Forum › Girly Debut discussion

Capture%20d'%c3%a9cran%202023-07-16%20161106
joined Jul 16, 2023

I was NOT EXPECTING that yandere face. I really love the art style of this manga, and love it even more each chapter !

SmallFriendlyScorpion
Not%20a%20single%20thought
joined Apr 25, 2020

...I still stand by what I said, Kitano's the best (yandere or not)

if the catgirl's not a misdirection that WOULD explain all the nervousness and sweating

Jesus
joined Sep 3, 2022

oh no, fuck kitano, he's a weirdo who wants to out the girl, you'd think a crossdresser would be more thoughtful

yaoi with anyone besides kitano

Img_2249
joined Mar 21, 2025

Forgot to say something from my last comment, it seems that Eru also came to this school hoping to get a girlfriend, and he also dislikes the idea of becoming friends with Girly and Kitano...but for some reason he also crossdresses. That's kind of curious. Does he believe that looking like a girl more will boost his chances of scoring a girl's love points, or is that just how he is?

Also that...poison, hopefully Kitano puts it to good use, because if he doesn't, someone else definitely would, and that's going to end up crazier than now...

joined Feb 25, 2025

Forgot to say something from my last comment, it seems that Eru also came to this school hoping to get a girlfriend, and he also dislikes the idea of becoming friends with Girly and Kitano...but for some reason he also crossdresses. That's kind of curious. Does he believe that looking like a girl more will boost his chances of scoring a girl's love points, or is that just how he is?

I think we will have some It Doesn’t Make Sense cases in the classroom, like, I’m sure others co-ed school exist who are close, there is no reason on going to this one lol

Maybe two options, the author didn’t think thing through and just made the whole class crossdress because the only think he thought was the main idea of “Girly have to find out” and didn’t notice the plot-holes
The other option, someone asked everyone to dress like this the day before class started, a “mastermind” type of situation

last edited at Jun 13, 2026 1:30PM

Brevity of Mammals
Brainsucker-square
joined Sep 13, 2025

And Eru goes straight to the top of my Secret Girl list. That was definitely overcompensation for something.

Icon_tinymila
joined Jan 30, 2017

I hope it turns out Kitano is trans so I can keep on supporting women's wrongs.

Img_2249
joined Mar 21, 2025

And Eru goes straight to the top of my Secret Girl list. That was definitely overcompensation for something.

Hehe, solid guess over here! But rereading chapter 1 tells me that whoever the girl is, she's going to keep watch on Girly and his Kitano buddy for a while, since he screwed his reputation on the first day of school for the sake of the secret girl. She may lay low for quite some while before actually showing up, and if it comes down to it, I wouldn't be surprised if she crossdresses as a boy to hide from the spotlight. Not to mention she's literally the only girl in the whole school, and not just Girly's class.

And I probably would guess Eru's letting Girly and Kitano take the risk of finding out the girl for sure while he stay in the background. It has already been established that openly speculating any person's gender here would be quite rude, since finding the imposter would mean throwing her to the wolves. The only method I can see working is the process of elimination, because there's no way any student who's not in the know can pinpoint just one person. 9 out of 10, they'll fail again before (probably) forming a solid plan.

Forgot to say something from my last comment, it seems that Eru also came to this school hoping to get a girlfriend, and he also dislikes the idea of becoming friends with Girly and Kitano...but for some reason he also crossdresses. That's kind of curious. Does he believe that looking like a girl more will boost his chances of scoring a girl's love points, or is that just how he is?

I think we will have some It Doesn’t Make Sense cases in the classroom, like, I’m sure others co-ed school exist who are close, there is no reason on going to this one lol

Maybe two options, the author didn’t think thing through and just made the whole class crossdress because the only think he thought was the main idea of “Girly will have to find out” and didn’t notice the plot-holes
The other option, someone asked everyone to dress like this the day before class started, a “mastermind” type of situation

That makes sense, because Eru sounds definitely doesn't sound like those who actually take crossdressing that seriously. He just ... has those clothes on for some reason, and if he came here to get a girlfriend then I do not believe crossdressing against your own preferences is the way to go.

There exists people who try to do this for the sake of blending in with girls, and frankly that's just lying. I know it sounds cheesy but people who were honest with themselves and are consistent gain more trust.

joined Feb 25, 2025

oh no, fuck kitano, he's a weirdo who wants to out the girl, you'd think a crossdresser would be more thoughtful

I get that the method is bad but if we go by that logic Girly is also a “weirdo”. By that logic even the whole premise of the manga is weird, out girls to see who is the “real” girl. Kitano is doing the same as everyone really, for different reasons obviously but still nothing specially evil.
If Kitano does that, she can just apologize like Girly did when he humiliated her.

last edited at Jun 14, 2026 12:59PM

Brevity of Mammals
Brainsucker-square
joined Sep 13, 2025

Reading this series does make me feel a little bit like one of those Twitter phrenologists who pour over pictures of celebrities to work out who’s secretly trans (all of them, apparently), but that is very plainly not the author’s intended vibe. Better to take the mystery in the spirit that it is being presented. It’s just more fun that way.

Random transbian dragoness
Image-22
joined May 19, 2026

Is girly in the closet a metaphore ?
Also tucking exist, just saying...
And Kitano is definitely a trans girl, the dynasty tag is here >:)

Img_2249
joined Mar 21, 2025

Yep, that confirmed it. He's crossdressing for the sake of getting girlfriends. And Kitano's right, he's technically decieving them. I believe he wouldn't get so many girls' contacts as a man, and that's reasonable. People of the same gender be friends easier because usually friends of the same sex wouldn't want to have sex with each other on default.

Good news is that they'll be more comfortable, but bad news is that none of them would see you as a potential romantic partner. Because no matter what you say about 'love is love', gender and sex undoubtedly plays an enormous part for most people's romantic relationships.

And despite all that, Girly actually managed to make him feel flustered with his appreciation. Very interesting, how much charisma is in his stats?

And finally, their plans to tackle the girl is actually quite brilliant, albeit a bit pervy, especially since they're letting the only one of the group who looks like a boy to do the peeping.
I wonder what's going to happen next, and more importantly, I would like to know how they're going to explain it if they eventually get busted. But no worries, this one's likely a boy as well, so no gender problems. (still quite curious about how did that person do so well in crossdressing though)

Nyarin
joined Mar 20, 2012

Midori is a super girly name.
The girls Eru picks up think he's a lesbian and are going to be pissed.

Capture%20d'%c3%a9cran%202023-07-16%20161106
joined Jul 16, 2023

Kitano is so cute I love her, she's so precious

Drop-your-favourite-sua-fan-official-art-and-ill-rate-them-v0-6mdt3s3iafof1
joined Jan 22, 2026

this is genderfuckery the manga

Drop-your-favourite-sua-fan-official-art-and-ill-rate-them-v0-6mdt3s3iafof1
joined Jan 22, 2026

kitano is transfem tho, as for the others who knows, too early to tell. i would love it to go the t4t yuri route tho

Ava-min
joined Dec 8, 2022

My prediction based on the first few chapters would be that Girly suddenly feels bad about peeping and bursts out of the hiding place to stop his classmate from undressing in this situation - once more revealing his nice personality and how he is constantly concerned about the well-being of others. This will then make yet another 'girl' develop a crush on him, and then 'she' either reveals the truth by her self, or it gets revealed by accident (or it remains hidden for the time being).

joined Aug 21, 2017

"haha bro i totally crossdress just to pick up chicks and not because i like it bro haha trust me"

D05536d6-01d1-4527-9102-4cc772fad5ed
joined Jul 6, 2020

My prediction based on the first few chapters would be that Girly suddenly feels bad about peeping and bursts out of the hiding place to stop his classmate from undressing in this situation - once more revealing his nice personality and how he is constantly concerned about the well-being of others. This will then make yet another 'girl' develop a crush on him, and then 'she' either reveals the truth by her self, or it gets revealed by accident (or it remains hidden for the time being).

it would be a very bold move to actually have the "real girl" be revealed so early, but then again I also thought that Kitano's whole shtick would be dragged out for the whole series, and then the author impressed me by directly tackling it in the second chapter. This series continues to surprise me so I'm looking forward to see where this goes regardless of the outcome of the ridiculous peeping gag

Bambinessa
joined Aug 2, 2023

Also tucking exist, just saying...

Different idea: intersex. If they have genitalia in-between a clit and a penis but no (external) testicles, they might prefer feminine underwear. And they could as well be a boy, at least legally (either because their family needed a male heir, or a myriad other reasons) regardless of how they're self-identifying.

Now I don't think this manga will go there, but as Cornonthekopp wrote, this manga has been full of surprises so far, and I wouldn't mind the woefully scarce rep.

SmallFriendlyScorpion
Not%20a%20single%20thought
joined Apr 25, 2020

is everybody's "boy" mode going to effortlessly serve like Eru's did because yes please

Vashu
joined Apr 2, 2017

yeah no this is just transphobic schlock idc how you wanna fool yourself into thinking this is that progressive or accepting bc that balls joke is framed so ugly and not in a "laughing with you" way. "no balls haver would EVER wear panties... because of their big BALLS har har" also proving the point someone made about "genderfuck" being tme folks fetishizing a perceived wrongness of transfeminine bodies and wishing they could fully inhabit our bodies and lives as a final conquest of them. jesus fuck some of you have an endless reservoir of goodwill for proven transmisogynists/ transmisogynistic tropes bc you really dont think all too differently, just again, people want the appearance of allyship. I didnt even get to the "preying on lesbians by presenting female" part. Classic bit of transmisogyny faced by trans lesbians.

ponytail.girl
joined Aug 3, 2025

Not a fan of them being so obsessed with who the cis girl is, they perv on someone changing.
That's a straight up crime. -_-

Ava-min
joined Dec 8, 2022

Just saw that the manga is already completed with 4 volumes / 32 chapters.

Lifeisfunguys
joined Jun 24, 2026

whats he gonna do if its a dude

To reply you must either login or sign up.