That wasn't a “normal” ending... it was disappointingly bad. With so many loose ends and couples left behind, the whole series somehow becomes a completely pointless waste of time for me... meh... just another new author for my personal blacklist....

i remember reading this since middle school, it even motivated me to learn english, that was about 10 years from now, times flies so fast! thanks to the translators for so many years of uploading this manga <3

last edited at Sep 16, 2025 5:44AM

ngl i hate it ending like this. honestly i could understand ayano/miyoshi ending like that, it kind of works for them but fuck, no other pair got any closure except eli/honoka and a few others that were basically wrapped up ages ago

still deeply appreciate the series tho, i loved it for years and years. i don't normally go for ecchi because it usually feels very silly, but this more restrained, realist style of it really captured me. and the art was beautiful especially after the big improvement in the first few

i stopped reading this years ago, but i'm glad mio/shizuka ended up together and had such a sweet romance while i was gone. they were my favs and iirc i stopped reading because of some drama with them midway. i'm satisfied!

It ended…. IT ENDED!??

It feels really weird seeing all these old series ending. Not just this one but also Hayate x Blade took me by a really big surprise. Now I’m all grown up… (supervise ur kids people)

It ended…. IT ENDED!??

It feels really weird seeing all these old series ending. Not just this one but also Hayate x Blade took me by a really big surprise. Now I’m all grown up… (supervise ur kids people)

with hayate its been done for years tbf, just someone actually picked it again and it's sequel, also no, kids should see yuri

I think there might be hope that Kishi might give us some nice treats with fanart in the future, maybe something a bit more explicit on pixiv or something. But I agree with everyone with the dissatisfaction of not seeing closure for specific couples. It might not be a nicely-written ending, but I would appreciate to at least see Haruka and Kanae kissing

Bummer, but we've still got so many precious memories. And this is a wonderful full circle moment. Virgins' Empire started with Miyoshi complaining about the heat, and she's back in the heat after 15 Lovely Years.

"I don't know if it will be one chapter or twenty" and it was one chapter and only this. It was pretty clear Kishi was running out of steam for some time on the series but I'm still disappointed that this was the end.

Thank you for translating this series.

Most of the couples were slice of Life stories with no real story arc to close. If I remember correctly, only 2 couples had significant drama, and those stories had a conclusion.

So I can understand not including the other couples in the final chapter and instead going full circle. But that doesn't mean I'm not disappointed withthis ending.

Personally, I'd would of been happy if it had also just shown the other girls in the background, doing their usual stuff. At least include them.

But oh well, I still love this series, and I'll keep including it in every survey hoping someday it'll be licensed in English.

How disappointing. It would have been better if, instead of the mini chapters, we have had endings. If feel when that started, it was the start of the ending. At least something. I don't know, not like, a lot of elaborated chapters, but at least one for couple. I have read this for so many years, and it feels like nothing. So sad. I understand that we have so many good chapters, but knowing they will have no end, I don't know...

No AiChie? No YuuMari? Aw man…

The Elisha and Honoka finale was so good, I was at least hoping for something like that for the “big” pairings. Sounds like I’m not the only one disappointed. Still, it’s hard to complain when the series has been going for so long and has been so good for almost the entire time.

We wouldn’t be here talking about it without Chads, so here’s a shoutout to the absolute legends that translated each and every chapter. And here’s hoping that Kishi’s next series is just as good.

It is true that I really wasn't into reading this but It was still very fun and i'm very, very happy/grateful to have read it. This is a true end to an era. Thank you so, so much to Kishi Torajirou and to Chads no Teikoku for all the very hard work put into this. It's not gonna be the same without this one. Looking forward to what Kishi Torajirou does next.

I've been reading VE for 3 years now, so knowing I'm not going to open dynasty and get excited cause a new chapter was uploaded makes me a bit sad ( •︠ˍ•︡ ) and I'm really happy my favorite couple got a nice conclusion, but I wish some of the other girlies did too... not sure how I feel about the sudden ending, but I'm just glad this manga exists and that I was able to read it ^^ ♡ thx for all the hard work, Chads!

https://youtu.be/o0WdKqMGItE
No closure for any of the other couples???
No Mask x Kaoru even please you're killing me here

So.. this is it? What about any of the other relationships? I demand time skip chapters so we get some more closure!

i did see Kishi-sensei's tweet and i understand the "ordinary day" ending concept, but ngl it still feels like a bit of a copout to only show 2 characters for a series that's known for its many beloved pairings. like just in the background doing PE class normally....

also i need ononana to sustain me :') the honoeli finale arc was AMAZINGLY done though so i can't complain too much!

Damn this is the lamest end ever, I'm glad Elisha and Honoka got their ending but what about everyone else? I can understand if the author is tired of the manga but I'd expect them to save some energy to give their characters some satisfying end.

I really enjoyed the experience of reading the series over the years but the ending was sadly unsatisfying.

Honestly, if we're being realistic, almost none of these girls end up together, that's just not how high school relationships work out. Most series get around this by focusing on a single couple/pairing, because while MOST people don't pair up for life out of high school, SOME people do, and the story can just be about one of those without stretching plausibility.

By making a series set in a girls school with so many pairings, relationships, and prospective relationships, you're left with the dilemma of either making an ending where many of the couples end up with long term prospects but it feels contrived and false, an ambiguous ending where you do a graduation arc and maybe a couple of them get together but mostly it's just leaving everything up in the air, or a time-skip/class reunion ending where you find out most of them broke up or never got together, and a lot of them married guys, and then it feels pretty shitty.

So while this feels on the face like a wildly unsatisfying last chapter, I could also sympathize with Kishi-sensei's decision to just go "eh fuck it the end." And at first that's what this looks like, but then I think about Honoka and Elisha's story, and I think there's something a little deeper going on here.

I think the reason he gave Honoka and Eli an ending specifically was because out of everybody, they had THE MOST to overcome if they were going to end up together, with Eli being an exchange student and leaving the country after a semester. Many of these couples have a whole year or two together before they graduate, many of them might attend the same college, and even if they don't, they're still all in the same country, they could end up at the same company, or find themselves in the same town, etc etc. But Eli and Honoka are going to have a literal ocean between them, and until the very end there it's kinda ambiguous if they're actually that committed or if they're just playing around. The fakeout in the ending where you start off thinking they fell out of touch works because honestly it would feel very real if they did. So the message here is:

"Look, we all know not all these girls are gonna get together, and I'm not going to dash your dreams by telling you which of your faves didn't work out. So instead of giving everybody an ending and deciding it for you, look, look here: The couple with the most obstacles is happily living together in quasi-marital bliss happily writing manga together, probably about Thomas Jefferson taking it in the butt from Tokugawa Ieharu. If they made it work, who's to say your favorite couple didn't?"

And y'know, I think that's probably about the best compromise between realism and narrative that you could probably do for a series like this.

last edited at Sep 16, 2025 9:01PM

I really enjoyed the experience of reading the series over the years but the ending was sadly unsatisfying.

Pfft....It's funny to me that I spent like 10 minutes crafting a comment talking about how the ending feels, and in the middle of it, here comes a post from somebody who uses the exact phrasing I used to describe a hypothetical dissatisfied reader.

The author has been tired of the manga for years, as shown by chapters being replaced by minichapters and the few "chapters" becoming extremely short. So it feels more like euthanizing your old sick dog than anything.

Honestly, if we're being realistic, almost none of these girls end up together, that's just not how high school relationships work out. Most series get around this by focusing on a single couple/pairing, because while MOST people don't pair up for life out of high school, SOME people do, and the story can just be about one of those without stretching plausibility.

By making a series set in a girls school with so many pairings, relationships, and prospective relationships, you're left with the dilemma of either making an ending where many of the couples end up with long term prospects but it feels contrived and false, an ambiguous ending where you do a graduation arc and maybe a couple of them get together but mostly it's just leaving everything up in the air, or a time-skip/class reunion ending where you find out most of them broke up or never got together, and a lot of them married guys, and then it feels pretty shitty.

So while this feels on the face like a wildly unsatisfying last chapter, I could also sympathize with Kishi-sensei's decision to just go "eh fuck it the end." And at first that's what this looks like, but then I think about Honoka and Elisha's story, and I think there's something a little deeper going on here.

I think the reason he gave Honoka and Eli an ending specifically was because out of everybody, they had THE MOST to overcome if they were going to end up together, with Eli being an exchange student and leaving the country after a semester. Many of these couples have a whole year or two together before they graduate, many of them might attend the same college, and even if they don't, they're still all in the same country, they could end up at the same company, or find themselves in the same town, etc etc. But Eli and Honoka are going to have a literal ocean between them, and until the very end there it's kinda ambiguous if they're actually that committed or if they're just playing around. The fakeout in the ending where you start off thinking they fell out of touch works because honestly it would feel very real if they did. So the message here is:

"Look, we all know not all these girls are gonna get together, and I'm not going to dash your dreams by telling you which of your faves didn't work out. So instead of giving everybody an ending and deciding it for you, look, look here: The couple with the most obstacles is happily living together in quasi-marital bliss happily writing manga together, probably about Thomas Jefferson taking it in the butt from Tokugawa Ieharu. If they made it work, whose to say your favorite couple didn't?"

And y'know, I think that's probably about the best compromise between realism and narrative that you could probably do for a series like this.

I agree with everything you say.

But, but . . . no more MahiMahi . . . sob

The author has been tired of the manga for years, as shown by chapters being replaced by minichapters and the few "chapters" becoming extremely short. So it feels more like euthanizing your old sick dog than anything.

He suffers from a serious kidney disease, which is probably why he's missed some deadlines and draws much less stuff for social media than he used to. I don't think the final HonoEli story arc is the work of someone sick with their creation.

The couple with the most obstacles is happily living together in quasi-marital bliss happily writing manga together, probably about Thomas Jefferson taking it in the butt from Tokugawa Ieharu. If they made it work, whose to say your favorite couple didn't?"

this made me LOL, I can totally see them writing that hahaha. but honestly, great analysis! I definitely agree ^.^