should this be a spoiler for rebellion?

Tifo-chan banzai!

Homura is the DEFINITION of suffering

So far this is turning out to be very interesting

Was that a Jojo reference with the shooting stars at the end?

The woman and the boy in page 12 are those Mami met when she was new, from the PSP game. The boy was eaten by Gisela because Mami failed to save him from the barrier, and his mother went mad with grief.

OK was not expecting prequel to Rebellion.

HOMURA DID NOTHING WRONG

HOMURA DID NOTHING WRONG

I never saw the point of Rebellion. Your girlfriend is now a love goddess, and yeah, people don't remember her, but you do, and she's a comforting presence, and the Universe is still being saved, and the Incubators are proven wrong, and yeah, there's fighting and suffering, but it's way less and only enough to give life meaning. So, let's destroy all that, destroy your reputation and become a villain, because, hey, you can't wait until you die by natural causes and can reunite with her. I really think Homura did everything wrong. I realize that's not a novel perspective. Homura was the only non-ditzy character (sorry, Madoka) who was a pure hero, period. Until this point.

The only way to explain it for me is the endless Groundhog Day crap made her, finally, snap, and the movie was The Madness of Homura.

Very intense, but alas this made it obsolete.

On reflection, Rebellion was "The Disappearance of Kaname Madoka"

I never saw the point of Rebellion. Your girlfriend is now a love goddess,...

That's the entire problem. All Homura wants is for Madoka to be able to experience normal school life as a teenage girl. If it was just for love and being with the girlfriend then after the rebellion Homura could have easily set things up to be with Madoka but no, she tries her very best not to interfere with Madoka. Sure there is that whole 'oh she might remember and get her powers back if you get too close' but then like you said, what was the point then to bring Madoka back and not be with her?

Part of the dramatic tension between the two is the fact that Homura doesn't consider what Madoka wants and tries to force what she believes is the 'perfect reality' onto her, even though Madoka is perfectly fine with being everyone's savior. It's possessive and crazy but after being in hundreds or thousands of time loops it's not surprising she got kinda loopy.

last edited at Aug 7, 2022 1:29PM

Even if we invest grief in you, the resultant victims are few
Even if we control your movements, your time under control is short

Go ahead, wet your throat in this bowl full of despair

Damn, these lines would fit as a lyrics for a metal song

last edited at Mar 15, 2023 9:39AM

Even if we invest grief in you, the resultant victims are few
Even if we control your movements, your time under control is short

Go ahead, wet your throat in this bowl full of despair

Damn, these lines would fit as a lyrics for a metal song

yes true :3

Well this is a pleasant surprise!

This doujin does its upmost to turn Rebellion into a coherent story and it almost succeeds. Regardless, it's at least very good in itself. I appreciated how it used Rebellion and the original show to sort of critique each other, that was very clever. And I loved the orphan incubator, she's definitely best girl.

I do find it funny that Nagisa got randomly aged up at the end

Never thought I'd actually get to see the rest of this. Glad I did.

True story: Ch01 of this story impressed me so much, I actually started learning Japanese first and foremost to read the rest of this story, since the years and years of waiting for the translation that might never come while having the raw in my hand (author published the pdf freely on their pixiv) were more than I can take sitting idly. I was not very good at learning new language from scratch, and busy with other stuffs in my life, so the learning was slow, even now I can barely get the gist of what was said in the raw, but it was a fun process :)

Pretty neat read, thanks for the TL

Pog read

Loved this, it was a great read going from the depths of despair to the fulfillment of their wishes.

Now that the follow up movie for Rebellion has been announced I wonder if the author is going to go ahead with reworking all this?

I do find it funny that Nagisa got randomly aged up at the end

Mami’s only input on the new universe was making her jailbait girlfriend legal.

I never saw the point of Rebellion. Your girlfriend is now a love goddess,...

That's the entire problem. All Homura wants is for Madoka to be able to experience normal school life as a teenage girl. If it was just for love and being with the girlfriend then after the rebellion Homura could have easily set things up to be with Madoka but no, she tries her very best not to interfere with Madoka. Sure there is that whole 'oh she might remember and get her powers back if you get too close' but then like you said, what was the point then to bring Madoka back and not be with her?

Part of the dramatic tension between the two is the fact that Homura doesn't consider what Madoka wants and tries to force what she believes is the 'perfect reality' onto her, even though Madoka is perfectly fine with being everyone's savior. It's possessive and crazy but after being in hundreds or thousands of time loops it's not surprising she got kinda loopy.

the reason also come because madoka too dense
the reason homura became what homura right now is because madoka selfless, like "Oh I Will kill the gigantic witch that so strong i will 100% die"

like that just stupid, homura on the FIRST TIMELINE SAY TO JUST RUN AWAY and MAYBE Try to Recruit People to avenge everyone on mitakihara city and kill walpurgis
youre blind because all you say was homura and didnt see what make homura like that is because of madoka Selfless like i bet 5m dollar if madoka listen to homura and run away and potentialy recruit magical girl to defeat walpurgis the story will be more beautiful

edit : like madoka wish to save a fking cat is just dumb, even more dumb than sayaka wish for someone she love but dont have the courage to say it because hitomi love him even tho hitomi give sayaka a day before hitomi confess

that just dumb, heck i bet even if there is the most dumb character on anime i will be sure madoka is the number 1, combine that with her selfless act of hero thinking she was the strongest in the first timeline is just also dumb

if youre to stupid to understand, just imagine it like an RPG game and youre thinking youre strongest and go yolo to the boss and died and your friend mocking you for it, that what madoka is...if she isnt selfless from the very FIRST TIMELINE None of this is end like this, homura will be moemura and madoka can even became homura senior magical girl..

last edited at Jul 17, 2025 8:02AM