Well I said it before, I can't be happy with Granbelm "final lesson" because it's been done to death through many films, video games and manga/comic "This power is too much so is better to seal forever, humans are weak and stupid but we can learn step by step!" they even do it with "sealed techniques" or "forbidden technology" so I guess I was expecting something more unique... I think Madoka did it right and they both self sacrificed.
To be brutally honest I would've been really upset if Shingetsu lives a normal happy life after the "sin" of literally negating the existence of so many people and the events that they went through and you'll see her with a smile reading a book in her room like "aah so peaceful"... Does that feels fair?
EpicYarnBoy posted:
The granbelm thing about removing magic wasn't because people were using magic for evil, it was because magic was manipulating them into being evil
If that were the case then people from the old times wouldn't have been able to seal it away, it was just the depravity of some people that forced another group to seal it for everyone.... Ah but there were many things that didn't make sense like they said that humans created magic and it wasn't good but then the "referee" says that magic has been around beyond the thousands of year, and the fact that if she removes magic I thought it would just be gone but then they say that it would be like it never existed in the first place and yet for convenience the families of mages are still around and happy going to school and looks like history itself didn't change... Like, they didn't want to deal with the aftermath of such a titanic change to the world/space/time.
On the final note ... When Shingetsu was questioning her own existence at the start of ep13 and why Magia was favoring her even though it was obvious that she had the least favorable desire for magic itself I really thought we would get a final revelation that would blow our minds ... But at the end it was more like "lol I thought she wouldn't do it!" and so magic is dead forever and ever THE END... I guess, is my fault for expecting too much when I could've just watched madoka again.
PS: All this can be easily forgotten because Machikaou did a great job, it was romantic, funny and beautiful... Is an anime about mahou shoujo and evil and we didn't even get a single fight! and it was still great! so that makes me happy... Dunno if we can get a s2 but if New game did it, then why not this one u.u
last edited at Sep 27, 2019 1:41AM