appstore posted:
There are trans women who don't "pass", or even don't want to.
And they can have representation too.
No one said the contrary At All. You are intionally reading my comment in bad faith and impliying something I didn’t say. The topic is not “trans women who don’t pass don’t deserve representation” is about how non-tran women constantly despict them as muscular, with a big jaw, etc. and how much this says about them, not about trans women.
Your comment is quit funny considering your historial of transphobic comments, especially the ones under “The Story of a Girl Who Likes Girls, and a Girl Who Used to be a Guy” and “Pale Blue-green Color Saudade”
I stand by my long-held opinion that in manga, most of the time, trans women are indistinguishable from non-trans women, like in "I Quit Being a Man..." or, as you say "The Story of a Girl Who Likes Girls, and a Girl Who Used to be a Guy". And in doing so, it pushes the narrative that only "perfect" trans women are "real" women and the others (muscular with "big jaw") are ridiculous caricatures.
I don't want "all trans women" to be depicted with muscles and beards, I want some variety in the representation. And this manga here does a good job of it. You're putting words in my mouth I never said.
Anyway, I'm done with this conversation, because whenever the topic of trans identity crops up, it always devolves into misunderstandings, bad faith arguments, fallacies all around and then the mods have to lock the thread.