You can just say "it's all comics" about everything on the reader, so it's not worth discussing anything. Clearly that's ridiculous. You absolutely can discuss comedy, whether it works or is well written or whatever. The fact that you like it isn't justification for telling everyone else to be quiet about it.
For me at least, the premise actually gets in the way of the funny. It's treated too much as a blunt weapon, and dragging it in just when the character interaction is funny in its own right is the very picture of "not reading the mood".
Now you are just putting words in my mouth. I never said everyone to be quiet about their criticism. I saw too many negative things in this story so I put what I think about it.
Comedy is very subjective, what some people find hilarious, others don't (that's why I think is the hardest genre to write).
I found the whole thing very endearing and hilarious because I started seeing a family and not a group of girls pretending to be one. They're a bunch of really great method actors.
What he/she said. ^^
Plus there are many other stories that focus on serious topics in this website and the discussion within them are...(you know) serious. This story is probably purely comedic with some plot and romance and not mean to offend anyone with its premise. Again, comedy isn't everyone's cup of tea and different people have different tastes.
P.S: I like cliche and classical ending. It will be nice if the paper plane girl is the end girl. However, I am up for a surprised pairing....(hopefully not the "eldest son")
last edited at Dec 3, 2014 3:43AM