Forum › Whispering You a Love Song discussion

joined May 9, 2017

I wouldn't call the serie convoluted, but I'll admit that I lost track of the characters/plot long ago. I'm just reading it casually, but most of the time I'm just "who is this character again?". I should probably just reread it, but at the same time, I don't like the manga enough to go through all volumes again. So I'll continue to be confused every month, probably until it ends :p

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

I'll probably be pointed with knives for saying this but I lost the plot since the festival. Could barely keep up with the 2nd couple. This is not what I signed up for and the story has become too convoluted and tried to be more deep than it has to. Also I don't like when everyone in the story is gay, it's not realistic(not that it has to be but I enjoyed HDWR more bc of it). Like I came for himari and yori and Yori barely shows up, they didn't touch on the intimacy thing. And instead we got some lindof obssesive incestish plot idk man wtf

The series isn't convoluted in my opinion, it's a story about two bands and their relationships. I also don't think it's being "too deep", this chapter is about two young women exploring their grief around someone they lost...that happens in life.

As someone that loves HDWR this series isn't HDWR and it isn't trying to be, and not every story has to be "realistic". Plus "realistic" and the definitions of what counts depends person to person. This is a fictional comic story about two lesbian bands, that's really not enough to break my suspension of disbelief.

Also we had a character that had to sort out how she felt about her sister and move past that. Which in my opinion really is not a big deal and yet people keep acting like this series went full incest porn lol

Yes, plus the series moved beyond being about just Yori and Himari (if it ever was just about them) years ago. It's long been an ensemble story since about 2020. At this point it's not on the author anymore; they've just got to stop reading. Otherwise it's been going strong the whole run through. I'm also unsure what's convoluted about this story. It's not doing anything complicated, just very character focused.

Yup, I feel like the series is still going strong and I'm engaged to see what blossoms between characters as the author explores their relationships. As we've discussed before I don't understand a lot of the reactions on these chapters, it really sounds like all the people that either hate this series or don't care about it anymore would be better off not continuing to read it...and yet almost every chapter we have people saying how they don't care about the plot, the characters, and they're just confused by everything happening yet they refuse to drop the series. Ah well regardless I still love the series and I'm really enjoying these chapters lol

joined Jul 15, 2020

I'll probably be pointed with knives for saying this but I lost the plot since the festival. Could barely keep up with the 2nd couple. This is not what I signed up for and the story has become too convoluted and tried to be more deep than it has to. Also I don't like when everyone in the story is gay, it's not realistic(not that it has to be but I enjoyed HDWR more bc of it). Like I came for himari and yori and Yori barely shows up, they didn't touch on the intimacy thing. And instead we got some lindof obssesive incestish plot idk man wtf

The series isn't convoluted in my opinion, it's a story about two bands and their relationships. I also don't think it's being "too deep", this chapter is about two young women exploring their grief around someone they lost...that happens in life.

As someone that loves HDWR this series isn't HDWR and it isn't trying to be, and not every story has to be "realistic". Plus "realistic" and the definitions of what counts depends person to person. This is a fictional comic story about two lesbian bands, that's really not enough to break my suspension of disbelief.

Also we had a character that had to sort out how she felt about her sister and move past that. Which in my opinion really is not a big deal and yet people keep acting like this series went full incest porn lol

This is why I said kinda and not fully incest. Also, If I remember the festival chapter was like chapter 25ish. Its been long long since Yori has had any real relevancy or the focus was HimaYori. And thats not what I signed up for, and initially it seems in the first volumes that the story was more about the realization of such feelings. I'm not saying its hard to understand, I'm saying it swayed off the initial volume plot and it bored me. I'd prefer of it was more fluff and it's just my opinion, I love a good drama like HDWR or Her Shim cheong, but I also love fluff dumb things like Our Yuri started with me getting rejected in a dream and I think the story should have stayed like the second but what do I know I stopped paying attention since chapter 30ish and just want the focus to go back to the 'main" couple but seems its too much to ask

last edited at Nov 4, 2026 3:50PM

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

I'll probably be pointed with knives for saying this but I lost the plot since the festival. Could barely keep up with the 2nd couple. This is not what I signed up for and the story has become too convoluted and tried to be more deep than it has to. Also I don't like when everyone in the story is gay, it's not realistic(not that it has to be but I enjoyed HDWR more bc of it). Like I came for himari and yori and Yori barely shows up, they didn't touch on the intimacy thing. And instead we got some lindof obssesive incestish plot idk man wtf

The series isn't convoluted in my opinion, it's a story about two bands and their relationships. I also don't think it's being "too deep", this chapter is about two young women exploring their grief around someone they lost...that happens in life.

As someone that loves HDWR this series isn't HDWR and it isn't trying to be, and not every story has to be "realistic". Plus "realistic" and the definitions of what counts depends person to person. This is a fictional comic story about two lesbian bands, that's really not enough to break my suspension of disbelief.

Also we had a character that had to sort out how she felt about her sister and move past that. Which in my opinion really is not a big deal and yet people keep acting like this series went full incest porn lol

This is why I said kinda and not fully incest. Also, If I remember the festival chapter was like chapter 25ish. Its been long long since Yori has had any real relevancy or the focus was HimaYori. And thats not what I signed up for, and initially it seems in the first volumes that the story was more about the realization of such feelings. I'm not saying its hard to understand, I'm saying it swayed off the initial volume plot and it bored me. I'd prefer of it was more fluff and it's just my opinion, I love a good drama like HDWR or Her Shim cheong, but I also love fluff dumb things like Our Yuri started with me getting rejected in a dream and I think the story should have stayed like the second but what do I know I stopped paying attention since chapter 30ish and just want the focus to go back to the 'main" couple but seems its too much to ask

For me I’m going along with the journey the author wants to take us on. If you think that’s boring and you haven’t enjoyed the last 36 chapters maybe drop it here, put that time and energy into something you enjoy more. As I’ve said I’m still really enjoying this journey myself and I’m looking forward to seeing it all unfold.

543633_50
joined Sep 10, 2022

I'll probably be pointed with knives for saying this but I lost the plot since the festival. Could barely keep up with the 2nd couple. This is not what I signed up for and the story has become too convoluted and tried to be more deep than it has to. Also I don't like when everyone in the story is gay, it's not realistic(not that it has to be but I enjoyed HDWR more bc of it). Like I came for himari and yori and Yori barely shows up, they didn't touch on the intimacy thing. And instead we got some lindof obssesive incestish plot idk man wtf

The series isn't convoluted in my opinion, it's a story about two bands and their relationships. I also don't think it's being "too deep", this chapter is about two young women exploring their grief around someone they lost...that happens in life.

As someone that loves HDWR this series isn't HDWR and it isn't trying to be, and not every story has to be "realistic". Plus "realistic" and the definitions of what counts depends person to person. This is a fictional comic story about two lesbian bands, that's really not enough to break my suspension of disbelief.

Also we had a character that had to sort out how she felt about her sister and move past that. Which in my opinion really is not a big deal and yet people keep acting like this series went full incest porn lol

This is why I said kinda and not fully incest. Also, If I remember the festival chapter was like chapter 25ish. Its been long long since Yori has had any real relevancy or the focus was HimaYori. And thats not what I signed up for, and initially it seems in the first volumes that the story was more about the realization of such feelings. I'm not saying its hard to understand, I'm saying it swayed off the initial volume plot and it bored me. I'd prefer of it was more fluff and it's just my opinion, I love a good drama like HDWR or Her Shim cheong, but I also love fluff dumb things like Our Yuri started with me getting rejected in a dream and I think the story should have stayed like the second but what do I know I stopped paying attention since chapter 30ish and just want the focus to go back to the 'main" couple but seems its too much to ask

If you haven't been paying attention since chapter 30, how are we describing the series as convoluted then? Otherwise, I agree with Fluffy. As I mentioned earlier in been literally years since what you're describing. The series is an ensemble one. Yori and Himari are not the only main characters; Shiho and Aki's arc was massively popular and even that is years old by this point. It hasn't turned into something new recently, and it's not going to change from what it's been for nearly the entire run. Aki/Shiho and Yori/Himari are the most popular but the beauty of this series is it develops new pairs they typically are well received.

last edited at Nov 4, 2026 6:05PM

joined Jul 15, 2020

I'll probably be pointed with knives for saying this but I lost the plot since the festival. Could barely keep up with the 2nd couple. This is not what I signed up for and the story has become too convoluted and tried to be more deep than it has to. Also I don't like when everyone in the story is gay, it's not realistic(not that it has to be but I enjoyed HDWR more bc of it). Like I came for himari and yori and Yori barely shows up, they didn't touch on the intimacy thing. And instead we got some lindof obssesive incestish plot idk man wtf

The series isn't convoluted in my opinion, it's a story about two bands and their relationships. I also don't think it's being "too deep", this chapter is about two young women exploring their grief around someone they lost...that happens in life.

As someone that loves HDWR this series isn't HDWR and it isn't trying to be, and not every story has to be "realistic". Plus "realistic" and the definitions of what counts depends person to person. This is a fictional comic story about two lesbian bands, that's really not enough to break my suspension of disbelief.

Also we had a character that had to sort out how she felt about her sister and move past that. Which in my opinion really is not a big deal and yet people keep acting like this series went full incest porn lol

This is why I said kinda and not fully incest. Also, If I remember the festival chapter was like chapter 25ish. Its been long long since Yori has had any real relevancy or the focus was HimaYori. And thats not what I signed up for, and initially it seems in the first volumes that the story was more about the realization of such feelings. I'm not saying its hard to understand, I'm saying it swayed off the initial volume plot and it bored me. I'd prefer of it was more fluff and it's just my opinion, I love a good drama like HDWR or Her Shim cheong, but I also love fluff dumb things like Our Yuri started with me getting rejected in a dream and I think the story should have stayed like the second but what do I know I stopped paying attention since chapter 30ish and just want the focus to go back to the 'main" couple but seems its too much to ask

If you haven't been paying attention since chapter 30, how are we describing the series as convoluted then? Otherwise, I agree with Fluffy. As I mentioned earlier in been literally years since what you're describing. The series is an ensemble one. Yori and Himari are not the only main characters; Shiho and Aki's arc was massively popular and even that is years old by this point. It hasn't turned into something new recently, and it's not going to change from what it's been for nearly the entire run. Aki/Shiho and Yori/Himari are the most popular but the beauty of this series is it develops new pairs they typically are well received.

I'm not a native english speaker and thats the word that came to mind, I'm not saying yall can't like it. I was just respectfully sharing my opinion and I did get some discourse going as expected lol. I was just expressing a thought, habe a good day yall

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

I'm not a native english speaker and thats the word that came to mind, I'm not saying yall can't like it. I was just respectfully sharing my opinion and I did get some discourse going as expected lol. I was just expressing a thought, habe a good day yall

You presented your views and we discussed them, which is pretty normal stuff for a forum, and I think we were also respectful in responding to the discussion you presented. Anyhow yes, have a nice day.

46-75
joined Jun 25, 2019

I still think it should have ended after Aki/Shiho getting together. Honestly it feel like Takeshima just get a couple together to then jump into the next one. I keep reading but honestly, it's lost its flavor a while ago. It's not bad, just too long.

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

I still think it should have ended after Aki/Shiho getting together. Honestly it feel like Takeshima just get a couple together to then jump into the next one. I keep reading but honestly, it's lost its flavor a while ago. It's not bad, just too long.

As I’ve been saying I think people should genuinely consider dropping the series when they feel this way. There might be only a couple of us that don’t think the series has “lost its flavor”, but those that are still enjoying the series are glad it’s still going because we want to see the rest of the couples fleshed out.

In%20your%20butt
joined Jun 21, 2021

it's just the forever curse of yuri series. Either they end vol 3 and "should've gone on much longer" or they actually make it past that hurdle, get a decent run in and then it's always "this should've ended way sooner" or "it's all boring now".

General opinion always seems to gravitate to one of these extremes somehow xd

last edited at Nov 4, 2026 9:05PM

543633_50
joined Sep 10, 2022

I still think it should have ended after Aki/Shiho getting together. Honestly it feel like Takeshima just get a couple together to then jump into the next one. I keep reading but honestly, it's lost its flavor a while ago. It's not bad, just too long.

As I’ve been saying I think people should genuinely consider dropping the series when they feel this way. There might be only a couple of us that don’t think the series has “lost its flavor”, but those that are still enjoying the series are glad it’s still going because we want to see the rest of the couples fleshed out.

Definitely not just a couple of us but yeah. Internet is nearly always negative but not representative. Series is still doing well. I always remind myself that most people don't comment and the ones that do, skew.

last edited at Nov 4, 2026 10:33PM

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

I still think it should have ended after Aki/Shiho getting together. Honestly it feel like Takeshima just get a couple together to then jump into the next one. I keep reading but honestly, it's lost its flavor a while ago. It's not bad, just too long.

As I’ve been saying I think people should genuinely consider dropping the series when they feel this way. There might be only a couple of us that don’t think the series has “lost its flavor”, but those that are still enjoying the series are glad it’s still going because we want to see the rest of the couples fleshed out.

Definitely not just a couple of us but yeah. Internet is nearly always negative but not representative. Series is still doing well. I always remind myself that most people don't comment and the ones that do, skew.

That's something I tend to forget, thanks for reminding me.

Avatar%20(pride%20version)
joined Oct 22, 2018

I still think it should have ended after Aki/Shiho getting together. Honestly it feel like Takeshima just get a couple together to then jump into the next one. I keep reading but honestly, it's lost its flavor a while ago. It's not bad, just too long.

As I’ve been saying I think people should genuinely consider dropping the series when they feel this way. There might be only a couple of us that don’t think the series has “lost its flavor”, but those that are still enjoying the series are glad it’s still going because we want to see the rest of the couples fleshed out.

Definitely not just a couple of us but yeah. Internet is nearly always negative but not representative. Series is still doing well. I always remind myself that most people don't comment and the ones that do, skew.

That's something I tend to forget, thanks for reminding me.

The silent majority strikes again.

Jokes aside, I'm personally still enjoying the series

46-75
joined Jun 25, 2019

I mean reading the thread, i feel more like the one finding it bland are the minority but that's probably just me. I comment once in a blue moon so my opinion is probably not worth taking.

joined May 8, 2026

it's just the forever curse of yuri series. Either they end vol 3 and "should've gone on much longer" or they actually make it past that hurdle, get a decent run in and then it's always "this should've ended way sooner" or "it's all boring now".

General opinion always seems to gravitate to one of these extremes somehow xd

If not that, then another group of people will be complaining that every character looks the same aka same face syndrome.

Sasakoi really can't please everybody.

62342532_p4_3
joined May 27, 2015

YoriHima crumbs inhales copium

That silly kiss charm move was a callback to (what feels like a million years ago in real life) Hima doing the same thing to Yori for good luck before the Sunny Spot concert.

Anyways, putting Kyou on the cover of the special edition, and only the special edition, is a crazy move.

last edited at Nov 20, 2026 11:33PM

joined May 8, 2026

I got so engrossed with the Hajimomokyou arc that I forgot that Yori exists lol

To reply you must either login or sign up.