Forum › All Through the Night discussion

Ipad%20wallpaper%20redraw%20[thumb]
joined Feb 28, 2013

Ooof... this one's going to hurt a lot.

joined Jan 14, 2020

ChatGPT in the credits?

3z8eb8cxabml0ib3limx
Divulge Scans
joined Dec 29, 2010

医療描写監修 [...] ChatGPT

Consultation on Depiction of Medical Care:
(Friend), (User), ChatGPT

O-oh

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

医療描写監修 [...] ChatGPT

Consultation on Depiction of Medical Care:
(Friend), (User), ChatGPT

O-oh

Augh. Yeah we really need an AI tag on here.

intheend Uploader
Hmph!
Lente
joined Mar 21, 2020

医療描写監修 [...] ChatGPT

Consultation on Depiction of Medical Care:
(Friend), (User), ChatGPT

O-oh

Augh. Yeah we really need an AI tag on here.

I'm not one to defend AI usage, but come on. you want to slap an AI tag on every work for which the author has done a google search? there's no genAI used in this work at all. all Orihi Chihiro most likely did is ask ChatGPT questions about the equipment/treatment/etc. which their friends and/or that user couldn't answer, and checked the information with the sources it pulled from

In%20your%20butt
joined Jun 21, 2021

医療描写監修 [...] ChatGPT

Consultation on Depiction of Medical Care:
(Friend), (User), ChatGPT

O-oh

Augh. Yeah we really need an AI tag on here.

I'm not one to defend AI usage, but come on. you want to slap an AI tag on every work for which the author has done a google search? there's no genAI used in this work at all. all Orihi Chihiro most likely did is ask ChatGPT questions about the equipment/treatment/etc. which their friends and/or that user couldn't answer, and checked the information with the sources it pulled from

I must concur as much as it pains me. "Asking ChatGPT" or Grok or whatever kinda has become the new googling. So much so that Google lost billions bc ppl keep asking the AI they invested so much in, instead of searching things on sites where they put their ads.

And while I can't prevent it from lowering my opinion of the author's practices, there is a difference in endresult between using generative AI to make smth and relying on search AI for pulling sources/references, as bad of an idea as it may be.

Unfortunately for all of us it's just a thing™ now i guess.

__akiyama_mizuki_project_sekai_drawn_by_ririru__aef7569108d461f730828c198e920bc8_1_1_1_1_1
joined Mar 9, 2024

Yuck. It pains me seeing people I respect "asking ChatGPT"(*) about something.
It's not even something niche, in this case. Could'a been a search in Merck Manual.

* One doesn't "ask ChatGPT" about something, one sends text sequences to LLM and LLM generates text sequences that mimick human language back. This is not "asking", even if users may feel like so.

last edited at Nov 15, 2026 7:20PM

joined Jan 14, 2020

one sends text sequences to LLM and LLM generates text sequences that mimick human language back.

To be fair, the Google LLM also provides links to real sources. Sometimes (only sometimes) those sources even back up what the LLM claims! Dunno about ChatGPT, never used it.

__akiyama_mizuki_project_sekai_drawn_by_ririru__aef7569108d461f730828c198e920bc8_1_1_1_1_1
joined Mar 9, 2024

one sends text sequences to LLM and LLM generates text sequences that mimick human language back.

To be fair, the Google LLM also provides links to real sources. Sometimes (only sometimes) those sources even back up what the LLM claims! Dunno about ChatGPT, never used it.

Still text sequences. Links probably got special treatment when being ingested for training.

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

医療描写監修 [...] ChatGPT

Consultation on Depiction of Medical Care:
(Friend), (User), ChatGPT

O-oh

Augh. Yeah we really need an AI tag on here.

I'm not one to defend AI usage, but come on. you want to slap an AI tag on every work for which the author has done a google search? there's no genAI used in this work at all. all Orihi Chihiro most likely did is ask ChatGPT questions about the equipment/treatment/etc. which their friends and/or that user couldn't answer, and checked the information with the sources it pulled from

I must concur as much as it pains me. "Asking ChatGPT" or Grok or whatever kinda has become the new googling. So much so that Google lost billions bc ppl keep asking the AI they invested so much in, instead of searching things on sites where they put their ads.

And while I can't prevent it from lowering my opinion of the author's practices, there is a difference in endresult between using generative AI to make smth and relying on search AI for pulling sources/references, as bad of an idea as it may be.

Unfortunately for all of us it's just a thing™ now i guess.

For me the LLM use is still dangerous and harmful, and it makes me not want to engage with the creator's work. Especially when they could be spreading false information that the ai spat out, sure my desire for an ai tag is probably too generalized for most users because yes at the very least it's not generative ai here (hopefully). For me it's still a very gross thing and "asking chatgpt/grok" being the new way to search things for a bunch of people isn't an excuse because it's an extremely bad habit in my opinion. Alas I just hate this state of things.

In%20your%20butt
joined Jun 21, 2021

Alas I just hate this state of things.

You and me both :/

__akiyama_mizuki_project_sekai_drawn_by_ririru__aef7569108d461f730828c198e920bc8_1_1_1_1_1
joined Mar 9, 2024

Alas I just hate this state of things.

You and me both :/

Both of you and me three >:(

joined Nov 15, 2026

Yuck. It pains me seeing people I respect "asking ChatGPT"(*) about something.
It's not even something niche, in this case. Could'a been a search in Merck Manual.

* One doesn't "ask ChatGPT" about something, one sends text sequences to LLM and LLM generates text sequences that mimick human language back. This is not "asking", even if users may feel like so.

I'm the author.
I didn't just "ask" ChatGPT to tell me what to write, instead, I made it provide me an accurate reading list for this and actually read through them. There will be a full reference list included in the complete edition coming out next month. In fact, I consulted my doctor friend (yes the one on the same page) about most of the medical depictions.
I did not just spend dozens of hours on fact-checking to now get called "spreading false information".

__akiyama_mizuki_project_sekai_drawn_by_ririru__aef7569108d461f730828c198e920bc8_1_1_1_1_1
joined Mar 9, 2024

^ Gee, for real? 織日ちひろ?

Okay. The way you use it is much better than just treating LLM's output as truth, which was what I intially imagined. I'm sorry for overreacting whenever I saw people using LLMs when I didn't know how they used it.

Though, still, since you have doctor friends to ask about these questions, maybe you can just ask them for titles of reference materials you can check? (maybe you can even borrow their books) I'd think doctor friends are much more reliable in medical information than stocastic parrots, as they often give out unreliable sources or made up nonexisting books. Also, aside from hallucinations (making things up) and sycophancy (affirming whatever users give), there are also grave ethical concerns regarding LLMs' training and inferencing process, like energy cost, water usage, web scraping that's basically DDoS attacks, and the pollutions generated by AI companies building up fossil fuel power stations. Microsoft even plans to restart Three Mile Island nuclear power plant, the scene of the worst commercial nuclear accident in US history, just to power its AI.

water and energy usage: 1 2
web scraping: 1
Three Miles Island: 1

And, I like your work very much. Do you have something like patreon or ko-fi?

joined Mar 31, 2025

Ooof... this one's going to hurt a lot.

I bought the physical of this. Without spoiling too much: yes. Don’t get too attached.

Undertale%20deltarune%20fukufire%20skateboard%20gay
joined Aug 4, 2021

very stark and beautiful. considering their other work as well, the author must have a profound grasp on life and living

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

^ Gee, for real? 織日ちひろ?

Okay. The way you use it is much better than just treating LLM's output as truth, which was what I intially imagined. I'm sorry for overreacting whenever I saw people using LLMs when I didn't know how they used it.

Though, still, since you have doctor friends to ask about these questions, maybe you can just ask them for titles of reference materials you can check? (maybe you can even borrow their books) I'd think doctor friends are much more reliable in medical information than stocastic parrots, as they often give out unreliable sources or made up nonexisting books. Also, aside from hallucinations (making things up) and sycophancy (affirming whatever users give), there are also grave ethical concerns regarding LLMs' training and inferencing process, like energy cost, water usage, web scraping that's basically DDoS attacks, and the pollutions generated by AI companies building up fossil fuel power stations. Microsoft even plans to restart Three Mile Island nuclear power plant, the scene of the worst commercial nuclear accident in US history, just to power its AI.

water and energy usage: 1 2
web scraping: 1
Three Miles Island: 1

And, I like your work very much. Do you have something like patreon or ko-fi?

You perfectly hit the nail on the head on all fronts I think, and companies like ChatGPT are Especially bad! Also commenting on this specifically,

I'm sorry for overreacting whenever I saw people using LLMs when I didn't know how they used it.

Exactly this! I didn't mean to be rude it's that when AI is used it brings a lot of questions, and it makes it hard to trust everything. It's why I said a person could be spreading misinformation, because sometimes people ask ai questions while believing it's completely reliable. It's one of the many reasons I'm strongly against the usage of ai and how it brings a lot of concerns along with it.

Yuu
joined Mar 28, 2015

For documentation purpose, LLMs are just tools like any other. Google, specific databases, etc...

It's convenient. As long as you crosscheck what it says with real people and real books, I don't see the problem.

It's a problem when it's a crutch for laziness or cost saving. When it replaces actual people or when you believe it'll save you from learning. The ethical or environmental aspects are another story.

If the author in this case used it for documenting themselves and looking for references, who are you to criticize them?

last edited at Nov 18, 2026 2:54AM

Internet_lied
joined Jul 15, 2016

TFW you want to read others' opinions on this gut punch of a Tragedy, but 80% of the thread is venting about ChatGPT.

last edited at Nov 18, 2026 3:08AM

Rhodes_island
joined Dec 23, 2016

If the author in this case used it for documenting themselves and looking for references, who are you to criticize them?

sit down pal, nobody gets to be exempt from criticism

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

If the author in this case used it for documenting themselves and looking for references, who are you to criticize them?

I voiced my personal opinions on AI and why I think it's bad, and also explained that from my perspective the use of ChatGPT raised worries and questions that are in my opinion very valid and reasonable. I don't wish the creators ill here, and I'm glad they clarified how it was used. Anyhow, we're very off topic with the work so I'm going to leave the subject here!

To reply you must either login or sign up.