AY. What does the site think in regards to Tutors and this tag? Generally they're tagged with this tag, although they're technically different things. Would you want tutors being added as a alias to the tag, or would you prefer a separate tag for it. There's a few stories involving tutors specifically, but I don't wanna go making the tag if people would prefer it as part of this. Thoughts pls

To me tutor x student is pretty much same thing as teacher x student as it works in similar way, but since I don't search for those tags, maybe there are some nuance to them I'm not aware off.

I'd leave it covering both, as you say it's a fairly small difference. You've still got an adult teaching a child, although it doesn't have the school trappings. Those might be make-or-break for some, but I think we've got few enough it doesn't matter too much.

I agree with Nezchan and Nevri. At most I think the alias idea would work but I don't think even that's actually necessary.

Generally they're tagged with this tag, although they're technically different things.

Odd; I didn't remember this being the case. The story that came to mind was Fragments of Love, which isn't.

Would you want tutors being added as a alias to the tag, or would you prefer a separate tag for it.

Neither. I think Age gap does the trick.

I'd leave it covering both, as you say it's a fairly small difference. You've still got an adult teaching a child, although it doesn't have the school trappings. Those might be make-or-break for some, but I think we've got few enough it doesn't matter too much.

I think the differences are more substantial than this. On the one hand, the age gap will tend to be smaller: 2-5 years instead ... let's say 5-10. On the hand, the power dynamics are totally different: a teacher occupies a formal position of authority, with a real ability to directly impact the future of their students and to punish them for disobedience, while earning a proper salary in a socially respectable position; a tutor, meanwhile, basically serves at the discretion of the student's family, is vulnerable to lost income and future employment if things go badly, and is probably also still a student.

Not saying the power dynamics aren't there, and there are obviously a range of cases (including some where the tutor will also be a fulltime teacher), but I don't think that grouping it all under "adult teaching a child" is the best approach.

Same concept
I remember having one and my parents and I always called her my teacher. I havent seen her in ages now, but in my head, I still see her as a teacher and tbh she still has that form of authority over me, if I were to think about it.

Besides, Tutor x Pupil/Student whatever is too precise, while Student Teacher pretty much covers it nicely

last edited at May 24, 2016 12:23AM

I'm looking for this manga where the teacher is being hit on a student, who turns out to be the daughter of the girl she had a crush on back in school. Does anyone know what I'm looking for?

I'm looking for this manga where the teacher is being hit on a student, who turns out to be the daughter of the girl she had a crush on back in school. Does anyone know what I'm looking for?

There are two that fit the bill:

The Structural Formula of First Love

Kusanagi-san is Being Tested

last edited at May 5, 2018 1:07PM

OrangePekoe posted:

I'm looking for this manga where the teacher is being hit on a student, who turns out to be the daughter of the girl she had a crush on back in school. Does anyone know what I'm looking for?

Kusanagi-san is Being Tested

Oh that is the one that I remembered and was sure it was it, but I didn't remember title and didn't know how to find it.

Renamed.

Ohh, there’s a tag for this now! Cool! :3