Clueless1 posted:

Only “Happy End” surpasses the betrayal of readers’s expectations. May the Yuri Gods strike down the author! (Just kidding, I just won’t read any of author’s other stuff)

Hey, this should round out this thread section. Let’s put a final nail in this coffin and stop making comments on this dead series.

Thread was dead for 2 years, so if anything you just brought it back to live. If you just wanted to rant about ending, go ahead, but then don't write pretentious stuff like that.

EDIT/ My bad I looked at account's date instead of post's. Still my point stands.

last edited at Feb 7, 2019 5:14PM

CozyCreature12 posted:

(I see, this author is an hentai pig author) well, what can I expect from someone like that?

It's so funny everytime someone uses argument "it is hentai artist". A lot of mangakas started as a hentai artists. The same way a lot of seiyuus started by voicing in eroge. Hell, even Morinaga started as hentai artist. So saying "I found out they wrote hentai before, no wonder they're terrible" means jack shit. There will be always a grace period when artist tries to find their own style outside of porn and write actual stories. The important part is whatever they get better or are stuck writing less porny porn. It can be rough around the edges, but I think Uran is doing good job so far.

CozyCreature12 posted:

this feels more like an hentai than a Yuri

Implying yuri hentai doesn't exist?

last edited at Feb 7, 2019 6:23AM

DeltaCZ posted:

im really hoping for this manga to go to intimate romance territory like sakura trick, i doubt it will though but it's fine since it's still enjoyable and cute anyway.

Since when girls in Sakura Trick learned what romance even is, to have intimate one?

Embersember posted:

Why is the moderator being so rude, the guy was just hesitant.

True

Yep, shouting someone down for stating their opinion is a bit overkill.

I actually read Nezchan's comment first then read Breizh's comment. I'm surprised at the reaction.
Nezchan, your comment was very unnecessary and frankly rude/mean.

It came across as somewhat abrupt, yes, but I'm sure Nezchan is just worried.

I wonder if there are different interpretations of what Breizh is saying? I first read it as them saying they thought the illness was made up/hypochondria/whatever, which would be out of line for a med student to say of someone they had not examined. But it sounds like other people got the impression that they were just concerned about the mix of medications which may not be helpful together or for that purpose, which is fair.

I understood "there are some strange things in this that are bothering me with this." as simply meaning, they think some meds etc. are weird/unnecessary, so I wanted them to elaborated on that.

Next bot

aranicar posted:

But why did she not have a belly button? Engineers forgot to give her one lol?

Idk if it is common, but in Heart-Pounding Excitement at Mononoke Girls' Academy the plot point was that youkai are not born like humans, so they don't have a belly button, so that is a easy way to tell whatever someone is human or not. Sure, scientist could just give her belly button to make her as human as possible, but I think it is referring that, since as a robot, she didn't have to be born from mother.

Blastaar posted:

And who the fuck puts the bed in the kitchen anyway?

IKR? Table is more than enough for fucking.

S31 posted:

It’s like poetry.

Thanks for that PTSD flashback.

syfalkda posted:

Insane Amount of Misunderstandings
. . . How much use would such a tag even get, hypothetically? Like, it's not every decade we get a character that's completely unable to understand the concept of other possible explanations for what is going on, and mentally crafts bizarre narratives for everything.

glances at Futari Monologue, then shrugs slightly as it's the only good example she can think of on short notice, and remains silent

Futari Monologue is what gave idea to Lots of Misunderstandings tag in the first place, so go figure.

I'm all for yuri, but from time to time, reading a actual good story about friendship between girls is nice too. I'm really enjoying this one.

schuyguy posted:

Edit: just checked, and I was right. In Iromeki Girls, Saki's little sister makes a video of Saki masturbating and tricks Saki into giving it to Aki.

That is what siblings are for.

gwennie-chan posted:

Honestly I am kind disappointed the author, who used the correct terms in the manga, wouldn't for the title. However, I acknowledge that saying "Kanojo wa Otokonoko" is smashing together both feminine and masculine words together, which is kinda bigendery, but overall yeah could've been worded better.

Yea, I think that is what they were going for, the mix of both genders.

yuripie posted:

Anyhow, what put me off the most is, why would Miki liked Makoto? I see little reasons for Miki to like Makoto unless Miki herself is a lesbian/bisexual and comfortable with a transgender. If she is comfortable with a transgender, it is illogical for her to show that much ignorance, like me, on the matter.

Makoto is not transsexual. Miki either knew him before he started to wear feminine cloths or she never really tried to understand him. It seems she simply see him as a guy, treat like one and just want to date him because she likes him (either because of his looks, personality or both). The point is, she don't care about his identity and all that stuff, she just want to fuck him and is jealous he has girlfriend, so she bullies them. Which honestly baffles me how she think it is a good idea and will make her love interest actually consider her as a potential partner.

And that just proved my point again. If transgender is a umbrella term for everyone not cis and doesn't simply mean transsexual, then they should say Makoto is not transsexual, not transgender. Because he is transgender, since he identify with both genders. But in manga they specifically use term transgender with the meaning of transsexual. So does Japan use different definition? Before you could just say trans or trans person and everyone knew exactly what it meant. Now it can mean everything and you have no idea which version the person is using, cos some people use trans and transgender to only mean transsexual. It used to be pretty simple, but now it got overcomplicated and the term become meaningless.

And that reminds me, now we don't actually have tag to tag works that have specifically transsexuals in them, because it was changed to transgender because it was a term transsexual preferred and felt more natural, but now that it is a umbrella term, we actually need a transsexual and transgender tags to differentiate the two.

last edited at Jan 30, 2019 6:45PM

shadesan posted:

Am curious what the title translates to in English? Google translate gives one thing, and mangadex another...

"My Girlfriend is a Trap."

Sorry I had too xP
Depending on kanji used "Otokonoko" can be translated as a "trap", but in this case it is the standard meaning of a "boy", so "My Girlfriend is a Boy".

That is what you get for guessing the meaning, without actually making sure which kanji they used.

I have no clue what you guys have problem with. I find it amazing. We need more stuff like that.

On the topic of "professional vs fan translations". We got first volume released here and they made a blatant mistranslation, which changes context quite a bit. And of course there is no option to release fixed version. The advantage of digital translations you can always update.

Breizh posted:

I don’t want to be disrespectful but as a med student, there are some strange things in this that are bothering me with this.

Like?

Not enough hate-fucking though.

Probably nothing, since it's not her business.

GeneralJ posted:

Would you want to fool around with your gf if you swapped bodies? Seems like it'd be very weird.

Nero is already weird, I know because I'm basically her and this always scares me.

You share her definition what "dressing like a man" means?

lord-of-roses posted:

Just curious: What kind of experience would make a girl afraid of other girls?

I assume she was teased/bullied because of her shabby look.

https://dynasty-scans.com/chapters/a_girl_falls_in_love_with_a_boy_ch03#2

I support Lots of Misunderstandings tag

Maybe Fluttering Feelings? There is not much details though.

Maybe Clones as umbrella term? Something that would suggest that 1 or more characters are multiplied.

EDIT/ Damn ninja'd

last edited at Jan 25, 2019 8:48PM

Multiple Persona sounds more like it is about multiple personalities, though not sure how else to name it.

last edited at Jan 25, 2019 8:40PM