Locked

Forum › I Reincarnated as the Heroine in a Yuri Game, but for Some Reason That Thing Was Still There! discussion

joined Feb 27, 2017

I don't get it, this isn't a trans manga. I think about wanting to be a woman and in a lesbian relationship all the time, but that doesn't make me trans.

Ask any of your guy friends how often they think about wanting to be women and/or want to be in a lesbian relationship.

Rsz_1screenshot_2021-08-18_at_11-24-04_the_idolmaster_cinderella_girls_fr%c3%a9d%c3%a9rica_miyamoto_shiki_ichinose_%e3%83%ac%e3%82%a4%e3%82%b8%e3%83%bc%e3%83%ac%e3%82%a4%e3%82%b8%e3%83%bc_-_pixiv
joined Apr 25, 2018

For all new eggs that hatched because of stupid internet debate: I'm sorry and congratulations!

Junnnnnnnn
joined Jun 22, 2019

I don't get it, this isn't a trans manga. I think about wanting to be a woman and in a lesbian relationship all the time, but that doesn't make me trans.

Ask any of your guy friends how often they think about wanting to be women and/or want to be in a lesbian relationship.

But all of my closest friends are sapphic women.

joined Apr 16, 2022

I don't get it, this isn't a trans manga. I think about wanting to be a woman and in a lesbian relationship all the time, but that doesn't make me trans.

Ask any of your guy friends how often they think about wanting to be women and/or want to be in a lesbian relationship.

But all of my closest friends are sapphic women.

Ask them too, for a control group

Illustration5
joined Aug 31, 2017

I don't get it, this isn't a trans manga. I think about wanting to be a woman and in a lesbian relationship all the time, but that doesn't make me trans.

I really like Bara a lot. I really like to see two boys chuu each other... Never once i fantasize about being a big hairy man to kiss another big hairy man... reconsider some things maybe

Img_3131
joined Nov 25, 2023

I don't get it, this isn't a trans manga. I think about wanting to be a woman and in a lesbian relationship all the time, but that doesn't make me trans.

i'm a cis girl. there is absolutely nothing that could convince me to be a guy, even temporarily. the concept is already nauseating. do they have certain things easier in life? yeah, probably. i've never wanted to be one. when people see my autistic lesbian self irl and assume i'm nonbinary or something, it makes me sad. i have no desire to be anything but a woman. so, all that said, you're probably less cis than you think lol.

won't be following this one because the humor isn't my taste, but i wish the scanlator the best.

__akiyama_mizuki_project_sekai_drawn_by_ririru__aef7569108d461f730828c198e920bc8_1_1_1_1_1
joined Mar 9, 2024

I don't get it, this isn't a trans manga. I think about wanting to be a woman and in a lesbian relationship all the time, but that doesn't make me trans.

Ask any of your guy friends how often they think about wanting to be women and/or want to be in a lesbian relationship.

But all of my closest friends are sapphic women.

Maybe ask some het women friends that are into bara/yaoi (no need to be close, just close enough to ask these questions :P), too, about whether they fantasize of being a man and fall in love with other men.

I really like Bara a lot. I really like to see two boys chuu each other... Never once i fantasize about being a big hairy man to kiss another big hairy man... reconsider some things maybe

Today I learned Bara and Yaoi are not necessarily the same thing. Thank you.

last edited at Aug 21, 2025 9:55PM

Wtf%20dog
joined Sep 7, 2024

For all new eggs that hatched because of stupid internet debate: I'm sorry and congratulations!

For realllllllllllllllllll.

joined Aug 11, 2022

RIP MC...didn't even got a A-Cup at best lol...But yeah I think this is definitely a Trans manga and MC is trans which is kind of obvious due to his (Her now, lol go ahead and cancel me for wrong pronoun~ XD) comments....
"If only I could abandon this body and be reborn as a beautiful girl". ---TRUCK-SAMA HAS ANSWER YOUR CALL AND WISH!!!

Her/(Former His) reaction to being scared is very understandable if you think about it from his/her (...Getting public humiliation and kick out...possibly even beaten up and killed in the very 'worse' case scenario by the royal guards or knights or stuff.) She cannot just be happy since she will be kicked out due to that 'organ'...can't really explain that without getting beaten and kicked out of the academy. (TRUCK-SAMA KIND OF FKED UP HERE...Or could have been a lazy random Deity.)

Due to still having a male physical organ she cannot fully enjoy her new life as a woman (Barely become a cute girl less than a day before realizing 'he(Become he again lol)' only almost fully a physical woman, her joy destroyed and reverting back to her/his old mentality influence by her/his previous body.). MC is enjoys her/his new body much more than 'his(Gasp I misgender her lol~)' old body that lead to 'her' isolation and lonely live as a loner. Her new face is much closer to her/his ideal self.

Also everyone loves cute and beautiful stuff~ Water is wet and gravity makes things fall. MC deciding to hide her/his 'Organ' with his game knowledge and 'I'll be a girl!'- inner thought at the end before getting caught.

Hopefully MC can become a fully physical woman like he(She now technically to be 'accurate') in the future like he desires and dreams of....Or at least be courageous and proud enough after stock piling enough achievements to be accept by both herself and the other people that might become her friends at school/academy.

I don't get it, this isn't a trans manga. I think about wanting to be a woman and in a lesbian relationship all the time, but that doesn't make me trans.

Yeah, I only fantasize about being a woman the normal amount.

lol. (˃ ᗜ ˂)

Nice sarcasm and joke~ 10/10!

Though I guess some people might actually feel that way, people are weird sometimes and unique different from each other at times I guess?...I mean some people fantasize about being a dinosaur, car, robot and stuff for fun? Though you might be in denial if your actually serious lol XD

...Though I guess you might not want to become or declare yourself a woman if you have very manly body (Cannot pass as a fem-boy or trap) and don't have the courage to...In which case I suggest finding the 7 dragon balls or a magic genie to become an beauty or cute woman, turn your dreams and fantasy into reality!!!

o
o
o
o
[Basic worthless comment about useless advice people should already know. (SKIP Below if you already knows the world sucks and is terrible.)]

But also wow....some people are intense in their feelings...I am going to have look over the thread to read all the comments to get everyone's thoughts about this manga later....Let me give you a piece of advice I learned since I was 9-10 years old....Humans are trash species and race...we have so much potential but yet we waste it all. War, pollution, the broken law system which only works about 60% of the time, etc. etc. bunch of other horrible stuff +X more horrible stuff....It doesn't matter whether someone is trans, Cis, Non-binary, whatever the fking heck pronoun or identity they have

....We are all humans, we should get along with each other....but sadly humans are a scum race if you grade them as a whole (Rare 10% at most truly kind people seeking to make the world a better place which is the reason I have any hope in the world at all, 50-60% meh-tier average people which can sway from good to evil time to time and the very rest are scum of the earth) XD

It doesn't matter what gender or sex your born with, a cis person can be the most understanding, kind, thoughtful and outstanding person ever or they can become the most Despicable 'arrogant' worst human alive....This also goes for Trans people...They can be amazing kind, thought people...or they can 'arrogant' annoying evil moron....It depends on the person personality, lifestyle, choices and, let live basically. Life is short, we are all worthless humans that will end up dying less than 100 years in the end after all.

Remember...attacking people online and trying to cancel each other (Unless that said person is a mass murder or something equally worst) is a sign of arrogant/Sin of pride fuel by a selfish desire to dominate other people. Example also include people like annoying nuisance tiktoker/U-Tubers...doesn't matter if they are trans or Cis...Annoying Titktokers and Nuisance U-tubers are beings that help spread hate and anger [Chain damage to their representative group/race sadly which thankfully balanced out by amazing Tiktokers and U-tubers.]

Also pet peeve...annoying people on Tw*tter that claims a fictional character is trans but isn't really trans and just projecting....there are many great amazing trans characters but it annoying when annoying arrogant activists try to paint a character as trans (No clear sign of character declaring they want to become a man or woman or asking for the author's intention and just declaring their opinion on the character without any evidence for their comment/opinion).

Okay that is all my worthless useless thoughts about the manga and what little comments I skim and notice through this thread, I am ready to be called a transphobic for my comment and few misgendering!!!! Go ahead, my gamer days has prepared me to be hurled with all kinds of slurs~!!

last edited at Aug 22, 2025 1:16AM

E05aff7c1334de03865ce183142c84b52
joined Feb 6, 2014

I love this. I love trans women if they cute like her, and that thingy is a nice plus. :) I wish I could be in her place.
I think love between a cis woman and a trans woman still love between women (yuri).

Thanks for the uploading. I am waiting for the next chapter :)

Wtf%20dog
joined Sep 7, 2024

A Wild Chaser Appears! Command?

The last several days have been fuckin' wild, y'all.

last edited at Aug 22, 2025 8:20AM

Wtf%20dog
joined Sep 7, 2024

RIP MC...didn't even got a A-Cup at best lol...But yeah I think this is definitely a Trans manga and MC is trans which is kind of obvious due to his (Her now, lol go ahead and cancel me for wrong pronoun~ XD) comments....
"If only I could abandon this body and be reborn as a beautiful girl". ---TRUCK-SAMA HAS ANSWER YOUR CALL AND WISH!!!

Her/(Former His) reaction to being scared is very understandable if you think about it from his/her (...Getting public humiliation and kick out...possibly even beaten up and killed in the very 'worse' case scenario by the royal guards or knights or stuff.) She cannot just be happy since she will be kicked out due to that 'organ'...can't really explain that without getting beaten and kicked out of the academy. (TRUCK-SAMA KIND OF FKED UP HERE...Or could have been a lazy random Deity.)

Due to still having a male physical organ she cannot fully enjoy her new life as a woman (Barely become a cute girl less than a day before realizing 'he(Become he again lol)' only almost fully a physical woman, her joy destroyed and reverting back to her/his old mentality influence by her/his previous body.). MC is enjoys her/his new body much more than 'his(Gasp I misgender her lol~)' old body that lead to 'her' isolation and lonely live as a loner. Her new face is much closer to her/his ideal self.

Also everyone loves cute and beautiful stuff~ Water is wet and gravity makes things fall. MC deciding to hide her/his 'Organ' with his game knowledge and 'I'll be a girl!'- inner thought at the end before getting caught.

Hopefully MC can become a fully physical woman like he(She now technically to be 'accurate') in the future like he desires and dreams of....Or at least be courageous and proud enough after stock piling enough achievements to be accept by both herself and the other people that might become her friends at school/academy.

I don't get it, this isn't a trans manga. I think about wanting to be a woman and in a lesbian relationship all the time, but that doesn't make me trans.

Yeah, I only fantasize about being a woman the normal amount.

lol. (˃ ᗜ ˂)

Nice sarcasm and joke~ 10/10!

Though I guess some people might actually feel that way, people are weird sometimes and unique different from each other at times I guess?...I mean some people fantasize about being a dinosaur, car, robot and stuff for fun? Though you might be in denial if your actually serious lol XD

...Though I guess you might not want to become or declare yourself a woman if you have very manly body (Cannot pass as a fem-boy or trap) and don't have the courage to...In which case I suggest finding the 7 dragon balls or a magic genie to become an beauty or cute woman, turn your dreams and fantasy into reality!!!

o
o
o
o
[Basic worthless comment about useless advice people should already know. (SKIP Below if you already knows the world sucks and is terrible.)]

But also wow....some people are intense in their feelings...I am going to have look over the thread to read all the comments to get everyone's thoughts about this manga later....Let me give you a piece of advice I learned since I was 9-10 years old....Humans are trash species and race...we have so much potential but yet we waste it all. War, pollution, the broken law system which only works about 60% of the time, etc. etc. bunch of other horrible stuff +X more horrible stuff....It doesn't matter whether someone is trans, Cis, Non-binary, whatever the fking heck pronoun or identity they have

....We are all humans, we should get along with each other....but sadly humans are a scum race if you grade them as a whole (Rare 10% at most truly kind people seeking to make the world a better place which is the reason I have any hope in the world at all, 50-60% meh-tier average people which can sway from good to evil time to time and the very rest are scum of the earth) XD

It doesn't matter what gender or sex your born with, a cis person can be the most understanding, kind, thoughtful and outstanding person ever or they can become the most Despicable 'arrogant' worst human alive....This also goes for Trans people...They can be amazing kind, thought people...or they can 'arrogant' annoying evil moron....It depends on the person personality, lifestyle, choices and, let live basically. Life is short, we are all worthless humans that will end up dying less than 100 years in the end after all.

Remember...attacking people online and trying to cancel each other (Unless that said person is a mass murder or something equally worst) is a sign of arrogant/Sin of pride fuel by a selfish desire to dominate other people. Example also include people like annoying nuisance tiktoker/U-Tubers...doesn't matter if they are trans or Cis...Annoying Titktokers and Nuisance U-tubers are beings that help spread hate and anger [Chain damage to their representative group/race sadly which thankfully balanced out by amazing Tiktokers and U-tubers.]

Also pet peeve...annoying people on Tw*tter that claims a fictional character is trans but isn't really trans and just projecting....there are many great amazing trans characters but it annoying when annoying arrogant activists try to paint a character as trans (No clear sign of character declaring they want to become a man or woman or asking for the author's intention and just declaring their opinion on the character without any evidence for their comment/opinion).

Okay that is all my worthless useless thoughts about the manga and what little comments I skim and notice through this thread, I am ready to be called a transphobic for my comment and few misgendering!!!! Go ahead, my gamer days has prepared me to be hurled with all kinds of slurs~!!

"All people are equal. Also those dirty transes on twitter who headcanon or make arguments that a fictional character is trans are bad."

WHY HAS THIS SITE BEEN LIKE THIS FOR NEARLY A WEEK

__akiyama_mizuki_project_sekai_drawn_by_ririru__aef7569108d461f730828c198e920bc8_1_1_1_1_1
joined Mar 9, 2024

"All people are equal. Also those dirty transes on twitter who headcanon or make arguments that a fictional character is trans are bad."

WHY HAS THIS SITE BEEN LIKE THIS FOR NEARLY A WEEK

Psst. Haven't you heard, they're more equal than other people /s

last edited at Aug 22, 2025 10:02AM

Lizardtalk
joined Aug 19, 2025

From ch1, this could be very cute, or very very unfortunate. Hopefully it treats this subject well and doesn't fall into some of the more common issues I see in these sorts of manga. I'll hold out hope, and remember, this, too, is yuri. :)

Trap is a slur, fyi.

joined Jun 11, 2021

this thread is insane. it's like a petri dish. so fascinating to watch

481253167_1180380530118873_7712287222084682114_n
joined Apr 21, 2020

It's amazing, innit? I have no horses in this game, for lack of knowledge, but it's like car crash, you can't look away.

joined Aug 11, 2022

"All people are equal. Also those dirty transes on twitter who headcanon or make arguments that a fictional character is trans are bad."

WHY HAS THIS SITE BEEN LIKE THIS FOR NEARLY A WEEK

....You just committed the sin of pride and arrogant....where have I said it was 'trans' making the head cannon...? I said people, In fact the person I was referring to is a horrible arrogant localizer...I am pretty sure she is not even trans but I could be wrong though.

Yeah, all people are equal...Fking equally worthless in the grand scheme of life duh lol (Excluding the rare 10% of the people in the world, I and most of the people on this thread I don't considered to be part of that percentage but I could be wrong, I don't know everyone here personally and some people here might be part of that rare 10%. I want to say and dream of a world where everyone is equal, would be nice but reality is not so kind...ALSO!!!...I believe I never said that all people are 'equal'...we are all humans thus equally worthless...Though excluding the rare 10% that has the power to change the world for the better...They are better than us.)

pst like I said, I kind of expected your type of reaction. People...Humans enjoys dominating other people either verbally or with violence but eh it could be just a simple misunderstanding though and you just got too heated up in reading my comment to fully view it and think it over.
Your 'probably' a nice kind person IRL but you also 'seems' to be the type of person to get very emotional to defends others, acting first and accidentally putting words in my mouth that I didn't say or type.

Yes, Your worthless and I am worthless, most of us are worthless beings in the grand scheme of things sadly (Unless your someone that makes like 100,000 dollars a year and possess amazing talents) with little power 'individually(Need like 10,000+ of us to actually create any real change)' to really matter but eh that life...Basically long story short. We should just enjoy our short worthless lives and try to get along as best as possible even if it's difficult to do.

But hey, if people want to believe in their head canon about fictional character then they are free and allowed to, I don't mind if people think that Batman is gay and secretly in a relationship with Robin...but when you try to declare it as 'Canon' and make other people believe then it becomes annoying. I like to follow logic and evidence for something to be concrete and canon though.

But hey whatever, you probably don't like me and probably hates my guts right now for reasons I don't know. -Shrugs- Eh, can't change your mind and it's whatever I guess. If you want a apology from me or something then I am not sorry for my comment, like I said we are all humans and thus all worthless [...Excluding the rare 10%].

Wtf%20dog
joined Sep 7, 2024

Jesus fucking Christ, people.

WHAT IS IN THE WATER

last edited at Aug 22, 2025 3:41PM

Illustration5
joined Aug 31, 2017

I really like Bara a lot. I really like to see two boys chuu each other... Never once i fantasize about being a big hairy man to kiss another big hairy man... reconsider some things maybe

Today I learned Bara and Yaoi are not necessarily the same thing. Thank you.

they are considered entirely different genres. Yaoi/BL is mostly made by women for women, Bara is for the demographic of gay man that are also bears/chasers (and me as an intruder i guess lol.) tho the two are slowly blending together, in some ways, nowadays :D

joined Feb 27, 2017

I don't get it, this isn't a trans manga. I think about wanting to be a woman and in a lesbian relationship all the time, but that doesn't make me trans.

Ask any of your guy friends how often they think about wanting to be women and/or want to be in a lesbian relationship.

But all of my closest friends are sapphic women.

Ask your father if he's ever wanted to be a woman. Ask a colleague or classmate. Ask anyone.

And then, If any of your sapphic friends are trans women, ask them how they knew.

I did, a few years ago, and the answers I got have helped me a lot and made me a much happier person.

joined Feb 25, 2025

I really like Bara a lot. I really like to see two boys chuu each other... Never once i fantasize about being a big hairy man to kiss another big hairy man... reconsider some things maybe

Today I learned Bara and Yaoi are not necessarily the same thing. Thank you.

they are considered entirely different genres. Yaoi/BL is mostly made by women for women, Bara is for the demographic of gay man that are also bears/chasers (and me as an intruder i guess lol.) tho the two are slowly blending together, in some ways, nowadays :D

You know, I've always wondered if there was a type of genre terminology of bara but for lesbian women. It certainly exists like you know when you see art that depicts lesbian relationships by a lesbian rather than a man but there's not really a term for it.

Most lesbian artist I follow have a “anime style” plus a litte more muscle or hair (very much limited to big eyebrows or armpit hair, if its nsfw a bush) but -sadly- I have never seen a lesbian artist draw women in a similar fashion to bara. Even masc x masc japanese artist use bifauxnen. The furry scene in japan is mostly dominated by gay men too. Honestly I have found more fat, hairy women in straight hentai

last edited at Aug 22, 2025 4:39PM

joined Feb 25, 2025

less worried about how authentic/inauthentically trans the main character is and more ill at ease at the (currently just implied) "lesbians secretly crave cock" thing I assume it's leading to with the main girl love interest. im going to continue reading because I desperately want it to be a good trans yuri but I'm skeptical.

Re-reads with a little more slowness
OH MY GOD!!! I didn't even REALIZE! It's already bad enough that it's het with extra steps, but now they're implying the lesbian character may secretly like dick/men. As a lesbian, I already have to deal with this in real life now I gotta see this in my dumbfun fantasy media? Nevermind, I'm no longer interested and dropping this.

Maybe it will turn like this, but not much was said, she is just curious. She is a sheltered Young Lady plus girls in catholic schools didn't had male teachers. For now that can perfectly explain her behavior.

joined Apr 16, 2022

I really like Bara a lot. I really like to see two boys chuu each other... Never once i fantasize about being a big hairy man to kiss another big hairy man... reconsider some things maybe

Today I learned Bara and Yaoi are not necessarily the same thing. Thank you.

they are considered entirely different genres. Yaoi/BL is mostly made by women for women, Bara is for the demographic of gay man that are also bears/chasers (and me as an intruder i guess lol.) tho the two are slowly blending together, in some ways, nowadays :D

You know, I've always wondered if there was a type of genre terminology of bara but for lesbian women. It certainly exists like you know when you see art that depicts lesbian relationships by a lesbian rather than a man but there's not really a term for it.

I think "rezu komi" (lesbian comic) used to mean that but the term isn't used anymore. Yuri in general doesn't have a target demographic so there isn't really a reason to distinguish the yuri that's "for women," unlike with BL.

Edit:

It's already bad enough that it's het with extra steps, but now they're implying the lesbian character may secretly like dick/men.

Not everyone with a dick is a man so you shouldn't conflate the two.

last edited at Aug 22, 2025 4:52PM

joined Apr 16, 2022

I get what you mean, totally totally. I don't mean, drawing women exactly like bara (overtly fat, muscular and hairy to giant proportions) but I guess what I mean is I want a terminology like bara that's meant to denote lesbian media and content that's made by lesbians and tends to have art cues that are a tad more realistic. Similar to the connotations of bara if that makes sense. The closest I could think of is maybe Josei GL that has a non-moe art style.

Yeah, though not all josei yuri is realistic, and plenty of non-josei yuri is. So it's more something you judge on a case-by-case basis.

You know what, good point. That is important context. It could be a situation like "Oh! So you're a man, curious I've never be around a man before". I still think it would be funny if it's about the MC trying to get the girls to pair up like his favorite yuri, I like dumb fun stories like that.

What you're neglecting to realize is that the protagonist of this manga is very clearly not a cis man, since they repeatedly express their desire to be a girl. So if the other girl likes them, that doesn't make her not a lesbian.

joined Apr 16, 2022

Truly, I had forgot that lesbians' are notorious for liking dick. I'm one myself and I forgot. Really sorry about that, won't happen again.

Trans women exist.

This topic has been locked.