Forum › The Blue Star on That Day (Ano Koro no Aoi Hoshi) discussion

joined Jan 14, 2020

Why the fuck is Ibu between Umi's legs. https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/the_blue_star_on_that_day_ano_koro_no_aoi_hoshi_ch20#29

Probably because its cold, given everyone has blankets over their legs and the constantly mentioned lack of heating in this school building.

Oh, I'd missed the blankets!

Previous page, I think Shou has a diagonal view of Umi with another girl between her legs, and is sweatdropping.

https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/the_blue_star_on_that_day_ano_koro_no_aoi_hoshi_ch20#28

joined Oct 27, 2018

I was really into this manga for a while, but I didn't really like this chapter. I don't know exactly what it is but it's like the longer this manga goes on the more it fails to pull me in. Maybe it's too much fluff now? Too slice of life? Too many characters? Or maybe it's just the tone is just different enough to be removed from what I initially liked. Though I can say I really don't like it implying Shou getting bullied is her own fault for not fitting in well enough or something.

370f6e22d5477fb96887976c3c5039f4410b136d
joined Oct 19, 2020

REALLY? THAT'S HOW FAR THEY GO?
HIKE HER PANTS UP, KISS HER THIGH, SHOVE YOUR FINGERS IN HER MOUTH
SOMETHING

Ykn1
joined Dec 20, 2018

Such a lovely Christmas (with a side of jealousy).

Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

I was really into this manga for a while, but I didn't really like this chapter. I don't know exactly what it is but it's like the longer this manga goes on the more it fails to pull me in. Maybe it's too much fluff now? Too slice of life? Too many characters? Or maybe it's just the tone is just different enough to be removed from what I initially liked. Though I can say I really don't like it implying Shou getting bullied is her own fault for not fitting in well enough or something.

It's not that getting bullied is her own fault, but they're children. They don't necessarily know the best way to respond to things that make them feel bad. Everybody has their own stuff going on. As you get older, you learn how to better interact with your peers, to understand that you might have done things that made them sad or uncomfortable. By keeping her distance and immersing herself in her own interests, she was sending signals to the other girls that she didn't like them.

The kind response to that kind of behavior (Edit: What we should teach kids, and what manga like this does teach kids by having them sympathize with Shou in the first place) is to assume that the person has their own reasons for being that way, and to give them distance while letting them know that if they ever want to approach you, they're welcome. The healthy and moral response is to just let it be and focus on your own business. But children don't always know the healthy response and aren't always kind enough for the kind response, so some respond to what they see as disdain with a like response. It doesn't make anything better, though, it just causes more strife and upset.

An eye for an eye leaves the whole world blind, and all that.

last edited at Aug 2, 2025 7:20PM

Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

REALLY? THAT'S HOW FAR THEY GO?
HIKE HER PANTS UP, KISS HER THIGH, SHOVE YOUR FINGERS IN HER MOUTH
SOMETHING

They are literally children

joined Oct 27, 2018

It's not that getting bullied is her own fault, but they're children. They don't necessarily know the best way to respond to things that make them feel bad. Everybody has their own stuff going on. As you get older, you learn how to better interact with your peers, to understand that you might have done things that made them sad or uncomfortable. By keeping her distance and immersing herself in her own interests, she was sending signals to the other girls that she didn't like them.

The kind response to that kind of behavior (Edit: What we should teach kids, and what manga like this does teach kids by having them sympathize with Shou in the first place) is to assume that the person has their own reasons for being that way, and to give them distance while letting them know that if they ever want to approach you, they're welcome. The healthy and moral response is to just let it be and focus on your own business. But children don't always know the healthy response and aren't always kind enough for the kind response, so some respond to what they see as disdain with a like response. It doesn't make anything better, though, it just causes more strife and upset.

An eye for an eye leaves the whole world blind, and all that.

It all just seems an awful lot lot victim blaming to me. Shou, and any more, self involved, introverted person is not at all and will never be even a little responsible for the ridiculous reactions of their peers. The whole thing is just reflective of our tendency to place extroverts feelings as more valid or important. There is no eye for an eye here, Shou did nothing to them.

joined Aug 21, 2022

How is it victim blaming when it was just Shou gaining insight as to why her old classmates reacted the way they did? It shows empathy and emotional growth.

Her whole character arc is someone who lived an isolated social life who gradually opens up to Umi and gains more friends as part of her personal growth, this is just her gaining more social skills.

It would be super weird if Shou pulled a Principal Skinner and went “it's the children who are wrong”.

joined Oct 27, 2018

How is it victim blaming when it was just Shou gaining insight as to why her old classmates reacted the way they did? It shows empathy and emotional growth.

Her whole character arc is someone who lived an isolated social life who gradually opens up to Umi and gains more friends as part of her personal growth, this is just her gaining more social skills.

It would be super weird if Shou pulled a Principal Skinner and went “it's the children who are wrong”.

That comparison makes literally no sense considering Shou is also a child, and a victim of bullying. Not some stubborn middle aged man. For such a neurodivergent coded character, this manga really does often fall into a nail that sticks out kind of attitude.

joined Jan 14, 2020

REALLY? THAT'S HOW FAR THEY GO?
HIKE HER PANTS UP, KISS HER THIGH, SHOVE YOUR FINGERS IN HER MOUTH
SOMETHING

They are literally children

They're high schoolers, and at least one of them has had fantasies about doing just that.

Nq9nh0qj
joined Oct 25, 2023

What a lovely chapter. It certainly melted my cold heart. Another comment mentioned not liking Blue Star as much anymore but I'm continuing to love it more with every chapter.

"more fun when it's just us girls" and leans into Shou. Followed by arm cling. Nae is not beating the gay allegations. Not sure if she's gay or is one of those false alarm straight girls that lesbians hate.

Meanwhile Umi gets to be one of those girls, unleashing her unconscious ladykiller moves on poor Ibu.

Not sure about Nae but she seems more physically affectionate with Shou than with the other girls (much to Shou's discomfort). https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/the_blue_star_on_that_day_ano_koro_no_aoi_hoshi_ch15_2#18 is the previous time Nae acted that way with Shou.

I am getting more and more convinced that Ibu has a crush on Umi though. Granted, Ibu is still probably a long way from realizing her own feelings. I could see her having a revelation about her feelings around the same time she finally puts together what's going on with Umi and Shou.

joined Jan 14, 2020

"arm cling" I said earlier, meaning grasping Shou's arm.

I'd missed Nae putting her arm around Shou's waist.

Recall that these two girls barely know each other!

I'd also missed the cuddle, with double sweatdrop but I feel that's less extreme than going for the waist... oh wait, Nae is doing shoulder cuddle and waist grab. No wonder Shou is double-sweat.

We've had a waistgrab before, when Umi scooped up Ibu, with Ibu being very conscious. But I chalk that up to Umi being "accidental ladykiller" with Ibu, friendly in a way that sets off false alarms. (Would love to learn why Umi is so friendly to Ibu.)

Nae... I dunno, girl, you're awfully sus.

joined Nov 9, 2019

Not sure about Nae but she seems more physically affectionate with Shou than with the other girls (much to Shou's discomfort). https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/the_blue_star_on_that_day_ano_koro_no_aoi_hoshi_ch15_2#18 is the previous time Nae acted that way with Shou.

Nae was giving a similar treatment to Umi at the beginning as well:
-https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/the_blue_star_on_that_day_ano_koro_no_aoi_hoshi_ch07#7
-https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/the_blue_star_on_that_day_ano_koro_no_aoi_hoshi_ch07#8

I feel like they both influenced each other with their tendency to skinship with people they appreciate.

Is Shou vegetarian? Nae doesn't let her finish a sentence so we can find out.

I'm not familiar with Japanase street food but, unless Japanese kebabs are commonly meat-less, Shou is not vegetarian.

last edited at Aug 5, 2025 7:02AM

joined Feb 6, 2018

The wholesomeness of this series is overwhelming. I love it. Knight Heron’s deserves kudos for bringing this series to life in English. Their afterwards are always interesting.

100% agree with you! Like I get a sweet story and an educational and fun afterwards. Like eating a sweet and savory dessert at the same time! Delicious and full.

joined Aug 21, 2022

That comparison makes literally no sense considering Shou is also a child, and a victim of bullying. Not some stubborn middle aged man.

It’s not a comparison, it’s a reference. The point is that it would be weird for Shou to think the other kids are wrong for not accommodating her antisocial attitudes.

For such a neurodivergent coded character, this manga really does often fall into a nail that sticks out kind of attitude.

This is how real people (and kids) act, I prefer a realistic story (as far as fiction goes) with characters behave in believable ways.

last edited at Aug 7, 2025 8:21PM

joined Jan 14, 2020

Wait, this was the third chapter? Aiiieee, that means the volume is over and we're back to the annual wait.

joined Oct 27, 2018

It’s not a comparison, it’s a reference. The point is that it would be weird for Shou to think the other kids are wrong for not accommodating her antisocial attitude.

It wouldn't be weird at all. I'm a real person who has really gone through that and knows others who have, and I continue and will continue to think that those kids and the real people like them are wrong.

To reply you must either login or sign up.