Forum › Posts by Iamlovingthat4u

Iamlovingthat4u
joined Aug 17, 2021

I sure hope i don’t have to remind everyone that before “trans woman” and even “gay” we were all “fags” and the specifics didn’t matter to our opressors and hardly even made sense to each other. Some real Veneno or Stone butch blues shit. We love to see it. Its expressive, shows off every person’s ugliness and seems somehow deeply honest. As a post-gender tranny freak who thanks to my grandmother’s fight i can get hormones and hold a normal job. i gotta respect my mama lori

last edited at Mar 24, 2026 3:08AM

Iamlovingthat4u
joined Aug 17, 2021

I Love this, Nawar Dagher, please keep making stuff. The art is incredible and really expressive. Literally no one is doing your charcoal pencil style, The depictions of anxiety, through the rambling internal dialogue and art are so raw and well executed that it makes the whole work shine. In those moments it reminds me a bit of Milk Inside a Bag of Milk, or maybe Mission-chan. honestly Id love more focus on the anxiety and introspection but i think an artist should go wherever their heart takes them.
There are a few awkwardnesses to the english, and i think the structural writing, as in like themes and plot are kinda flat at times. I feel like the interiority of some of our other characters here feels underbaked, what are they anxious about? Do we need more characters before we have even explored our first three? What are their goals? Largely it seems like each chapter is written independently of each other which can give it a stiltedness, where is the story going?

So rarely do you get this much soul from a yuri work but thats probably becuase most of what we read here on dynasty are works by professional mangaka with editors, rather than early, naive works that have yet to find themselves.

I’m writing this mostly for the author, knowing she reads the comments here. Thanks for posting this out here, great idea since piracy and free stuff is the only way art gets to the masses these days. And i somehow worry that, well if our main character’s authentically written anxiety is anything to go by, that our artist could be scared off by negativity, especially since there is a lot i feel is missing, i want her to know that she’s made something genuinely powerful at times and to keep at it.

Gosh i really gotta learn to draw and make my own yuri.

I love that yuri is so tied to the japanese school setting that the setting becomes mythic, almost required in yuri works, even if none of us experienced it, we lived its myth through our favorite genre and need to express ourselves through these tropes.

last edited at Mar 23, 2026 1:13AM

Iamlovingthat4u
joined Aug 17, 2021

Looking for girls to treat me like they treat dickgirls in futayuri.

Iamlovingthat4u
ShenYu discussion 08 Nov 18:23
joined Aug 17, 2021

Dang, no girl penis

joined Aug 17, 2021

Idk who this Nobody is but damn, on top of defeating polyphemus they also correct scanlations? Damn ppl are serious about quality huh!?

Iamlovingthat4u
joined Aug 17, 2021

Knight heron translators notes are the best thank you

joined Aug 17, 2021

There are old trans women who show up at the events with all the younger trans women. Some are weird some are well liked. You’re never too old to Transition. Moe is this impossible to achieve thing in the first place, mostly this is fear of aging and fatness, standard dysphorias, plus gender stuff. Like if the story was about a young man the end result would be them crossdressing and trying to look more girlish. If an old woman then young girls would be glad to have someone into their interests. We will all get old someday and we must be ready not to hate ourselves though its really hard.

dysphoria hydrogen bomb

Uh but yea its pretty brutal.

Iamlovingthat4u
joined Aug 17, 2021

Oh no, my heart.

That aside, would a Trans Yuri romance story called "Schrödinger’s Girl" be considered a clever idea, a silly idea, or an insulting one?

I only ask because that is what popped into my mind when I saw the title. Only for it to a literal Schrödinger’s Girl(Cat).

Theres something here about being a girl only when you aren’t observed - crossdressing in secret. Something to do with doubt, like they’re not sure if they actually want to be seen like this or if its a fetish or if its important at all, until they are observed and the wavefunction collapses. Maybe scientist girl trying to study our pov character trans girl?

Iamlovingthat4u
joined Aug 17, 2021

I don’t expect everything to end up hunky dory like “is my hobby weird” but oddly im excited for whatever happens. Even if these characters crash and burn and grow even more toxic its obvious that the author has made what’s killing them be repression and self hatred and controlling impulses not their fetish. I think usio shio likes a happy ending but i cannot be sure, so glad to have toxic yuri.

Iamlovingthat4u
joined Aug 17, 2021

God i love crossdressing manga even if its kinda low on substance. This is the kinda stuff that got me to dress fem for the first time

Iamlovingthat4u
joined Aug 17, 2021

every time another oneshot from this polyam yuri anthology gets translated it's a good, good day~

also YESS! You can be polyam and still experience jealousy! THANK YOU!! It always peeves me so much when ppl think that just bc you're polyam you're not allowed to feel jealous. Of course you can! It's a normal human emotion! Some ppl feel it, some don't and either way is fine. How we choose to deal with it is what matters.

^^ Jealousy is a beed not getting met, its feeling scacity in your relationships. If feel like you want more time with the other person just ask! But also, sometimes you want more intimacy or something from them that they dont want! So you have to get that need met with other people. Its normal to invite someone over to watch movies and they decline so you bring anotjer movie friend. Cuddling and emotional support and sex, and all the social needs a person has can be met with multiple people, if you feel jealous its worth asking why? If you feel like you’re not enough then maybe try remembering that this person keeps choosing to spend time with you. If you’re worried the other person can do somethi no for the person you love that you can’t remeber thats good that theyre getting their needs met. There are no rules, only trying to make each other happy!

Iamlovingthat4u
joined Aug 17, 2021

Quick, someone get the girls from “our love is disgusting”
https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/our_love_is_disgusting_ch01

joined Aug 17, 2021

Thank you scanlators! These are really great, love the vibe these two have with my whole heart

joined Aug 17, 2021

Because of the, themes of age and youth and love of western music…

Petition to change this manga’s unofficial title to “smells like teen spirit” sign here:

joined Aug 17, 2021

Ayy nice excited for transmasc “the bride was a boy” gosh i read that like 6 years ago and it helped me realize i wanted to transition. Lets go tboys and enbys, tho this may be a little different (worse?) cause its the mangaka as friend not strictly autobiographical

last edited at Sep 27, 2024 12:05AM

joined Aug 17, 2021

Phenomenal manga but “wasnt a boy at all” is a terrible title. I know it was a placeholder but now that we know more Id prefer “smells like teen spirit” or something, that evokes the teenage aangst and western rock music they love

Iamlovingthat4u
joined Aug 17, 2021

This show is so horny about women it could give me new kinks. The way it draws armpits makes them seem hot and im not even into them. Makes me feel way more comfortable being gay, this is what yuri is all about

Iamlovingthat4u
Mint Candy discussion 06 Oct 14:16
joined Aug 17, 2021

Cute. Needs more dickgirl

Iamlovingthat4u
Yuri Danshi discussion 24 Jul 11:22
joined Aug 17, 2021

As a Trans woman attracted to women (do I dare tread upon the name of yuri to bestow it upon myself? Even questioning cis lesbians feel they cannot approach the infinite beauty that is yuri, and even as they grow into confidence in themselves, as Achilles can never reach the tortoise they must know that the grandeur is of fantasy is unattainable. no I cannot claim it, though my relationships are unique and beautiful in their own right I feel deeply that I am a different creature than the yuri that may exist but only on the page) I feel this work is honestly deeply resonant in my very soul. Not only is each episode a full treatise on the ins and outs of the point that is explored but it is applicable elsewhere. To appreciating another culture, heck as weebs all of us must understand what it is like to be yuri danshi, to study, to read so many works about Japanese high school though we can never experience it for ourselves, maybe some few of us may vacation, fewer may even live there and integrate but we can never be truly subsumed. The work is also Applicable to all fantasy itself as I mentioned earlier. To privelage, the idea that our appreciation, our allyship itself does not leave room for that which it supports. As a white person living in America I have this unwanted privelage, I fear that my presence in spaces to lift up those oppressed by race is unwanted and yet, and yet, what is there to do? How best to support from the sidelines? Goddess of yuri, what am I to do?! Upon beginning this work I suspected, nay hoped, our protagonist was one like myself, and needed to come to his own feminine identity so he can realize the yuri that he so dreams of. But I was wrong and so glad to be. Though the take on crossdressing can be read as transphobia I choose to read it as how our yuri danshi did: how dare I judge others on these standards they did not agree to. I am also so happy it is structured not like shoujo but like shonen, to further drive home that these are men. I truly cannot wait to see what the authors conclusion may be, for i am desperate to be relieved of the curse, the purposelessness, of allyship, exoticism, impossible fantasy, the curse of the yuri danshi.

Iamlovingthat4u
Anemone discussion 24 Feb 09:07
joined Aug 17, 2021

Lmao I was hoping I’d find a political discussion on the ethics of the French Revolution in the comments.

My two cents are that that as an anarchist velvet, bloodless, revolution is the goal, but also to understand that it is not in the ruling class’s interest to allow you to do this. It is in no way my place as to tell a prisoner or starving man to wait till a better time, or a time to vote them out. Kropotkin talks about how the French revolution and the subsequent Paris commune was not lost because of the blood for blood fervor but rather because the common people did not have bread. After all, the goal of any revolution, of any society should be the end to scarcity and well being for all.
Someone brought up a good point about the lineage of the monarchy needing to be severed, and of course a truly enlightened revolution would spare literally everyone, save every life, a practical one understands that that tragedy may be necessary, after all britain’s monarchy exists not just symbolically as a horrible historical injustice but presently, people who live without having to work by nature of their blood, funded by the rest of us, when we all could live that well if they did not exist. Then the propaganda machine they run sells the masses a new opiate of royal drama tabloids.

This is to say it is able to be simultaneously tragic, and even possibly horrifyingly unnecessary to end the life of another human. But also at the same time this mistake does not make the whole revolution riven, it shows we have to be all the more serious about well being for all.

Either way gorgeous work, loved the page of darkness there that made me really feel something

joined Aug 17, 2021

There’s a manga I read not long ago on here about an honor student pranking or teasing or otherwise messing with another girl. I think it’s a series but not very far in? The episode I remember involved not only her asking permission to merciliessly prank the other girl but also had honor student girl getting pretend upset at something leading to the other girl profusely apologizing and the reveal is that she just was messing with her.

joined Aug 17, 2021

Multiple discoveries hypothesis: witch boy by Molly ostertag

joined Aug 17, 2021

I use the index and middle because I’ve got better coordination with those and they get less tired

joined Aug 17, 2021

I am loving Nanao and how she has no idea what is going on. I wonder if she will find out about the service and try it out. I am also assuming she will do a joint deal with Asumi one day.

She's going to assume that Asumi is the prostitute, and try to hire her after several pages of working up the courage to ask. Just you watch.

Either you pre-read the Japanese or you’ve got serious prediction skills. Can’t exactly abuse them in Vegas or anything unless there’s a weirdly specifc new lotto game about yuri manga

Iamlovingthat4u
Mark discussion 06 Aug 21:43
joined Aug 17, 2021

So many great vanilla futa works that haven't made it over to the site for no apparent reason, but when we finally do get another one, it's omegaverse. Yay...

Vanilla yuri futa is the food of the gods