Forum › Mine discussion

Pov_youre_a_triple_mugger
joined Feb 19, 2016

I'm torn. Do we put the Yandere tag, or the I *WILL* end you if you as much as look at her sideways tag?
Or do we put no tag for spoiler reasons?
It is a very short one-shot anyways, I feel no need to warn against spoilers that you will have in two or three clicks, but some people might think otherwise...

I don't know if needs either, but what's the point of a tagging system intended to help people filter through undesired content if it isn't going to be used because it might spoil some shock factor or some other dumb reason? I've never really understood why people try to argue this.
Like, yeah, it's only a six page one shot, and the subject matter isn't that egregious (personally, at least), but it's the principle of the thing. Things should be tagged properly, or they shouldn't be tagged at all.

Chimera
joined Aug 2, 2023

I'm torn. Do we put the Yandere tag, or the I *WILL* end you if you as much as look at her sideways tag?
Or do we put no tag for spoiler reasons?
It is a very short one-shot anyways, I feel no need to warn against spoilers that you will have in two or three clicks, but some people might think otherwise...

I don't know if needs either, but what's the point of a tagging system intended to help people filter through undesired content if it isn't going to be used because it might spoil some shock factor or some other dumb reason? I've never really understood why people try to argue this.
Like, yeah, it's only a six page one shot, and the subject matter isn't that egregious (personally, at least), but it's the principle of the thing. Things should be tagged properly, or they shouldn't be tagged at all.

All tag suggestions are reviewed manually and this is barely out for 24 hours. Cut the site staff some slack before assuming inaction as a deliberate stance. Since this has no other tags besides Yuri, it stands to reason the uploader didn't bother and they're still being processed.

On the general topic: i recal some older one-shots where tags were apparently withheld for spoiler reasons, but even those seem to have eventually recieved the tags years later. Objectionable content has never been hidden to knowledge. But I'm also skeptical of supressing information the reader requires to make an informed decission. VNDB for example allows to makr tags as spoilers (DDLC for example), but depending on the backend-implementation of the site this might not be easily feasible, especially since you'd probably need an entire tagging task force to sort the ensuing mess.

Leaping%20cow
joined Sep 27, 2017

Maybe a "Possessive" tag for Soft-Yandere could work...?

Cnwdrjjvmail6tq
joined Jun 30, 2017

I loved it!

joined Sep 3, 2025

Umm… cool

To reply you must either login or sign up.