Forum › Former Evil General Is Crushing on the Magical Girl discussion

Ezgif.com-gif-maker%20(1)
joined Jun 6, 2020

yknow after watching the body

Give me MORE of this

Screenshot_2020-10-28_003849_2_2_69
joined Sep 14, 2014

This here is some delicious ANGST YO

0031
joined Jun 19, 2025

Thank you for the chapter update!
God i love this!!

Nyarin
joined Mar 20, 2012

It does feels a bit forced that Hane didn't tell Junna she doesn't love her just as a stand-in.

03
joined Mar 4, 2018

meh

emberisthesilliest
Img_6941
joined Feb 24, 2026

ok then

i wish it was in order though

Watashi,%20apathetic%20(600x600)%20a
joined Jul 30, 2015

ninryu posted:
It does feels a bit forced that Hane didn't tell Junna she doesn't love her just as a stand-in.

She tries, then gets interrupted by the creepy "accept her request" page and the scars left over from the foiled rape attempt grow right after. I think the vines were the spell her attacker was using to brainwash people, and interrupting it partway wasn't enough to fully counteract the effects. Given how much of a mess the villains' brainwashing left Junna in, I think we can count Hane lucky that sabotaging her love life is all it's done so far.

joined Oct 21, 2018

We have reached the miscommunication arc people!!!

Screenshot2026-04-25at7.19.16p
joined Apr 25, 2026

It does feels a bit forced that Hane didn't tell Junna she doesn't love her just as a stand-in.

I'm sure she geniunely loves Junna but she can't say that properly because the cruix of her affection lies with Junna being the older magical girl.

Now Junna could be the older magical girl who was brainwashed (and evidence seems to point to the particular strawberry charm which hasn't been contridicted yet), but the drama is that she is currently an entirely different person (an evil general who has been terrorizing the populace no less) who was just saved because she happened to have the charm. Hane can't just say she loves her not as just a stand-in because that wouldn't be true (atm) but she also vowed that she would make Junna happy no matter what.

Without other options, she accepts the "farce" of it for Junna. The result is a miserable mixture of guilt and trauma borned out of a selfish desire. Her only salvation would be that she is eventually proven right, that Junna is the older magical girl who saved her.

Couple_under_the_stars
joined Nov 7, 2022

I kinda appreciate Junna thinking she can't just go back to a normal life, being Floria Rose's beloved, as if her being part of the evil organization was nothing. I want her to move on, but refusing to accept it that easily honestly just makes sense.

Also wait the goddess just straight up deletes anyone on dark lord's side? Feels like there's no rescuing the girls or anything then.

It's not that simple. Junna in her magical girl form, when she destroyed the rapist creep a few chapters ago, did spend some energy to heal and erase memories of the girls, so clearly it's not a case of "once on their side, execution guaranteed".

I wonder if Junna might be someone who was corrupted but thinks she joined willingly ?

joined Sep 25, 2017

I'm sure she geniunely loves Junna but she can't say that properly because the cruix of her affection lies with Junna being the older magical girl.

Now Junna could be the older magical girl who was brainwashed (and evidence seems to point to the particular strawberry charm which hasn't been contridicted yet), but the drama is that she is currently an entirely different person (an evil general who has been terrorizing the populace no less) who was just saved because she happened to have the charm. Hane can't just say she loves her not as just a stand-in because that wouldn't be true (atm) but she also vowed that she would make Junna happy no matter what.

Without other options, she accepts the "farce" of it for Junna. The result is a miserable mixture of guilt and trauma borned out of a selfish desire. Her only salvation would be that she is eventually proven right, that Junna is the older magical girl who saved her.

Yes, exactly! Hane is like "I like Junna, but I started liking her because I thought she was the older magical girl, so do I like her because of or despite that?" And Hane can see that she hurt Junna by thinking of her as the older magical girl, and rejecting her now would only hurt Junna even more, and Hane can't bear that.

Hane can't say that the one she truly loves is Junna because right now she doesn't know if that's the case, though i do think she does, she just feels guilty that her love started by superimposing an old crush onto her. If she rejects her in a way it destroys any future chance to be with Junna, but the thing that ultimately convinces her is that she doesn't want to hurt her even more, which is a tragic irony because she's doing just that.

Nyarin
joined Mar 20, 2012

To be clear, I know how Hane really feels about Junna, my problem is that the reason she doesn't tell Junna her feelings feels contrived in a way that breaks my suspension of disbelief.

Chikane%20and%20himeko%20from%20kannazuki%20no%20miko%20which%20you%20should%20watch%20btw
joined Feb 26, 2020

Since this chapter came out, I've been trying to figure out why this arc's whole "resolution" bothers me so much and feels so contrived. I'm not sure if I can put it into words as well as I'd like, but...

I think I'd be able to accept Hane angsting over the thought of "I only like her because she resembles my first crush" if we, as the audience, had actually seen any evidence of that being the case. However, in the first place, Hane knew Junna as just Junna, her senpai, prior to learning of her identity as the evil general + discovering the possible connection to her first crush, and on top of that, we've seen all these snippets of the two of them genuinely bonding since that happened, with no obvious sign that Hane is treating her as a stand-in for somebody else.

They already have a clear foundation of properly knowing each other personally, so it makes the entire conflict feel contrived, particularly on Hane's end.

In order to make a conflict like this feel justified, you have to ground it by tying it in with the rest of the narrative, but there's simply not enough depiction to prove that Hane has been projecting her feelings for the older magical girl onto Junna at all. The only argument I could understand is that Hane insisting on wanting Junna to wear white is kinda like that, but... It still doesn't feel like enough to warrant such an extreme conclusion.

And, for the record, even if we're meant to understand that Hane's worries are incorrect and unwarranted, I still don't understand how her subsequent behavior follows from her established perspective.

We've seen evidence that Hane feels guilty over what she did to Junna and fears for Junna's safety, but the line of logic leading from those feelings to "I'll just silently accept everything she's saying about how I only like her because she resembles my first crush and date her under that pretense even though I'm clearly hurting her feelings"(???) feels especially flimsy.

I can understand where Junna is coming from well enough (although there are other writing problems concerning her side of things that I won't mention here), but Hane feels especially difficult to empathize with because I just can't understand where she's coming from. It's not that she's mysterious-- rather, her actions feel completely arbitrary.

Sorry to be harsh, but establishing a characters' values and personality in advance in order to justify and explain their future actions is a fundamental necessity of good storytelling, and this author is really, really bad at it. It makes the conflict feel like it comes out of nowhere, so it's hard to get emotionally invested in the angst when I'm just thinking, "What the heck is even going on?" and, "What in the world is wrong with you, Hane??"

last edited at Nov 20, 2026 8:23AM

To reply you must either login or sign up.