

I don't really see the point of this manga.
It's not advocating for lesbians.
It's not advocating for trans women.
It REALLY doesn't seem written by someone who is queer, or even has close queer friends.
So the way I'm reading this is it's written for straight people, by a straight person, who just picked up a random-ass premise for shock value, and the mangaka has neither the artistic nor writing chops to pull it off.

Personally, not offended by it. It just seems. . . Dunno. Very hollow and very schlocky.

ponytail.girl
joined Aug 3, 2025

I must say, when they said "Would you do ANYTHING? Just sign here!" I was expecting SIGNIFICANTLY more selling of souls to infernal powers.

Same!