Forum › I Don't Know Which One is Love discussion

Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

Awfully pessimistic of you guys. Could just as easily be a sextet.

It's a harem comedy, conflict is the fuel in the furnace.

joined Nov 13, 2021

I just realized it,
The other girl obsess with her smell
The other girl obsess with her voice
The other girl like touching her
The other girl,like kissing her!
Only the teacher is normal

joined Mar 8, 2016

Senpai--those nails . . .

This is how you know that Roommate-san won't be the final girl. XD

Ioruu%20dr
joined Jul 13, 2014

Feels like this girl is going to get 'nice boat'-ed in the end of this ordeal

X10
joined Jul 14, 2017

Thank you for picking it up!

DivineAlexandra
Ihstarresi
joined Jun 22, 2018

I just wanna say I really love this manga. There's something about Tamamusi's style and writing that really vibes with me on this one. Can't wait for more

34
joined Aug 27, 2021

LMAO I'M SURPRISED THAT SOMEONE ACTUALLY PICK IT UP(Thank you) Like... I thought it would be that kind of manga, that left to be forgotten BUT IT'S HERE!!

RadiosAreObsolete
Img_20210321_022239%20(2)
joined Mar 6, 2021

So they all love her in parts: the way she feels to the touch, the way she smells, the way she sounds.... All very superficial.

Well, she is superficial herself anyway, so...

Mahiru
joined Aug 28, 2016

It's kind of like the blind men and the elephant but with different senses, except the blind men are anime girls, and the elephant is also an anime girl. And instead of trying to identify her, they're getting horny. Wait, maybe it's not like the blind men and the elephant...

Smol%20dankkonata
joined Oct 10, 2018

Oh my god this is amazing already what the hell??? I don't know where it's going but I don't know if I care I'm injecting it straight into my veins

(y)
joined Jan 9, 2017

The horny just exploded out of nowhere

But to quote a fanfic Dr Mundo: it's lust, not love

(y)
joined Jan 9, 2017

Wait, each of the girls represents one of the five senses! That's a fun bit of theming for a harem

I kinda see that for three of them but idk ab the other two, wonder the theme will amount to anything at the end

omg lol what if it ends up being none of them & mc ends up w a girl who has ties to all five senses

Idol - Touch

Prince - Hearing

Roomie - Smell

Onee-Sama - Sight

Kiss Demon - Taste

But that would also be hilarious (its the best friend)

Idol's totally sight (photoshoot, sexy lewds, etc)

Prince and roomie are straightforward, but rereading the teacher chapter the first thing she does is feed her- twice. I bet she's taste ^^_^^

And then the party girl would be touch? Which, she's super handsy I guess, idk

Riri certainly does give mixed messages, her chapter starts with a sight quote and ends with a touch quote and the chapter contains both touch and sight related things

Screenshot%202021-01-25%20004222
joined Jan 17, 2021

should've been "I Don't Know Which One is Thirsty"

Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

should've been "I Don't Know Which One is Thirsty"

The answer, evidently, is all of them.

Mask
joined Jan 6, 2015

I like the smell girl. She seems stern but affectionate. I also like seeing smell fetishes when it's not about stink and sweat.

6f1ccea7-b3f0-4820-814d-bccd7482bcd0
joined Mar 31, 2021

in love with this

Nishikino-maki-and-ayase-eri-3-love-live-school-idol-project-37571467-350-197(1)
joined Dec 1, 2018

Kiss demon Senpai, lol

1668296205361678
joined Dec 17, 2021

I want to think it's all love.

Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

I like the smell girl. She seems stern but affectionate. I also like seeing smell fetishes when it's not about stink and sweat.

I mean, she seems better than her first impression, but let's not forget her immediate response to her new roommate was "Your clothes stink, I'm going to strip you nude in your sleep and literally throw them away." which is....pretty not cool? But it does seem like she's less terrible than that by itself would imply.

Profile
joined Jul 22, 2014

i love the style and the premise so much. <3

Screenshot%202021-01-25%20004222
joined Jan 17, 2021

should've been "I Don't Know Which One is Thirsty"

The answer, evidently, is all of them.

Then it should be "I Don't Know Which One is Thirstiest"

My money is on the idol.

last edited at Feb 7, 2022 10:42PM

Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

Then it should be "I Don't Know Which One is Thirstiest"

My money is on the idol.

Safe bet. It's always the quiet ones.

Screenshot%2006-15-2022%2021.27.00
joined Mar 25, 2021

I just realized it,
The other girl obsess with her smell
The other girl obsess with her voice
The other girl like touching her
The other girl,like kissing her!
Only the teacher is normal

BET, bet shes obsessed with her appearance. Like cmon we've already crossed four of the five human senses!

Also I really like smell senpai so far, very weird combination of quirks.
Philosophical, smart, intimidating yet also has a cute, carefree side, and has a smell fetish!
Really loved how she almost topped our protagonist

joined Mar 20, 2012

This is super funny but at the same time she is getting so many stalkers, I'm confused. Ah well it's ok since she agrees to it I guess.

Tron-legacy
joined Dec 11, 2017

This is super funny but at the same time she is getting so many stalkers, I'm confused. Ah well it's ok since she agrees to it I guess.

Being into somebody and actively trying to spend time with them isn't "Stalking".

(Edit: I mean the clothes smelling thing is a little stalkery, I'll grant that.)

last edited at Feb 11, 2022 4:04AM

To reply you must either login or sign up.