@Lilliwyt

It's not headcanon. It's canon. If you didn't play game, you have no idea. That's how game portray their relationship. And Madoka frenchiase was always gay with MadoHomu, but Magia Record has a canon lesbian character who wished for her crush to love her back, so it's not like they'd never go there. As I said, IroYachi is pretty much canon, without ever confirming it, but you'd need to be blind to deny it.

last edited at Apr 19, 2020 2:14PM

I see they are looking to have their own baseball team! respect

They made them as a duo unit in the game with art like this. Try telling me it's just people taking it too far.

last edited at Apr 19, 2020 2:22PM

That's not the part i consider as head canon, it's the " I view Mifuyu as Yachiyo's ex".I know that much there is a canon lesbian character and yada yada, there is enough talk about the gacha on the Dynasty Discord but when someone said "I view x as y''s ex" then it mean it's not canon because it's a personal intepretation of the relation, not how the actual relation is.

Edit : It's not that part i consider headcanon Nevri. I fully know the relation between this two.

last edited at Apr 19, 2020 2:24PM

Please keep the paragraphs coming, I'm enjoying every moment of it (even if it comes at the cost of my younger brother being frustrated with me occupying the computer for longer than 30 seconds)

Fine, Mifuyu and Yachiyo could be just friends, but since game already pretty much turned Mikazuki Villa into whole happy family with parents, children and aunty, we're just having fun with it. Sure Yachiyo and Mifuyu are only a childhood friends, who spend 7 years together fighting witches, then separate because of different opinions and later when Mifuyu disappeared, Yachiyo dropped everything and spend rest of time looking for her and when she thought she finally found he, but she turned out to be fake, she almost turned into witch from shock. I guess instead of girlfriends that broke up, they are only very close friends.

See, to me personally, the "Mifuyu is Yachiyo's ex" thing comes in huge part from the "bitchy ex" scene in chapter 6, before that point I was unsure what exactly the nature of Mifuyu and Yachiyo's relationship, but that scene just hits like a truck with that sense of "Oh, oh, oooh, so this is how it is, hm?" and everything just starts to slot into place really well... and it is one of the things that the anime keeps and does it really well, while the circumstances of the scene are changed with Mifuyu being indirectly invited there, but otherwise the context of the scene is the same and it is such a tense scene, cutting off the background music just to build up the tension, and even using Yachiyo's Doppel to show how much the situation affected her... they wanted to make sure to deliver the same context even in the different adaptation.

You want to make me feel bad to be the one who is saying is just friendship and not love. Fine, i know Madoka has a big lesbian vibe going for it but that doesn't mean friendship can't exist, especially when you're only two persons alone. I know it's a yuri site but come on, just because two girls stay a long time together, more so when they are fighting, doesn't .mean they're automatically gay for each other. Your last sentence sound like it's not possible that they're just close friends.

@Nevri By canon lesbian I assume you mean Rika right? I ship her and Ren (whose feeling are more ambiguous). Although even in the case of Rika she ends up regretting her wish because she feels the wish effectively brainwashed the other girl into loving her. She later confesses this to Hinano who doesn't think of her as being disgusting for the wish.

On an unrelated note, I'm still looking for a good partner for Ashley Taylor (NA exclusive magical girl) besides Riko Chiaki (11), Rika (already taken), and Emiri/Emily...

last edited at Apr 19, 2020 2:46PM

@Lilliwyt I'm messing with you. I agree it can still be friendship, but it also is very easily shipable and the experience they had could easily lead to romantic feelings. If they were boy and girl instead of 2 girls, I bet everyone would say they dated and nobody would ever question it (man, I really hate that double standard). Especially considering the kind of live megucas live leads to them bonding more strong with other megucas over their shared experience/fate, Yachiyo and Mifuyu could easily develop feelings for each other, even if they'd never acknowledge them and just treat them as a matter of fact/thought it was still just friendship, but as you said, technically, nothing is confirmed.

@Sakura Cartelet Yes Rika and yes I know her whole deal. Ren was my favorite girl when I first started playing and I rolled her banner and I ship her hard with Rika and lucky for me game pretty much made her and Ren canon so. Also I'm not sure what you tried to imply with spoiler portion.

@Nevri The spoilered part was from Rika's side story which details her wish and how she reacted after finding out what it really did to her beloved (who was not Ren at the time). She also talks with Hinano about this and Hinano consoles her (like a good big or in her case "little sister" would). I don't have Ren in my party so I have no opinion on Ren's side story which according to the wiki is a continuation of Rika's.

@EvelineClariss I don't think the mods will get too mad since we're discussing Magia Record ships, characters relationships (whether they are romantic, sexual, or otherwise) and how they relate to this image. Maybe anyway?

@Sakura Cartelet I know. I read it xD I just am not sure what you were trying to say by mentioning it. Also I don't really think telling backstories are spoilers. And we spoiled half of the main story from the game already.

Mods shouldn't get mad until we actually start insulting each other etc. Since we keep it civil, it should be fine, then again walls of text aren't really place in comments, but from experience I know it only happened because it's here. If we try taking it somewhere else, the discussion will die immediately.

last edited at Apr 19, 2020 3:16PM

There's also Ren's event which also shows Rika's and Ren's relationship.

Oh, something fun to mention, is that our friendly neighborhood adjuster Mitama actually ships certain pairings, including Rika & Ren(visible in Mitama's own personal training story), and Masara & Kokoro(outright calling the two of them out on being too dense to understand their own feelings at the end of Masara's personal story), and considering how Mitama's adjusting works, there is a good chance that she understands how these girls feel better than they do themselves.

Oh, oh, oh! Since we are talking RikaRen, while this doesn't progress their arcs in any particular way, there is a very touching scene in chapter 8 of the main story where, shortly after learning the truth about Witches, Rika is kinda freaking out(as are most girls), but Ren tells her that even knowing the truth and how harsh it is, she doesn't regret becoming a meguca one bit, because it led to her to meeting Rika in first place, which is just such a precious scene in general...

Right! That was great. First it was Rika that helped Ren find something worth living for and then it was Ren's turn to give the same support to Rika when she was at her lowest point. That was indeed very beautiful scene! Also that line that they become megucas to find each other. I'd disagree with it not progressing, especially since I feel like that line is as close as we're going to get to officially confirming them. Outside of duo unit. I don't know what the christmas story is about, but I bet it's gay.

It's probably best if you move this discussion to the official thread https://dynasty-scans.com/forum/topics/15913-magia-record-puella-magi-madoka-magica-side-story-doujin-discussion

The mods around here aren't exceptionally patient. If they didn't do anything about this they would actually be downright hypocrites. So it's better to try and avoid it.

It's so cute <3

She doesn’t want to show her to anyone else bloomersless

last edited at Apr 19, 2020 3:50PM

I'm taking further discussion to the linked page. Anyone who wants to keep discussing can find my comments there.

I only support MinamixAnastasia >.<
Still good art ;D

That’s Ranko, I’m sure Rin is busy with Uzuki
It on the tags: https://www.pixiv.net/en/artworks/49645566

last edited at Apr 19, 2020 4:03PM

Which pairing it is ? There is tag for 3 differents pairings.

Look at the hands. All three fingernails are different colors so it's probably Minami x everyone listed.

While this has basically been resolved on its own - and anyone who wants to continue should hop on to the discussion thread - I just wanted to clarify something.

If they didn't do anything about this they would actually be downright hypocrites.

This is probably more an issue of inconsistency rather than hypocrisy. Personally, as long as everyone is staying respectful and constructive, I don't see any issue. As Nevri said, it's entirely possible that moving the discussion kills it. We mods shouldn't be killing discussion without good reason, I'd hope.

I'm taking further discussion to the linked page. Anyone who wants to keep discussing can find my comments there.

And thank you! :)

last edited at Apr 19, 2020 4:50PM