Forum › Earth Girls discussion

B25e08d9df956cc70b30a6cce4e9e9cb
joined Aug 27, 2013

I never really liked Mira as a storyteller. She was always a porny mangaka to me, one of many who draws pointless hentai, thoughtless sex, beautiful pictures without any sense. But Earth girls and Mira's early works, they prove me wrong. And it's not only genuinly interesting to read her stories, her talent in storytelling, in creating characters, in describing relationships is much bigger than interesting. It flows soooooo naturally, as if I myself is one of her characters and I make the decisions they make. I don't approve what they do, I don't like such lifestyle and I'm against polyamory, but honestly, in this story it feels so right... I would just do the same. I love this feeling when what I read perfectly synchronizes with my mind, such a blessing.

last edited at Dec 24, 2018 9:37PM

Pity
joined Jan 11, 2014

I never really liked Mira as a storyteller. She was always a porny mangaka to me, one of many who draws pointless hentai, thoughtless sex, beautiful pictures without any sense. But Earth girls and Mira's early works, they prove me wrong. And it's not only genuinly interesting to read her stories, her talent in storytelling, in creating characters, in describing relationships is much bigger than interesting. It flows soooooo naturally, as if I myself is one of her characters and I make the decisions they make. I don't approve what they do, I don't like such lifestyle and I'm against polyamory, but honestly, in this story it feels so right... I would just do the same. I love this feeling when what I read perfectly synchronizes with my mind, such a blessing.

This. I agree. Her earlier work has NSFW scenes but the way it was portrayed seems less like a porno than these much older one. Her early works sex scenes feel more passionate and emotional to me and it seems like when they do have sex they're trying communicate their genuine feelings. I think she attempted the same with her later works, but it just doesn't hit me as much.

Ryuko
joined May 1, 2018

I never really liked Mira as a storyteller. She was always a porny mangaka to me, one of many who draws pointless hentai, thoughtless sex, beautiful pictures without any sense. But Earth girls and Mira's early works, they prove me wrong. And it's not only genuinly interesting to read her stories, her talent in storytelling, in creating characters, in describing relationships is much bigger than interesting. It flows soooooo naturally, as if I myself is one of her characters and I make the decisions they make. I don't approve what they do, I don't like such lifestyle and I'm against polyamory, but honestly, in this story it feels so right... I would just do the same. I love this feeling when what I read perfectly synchronizes with my mind, such a blessing.

Wow, really? I completely disagree, this version of the earth girls series is pretty boring and tiring go me. Even with the gucci sex and stuff, I hate Katra, and I don't understand why anyone would like her in the first place. She's boring, air-headed, and dumb, yet everyone wants to be with her. And she's so oblivious and fine with everything that she cheats on everyone with everyone! The chief, her childhood friend, the traveller girl, and now Io. The whole story is just a big tug of war for Katra and I just don't find it interesting at all, unfortunately.

2c8398570900c5e79edaf431f20173aa
joined Oct 9, 2018

damn, Kidaha will loose one of her waifu again aizzzz

Untitled
joined Dec 16, 2014

at one point, I was hoping a twist that lo will steal katra from everyoneI

Utenaanthy01
joined Aug 4, 2018

So... it's between Mifuri and Juna now?

Unless Kidaha manages to snatch a dramatic comeback victory...

241
joined Sep 25, 2018

One day, there's just going to be one giant fuck pile so dense you can't tell where one body ends and another begins, and no one will bat an eye at where it came from

Pixelavatar48
joined Mar 29, 2013

It really seems like they're setting Katra up as the successor to Kidaha doesn't it? She has a similar "full of love but also totally useless" vibe

57e011396781cdc3308f5aefac880571
joined Feb 19, 2016

I'm always a proponent for yuri harems but I just can't with this one. Characters like Katra is the reason why I hate het harems in the first place. Everyone just throwing themselves at main character simply because they're a main character who's also "nice" to them on occasion..

And now she's sullying the one good character whose main character trait was how cool she was in keeping up with Kidaha's stupid antics.. This manga kinda ruined Earth Girls for me tbh..

shadesofgreymoon
Swxj4ro
joined Jun 5, 2016

There are people who exist that just have "something" about them. Be it general charisma, an aura of charm, whatever. I think Katra is one of those. She's "useless" but she's charming, unassuming, generally kind and caring, never judgmental, and also apparently very good at listening and just being there for someone when they need it. I can understand why others would be drawn to her, and the fact that she's also completely blind to her own situation, oblivious of the conflict she's been brewing, makes all the drama make sense to me, ESPECIALLY when she's been around Kidaha and polyamory for so long that hooking up with more than one person is a natural thing for her to do.

Clodsire
joined Jul 4, 2018

Man, when in doubt,
Yuri fuck it out?

Clodsire
joined Jul 4, 2018

Sex is wrong and you will go to hell for it

Is this a meme or something or just some random trying to troll?

It’s a troll. May the moderator gods strike trolls down.

That being said if sex was indeed wrong then we are all hellspawn and im ok with that.

Yeah.....I’m probably going there anyways. Same for a few others too...

Heaven is a daycare according to this person. Only 0.3% of people aged 40+ are virgins.

So im guessing I’ll have some friends in hell? I’m not currently going there for the sex part tho :p

I was goin there already!

joined May 27, 2018

Wasn’t a fan of this latest chapter, honestly not all that into this entire arc. I don’t see the big draw with Katra, and the new girl is pretty annoying. But I totally hate that Mira took my fav stoic character (Io) and made her a crying mess and then on top of that, she hooks up with Katra! It felt super misplaced. Mira you totally have to redeem yourself, next chapter have Kidaha secretly witness what happened, get jealous, and then make up and rekindle with Io.

last edited at Dec 25, 2018 2:43AM

Omochikaeri_thumb
joined Nov 2, 2013

Just what is going on with this story? Its one big fuck fest. I dont like this turn of events with Io.

A8655427-a1fe-40eb-9c2f-10bb35cb2487
joined Aug 26, 2018

I think I’ve said this before, but Mira makes everything better
Katra has the right idea about friendship

ps you can read the raws of the whole manga on nhentai

last edited at Dec 25, 2018 3:28AM

E05aff7c1334de03865ce183142c84b52
joined Feb 6, 2014

Wasn’t a fan of this latest chapter, honestly not all that into this entire arc. I don’t see the big draw with Katra, and the new girl is pretty annoying. But I totally hate that Mira took my fav stoic character (Io) and made her a crying mess and then on top of that, she hooks up with Katra! It felt super misplaced. Mira you totally have to redeem yourself, next chapter have Kidaha secretly witness what happened, get jealous, and then make up and rekindle with Io.

I like how Io lost her composure (nobody perfect) but the sex scene was not neccessary here. It feels she cheated Kidaha because she only belonged to her before...

joined May 27, 2018

Wasn’t a fan of this latest chapter, honestly not all that into this entire arc. I don’t see the big draw with Katra, and the new girl is pretty annoying. But I totally hate that Mira took my fav stoic character (Io) and made her a crying mess and then on top of that, she hooks up with Katra! It felt super misplaced. Mira you totally have to redeem yourself, next chapter have Kidaha secretly witness what happened, get jealous, and then make up and rekindle with Io.

I like how Io lost her composure (nobody perfect) but the sex scene was not neccessary here. It feels she cheated Kidaha because she only belonged to her before...

True, I agree it gives her more dimension as a character. I’m not so much bothered by her breaking down than I am by them segwaying that comfort into random sex lol. i was reading it like “no wait, Io’s Kidaha’s girl!”

E05aff7c1334de03865ce183142c84b52
joined Feb 6, 2014

I have a bad feeling Kidaha will leave the village... T_T
No wifes, no reason to stay?

last edited at Dec 25, 2018 4:57AM

Pity
joined Jan 11, 2014

Wasn’t a fan of this latest chapter, honestly not all that into this entire arc. I don’t see the big draw with Katra, and the new girl is pretty annoying. But I totally hate that Mira took my fav stoic character (Io) and made her a crying mess and then on top of that, she hooks up with Katra! It felt super misplaced. Mira you totally have to redeem yourself, next chapter have Kidaha secretly witness what happened, get jealous, and then make up and rekindle with Io.

Agree on this. I hate the new girl tbh. She kinda threw everything into a loop when created this huge drama. I feel especially sad my girl Io, she's my favorite throughout this series and to see her cry really make me irritate at Kidaha. I hope she'll appreciate Io more when she loses her.

32104671_1715652908533240_2109611648586088448_n
joined Jul 30, 2015

Kidaha should leave with lo. I like how lo want now Kidaha for her own, because they the best characters in the Manga :)

B25e08d9df956cc70b30a6cce4e9e9cb
joined Aug 27, 2013

Maybe I'm becoming too open-minded or I don't know but the sex between Katra and Io felt super natural and right to me. That's the point, nobody is nobody's girl, everyone is truly free and loves every member of that village equally. This little act of sex was just an act of friendship and Mira expressed it really well. The two had ideal chemistry, they were thankful to each other and happy that they talked, so sex was like...buying a delicious snack for your partner - a wish to show one's gratitude, to deepen the bound between them. And it was honest because both Katra and Io treat sex as nothing more than showing all sorts of love: for a friend, for a lover etc. Now if Juna hooks up with some random chick - that would feel unnatural.

And hey, Io remains Kidaha's most important woman, so why would she leave? Who said that Kidaha loves Katra the same way as Io? It's obvious the reason is Juna, if Katra paired up with Mifuri and continued to live happily with everyone, Kidaha would treat it the same she always does. But here came Juna - equally strong, arrogant child who rivals Kidaha in her leadership and wants to take one of the girls away, forever. Anyone would get their pride hurt and make a mess out of it, especially Kidaha. So I don't see any problems here.

joined Aug 21, 2015

I've seen the raws of all the next chapters
https://nhentai.net/g/252751/134/

last edited at Dec 25, 2018 7:23AM

Utenaanthy01
joined Aug 4, 2018

Just what is going on with this story? Its one big fuck fest.

I know! Ain't it great!?

Cnwdrjjvmail6tq
joined Jun 30, 2017

This story is so good xD finally a new chapter!!
The scene of Io and Katra was so natural to me too :) so beautiful!

last edited at Dec 25, 2018 10:36AM

241
joined Sep 25, 2018

I've seen the raws of all the next chapters
https://nhentai.net/g/252751/134/

Thanks for the link, now I don't gotta bother with reading it here anymore. I can't understand Japanese but it's pretty easy to tell what happened. Maybe it's because most of the yuri I've read hardly shows any explicit sex scene but it's just gotten grating, formulaic and overtly pornographic after a while.

To reply you must either login or sign up.