Forum › Posts by Lightsteam

Lightsteam
Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

Anyone got a yuri manga where a protagonist is, for lack of a better term, a dumb simp ?
Like a big idiot who immeditely do something with a big dumg smile if a pretty girl ask for it.

I'm not talking about serious abuse stuff like (chirizokonai_no_hiraeth)[chirizokonai_no_hiraeth], but rather a comedic work.

Then the character can either finds someone good, learn to be less easily swayed whatever the case, really any direction is fine if the writing and comedy is good.

Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

Lovely.

This artist have been doing good work with the One Shot, so I kinda hope they make a serialised yuri manga one day. Though if and when it happens I hope it's not a monkey paw situation where the serialization happen to have a worse concept than the One-Shot.

Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

He SEES the vision !

Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

I'm surprised to see that you all liked it, the dialogues felt really unnatural to me, and the whole story had a stiff, unpleasant narration

I mean, it's not exactly meant to be a grounded realistic exploration of .... so the dialogue style works for this story.
Pacing admitedly is something else, but that's an issue for this kind of Oneshots.

Not the story of the year, but it accomplish it's purpose of well.

Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

Holy goly, this yuri manga is yuri as all get out. I hadn't seen such unironic display of onee-sama in years. This is beautiful.

Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

Hoyorin is goated.

Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

No one ship them stronger than Captain Narita.

edit: Pretty sure anyone trying to argue what specific orientation is Aya is putting much more effort in asigning her a label than she herself does. She love Mitsuki,
Sometime we all gotta stop overthinking or classifying everything. She loves Mitsuki, there's not place for anyone else guy or girl, that's about all anyone needs to know here.

last edited at Oct 26, 2026 1:03AM

Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

I kept meaning to read that one, starting it and liking it, then forgetting it until i remember it month later, restarting it. Not being able to read it for whatever reason etc. Guess i'll finally just read it now.

Lightsteam
Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

I wasn't sure about the dynamic but after reading 1.2 and 1.3 this is just the right kind of perveted idiot i like.

Also since they're leaving together and seems like we're going to get some chapter about their at-home life, should this also get the Roommates tag?

Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

More like "I might fall for my best friend".
Super cute.

Lightsteam
Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

I think A Story About Doing XX to Girls From Different Species is kinda like that, not very introspective, though, quite the opposite even.
Aside from that, that's typically the "I know i have read that, but can't think of it on top of my head".

Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

Dowoooaaaw, tmfly's art is so squishy and cute in this one! Seriously, I think this is the squishiest it has ever been.

last edited at Oct 7, 2026 2:58PM

Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

Oh yeah, Class rep yuri ! (public moral comitee in this case, but i'm talking about the character type, not the literal function). Like tomboy or gals, they go well with everything.

EDIT: And the class rep type is the top, AND it is a manga where one of the girl tries to win the battle of teasing but fail ?! Blessed be you, Torii Shizuku ! I shall go to pixiv and fav the original post as a show of grattitude.

last edited at Oct 4, 2026 10:38PM

Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

She showed off like that on live TV !
I swear this girl is like the combative herbivores animals, her first instinct if to try to run away, but if put in a situation when she can't, she just attack and ram into things like a rhino or a angry deer asserting dominance. No middle ground.

Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

This is the second yuri manga about an overworked and exhausted 30 years old woman who get pampered and healed by a stalker i read this month. Which is not a lote but it's funny it happened twice.

last edited at Sep 24, 2026 7:04PM

Lightsteam
Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

^Like Amasaya in that it is about an established couple? The personality of the characters? Is there a gyaru in it? Was it a long serie?

Fews I can think of (excluding recent ones like Gal to Gal yuri and Childhood Friend, Big Love since you mention it's pre-2020):

Shino and Ren
Boyish Girl x Gyaru (and from the same author Boyish Girlfriend)
Tomoko & Mitsuki

last edited at Sep 22, 2026 8:15AM

Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

These rooms are getting more and more specifics.

Lightsteam
Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

^We have the Dark Knight already (Unless there is another Dark Knight Manga I don't know about.
Otherwise, for requesting things to be added to the site, heads here: https://dynasty-scans.com/requests

Lightsteam
Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

The fact that it was first kiss for both of them, but they were both very willing to kiss (just to verify the rumor, of course) is the cherry on top, or rather the strawberry on top.

Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

Gotta say, i'm pleasantly surprised (not too surprised) with the tone and direction this manga went with. Not having read the One Shot, At first, due to Lulu's massive...well everything really, and the premise of her pulling the ultimate u-haul from the other side of the universe i thought it would try to go more wacky-hijinks comedy with maybe some romantic or dramatic moments here and there, but wouldn't quite be able to get it right. . But instead it's focused much more directly on the emotions of the characters and the comunication between them, some drama, and just a bit of wackyness here and there, which is much better for it. I hope it can continue for a while to develop and show the two slowly getting more intimate.
(Don't get me wrong, wacky hijinks over the top comedy are also fine, but this isn't the vibe for this).

Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

"Childhood friend will always lost" has went so far that "anthology of childhood friends will definitely get together" become a thing lmfao

Really hope some more chapters will get posted.

Funny enough, childhood friends romances are actually very common. Even before self-aware "parodies", the amount of childhood friends who do ends up together was probably larger than those who didn't.

Lightsteam
Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

The rare, looks like a One-shot, but it's chapter 1 and we're getting more. The opposite of the more common "makes that a serie!" one shot.

Lightsteam
Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

^It is, it's even credited as such. (Princess Knight is the English title). I'm more surprised by the fact it seems to be official. I knew we'd get a new take on this one sooner or later, though so not too surprised either.

Is the series news to you? it was in the anniversary magazine TezuComi, there's a bunch of Tezuka stuff in there.

Honestly I find it pretty lacking, it's cute, it's good. But it just feels like any modern fantasy/adventure manga.
I guess I've been spoiled by other retelling of Tezuka's work. Even the art, while good isn't anything unique.

Guess I'm just a sucker for transcoded yuri. I'm really excited to get further into this one :>

I had heard of it 1 week before this was uploaded here, in a conversation about the 2008 Hanamori Pink manga. My comment wasn't very well formulated even though i edited it several times, because i didn't realised how sleep-deprived i was.

Don't get me wrong the trans-coded part is welcome since it ties into the themes of gender identity of the original, i personally love stories with handsome girls in masculine clothings. And while the original wasn't Yuri, i am not going to complain about that being the yuri fan that i am.
But that's kinda precisely my problem. The original was about Saphire being born with both the heart or a man and a woman, you'd think a modern rewriting of this that can focus on and explore the themes with more depth and speaks of gender-fluidity or the likes would just write itself. But aside from Saphire crossdressing, it seems mostly like the "adventure and huge knockers and skimpy outfit" you could see in all sort of manga nowadays. Which isn't necesarilly bad. like i said, this one does seem cute and fun. I'll read more, and i'll probably be more positive about it if it wasn't an adaptation of my beloved Princess Saphir, but if anything the theme where stronger in the ogirinal. I don't expect everyone to have the ambition of Naoki Urasawa's Pluto, but i just feel we can so obviously do better with the premise.

Haven't seen Ribbon Hero yet (i don't have high expectation for it), and there is the 2013 manga by the writer of Tasihou Yakyuu Musume (RIP) , but i have no way to read this one to the point i wondered if i gaslit myself into thinking it was real (writer also did a Golden Bat adaptation that it cannot read either).

Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

To me Yuri is a lesbian umbrella term so I don't agree with the idea of separating the two. Anyway, the twist the end was definitely creepy but I guess not entirely surprising lol

See; that's a perception a lot of people have , especially in the west, but she's right. Yuri refer to a genre. It obviously have ties with lesbians, but the two are, in fact, different things. Of course, some lesbians will like and write yuri, sometimes even putting a realistic spin to it. Or (half-)jokingly refer to real life stuff as "yuri".
Take our definition of yuri here on Dynasty-scans, we have a clear cut "it's yuri if theres are canon wlw" which is good and practical for tagging purpose, but that's not the "real" definition (to the extent that there is such a thing as a real definition for such a thing). A lot of things that we will say are not yuri because they're not explicit enough so it's subtext would just fall into yuri because they do fit in the genre. Meanwhile sometimes women writting manga that aim to be a reaslitic depiction of LGBT will prefer using other terms, sometime to the confusion of reader who don't see a distinction.
Heck i don't remember which manga it was that had people arguing in the comment section of a certain now-defunct manga pirate site that two characters wouldn't get together because the author had say "It wasn't yuri", when to me it was pretty obvious that the author just meant it wasn't in that genre.

I wouldn't use the term Yuri in real life though I do think Yuri manga/anime are lesbian. Where I don't think a story has to be realistic to be gay or lesbian, just as a straight romance that's idealistic and maybe fantastical is still hetero. I just don't think disqualifying a ton of the works on here as lesbian is a good thing to do personally.

The issue isn't that a story that isn't realistic isn't lesbian, many yuri manga will use the L-word even. The point is inversely that the aim of the yuri genre isn't necesarily to say something about lesbians and that depiction of lesbians don't necesarilly fall into the yuri genre. The two have ties, obsviously, "lesbian" is in the lexical field of "Yuri". But the two terms are not synonymous.
And the comparison with het doesn't really work, since...obviousely straight people don't have the same history and het romance don't have the same history as yuri and aren't a specific subgenre, they're just romances (the equivalent would be that lesbian romances are still lesbian romances no matter how idealistic or fantastic they are).
And of course, the whole Yaoi, Bara, Gay Men is a whole other different beast altogether.

last edited at Sep 1, 2026 6:33PM

Ichimatsu_kohina_11153
joined Jul 25, 2014

I was wondering why a bunch of Manga i happened to read around the same time a short while back are getting uploaded in a row, before i remembered i read them when i was looking at the scanlator page on Mangadex or somewhere.

At least from what I've heard, the most unrealistic thing about this is a high school girls' restroom being a suitable place for heartfelt talking and even a confession. All I've heard from the women around me was how filthy and disgusting they were.
Maybe that's a Japanese cultural thing and they're much cleaner and less smelly than in Europe...

Interesting to see a yuri work from Matsuda Mai. I should get back to her "main" het series some time. Kinda stopped reading about ten chapters back.

Can't talk about the rest of Europe, but the restrooms in my high school (France) where cleans and not more weary than the rest of the school, And let me tel you it was no high class school so i have to assume other school weren't worse. Probably not where people would have a heart to heart since... you know, toilets. But i do know some chicks, including that one flanel wearing girl in my class had gay sex in the stalls, but that was rare (as far as i know at least).