I'm so conflicted about this.
On one hand, Botan is cute, she likes Keitarou for who he is, male, nice guy, honest. And she's so damn adorable! Her facial expressions and her spunky approach to life is so funny.
On the other hand, Aoi has had pain, heartbreak, father issues. And yet, despite that, she can be cute, funny, honest to a fault. Her attempts at moving forward, and trying to get over emotional trauma, make her someone I root for.
So I'm conflicted as to who should be with the main character.
I wish I could cast a spell and make two separate Itsuki sans. One female for Aoi, and a male one for Botan....