Forum › I Wish Her Love Could Come True discussion

joined Apr 16, 2022

I can't blame anyone for hating this manga or for vocally trashing it, it certainly has issues even beyond the inherently controversial premise. But I also don't think it's right to say that only bad people enjoy it. I personally enjoy this manga because I like messy drama with highly flawed characters, not because I want to fuck lesbians (I don't identify with Ren at all, actually).

joined Nov 5, 2023

I can't blame anyone for hating this manga or for vocally trashing it, it certainly has issues even beyond the inherently controversial premise. But I also don't think it's right to say that only bad people enjoy it. I personally enjoy this manga because I like messy drama with highly flawed characters, not because I want to fuck lesbians (I don't identify with Ren at all, actually).

I like watching story with drama but i'm not really into watching a story where one of the main character is that close to be a rapist

joined Aug 20, 2025

Isn't this Yuri tagged? Why there is BG in this? Lmaoooooo I don't need handsome dick shit in GL or Yuri manga

543633_50
joined Sep 10, 2022

Isn't this Yuri tagged? Why there is BG in this? Lmaoooooo I don't need handsome dick shit in GL or Yuri manga

I wouldn't expect much on the Yuri front from this series.

last edited at Aug 24, 2025 9:33AM

Kirin-kun Uploader
Oip
Rehashed Scans
joined Mar 21, 2021

I'm hesitating between dropping it and resuming it. Though it's a lot of work for something so hated.

The ending isn't that terrible. Yoh rejects the guy and tells him that the one she likes is Misa. Later, she confesses to Misa, who tells her she's always seen her as her best friend and never thought of the same sex as a possible romantic partner, but she promises to consider her seriously. Bonus chapter hints that it may happen in the future, because Misa gets flustered by Yoh's rizz

It doesn't end in het at all.

Probably people think the guy should be sent to the gallows or something, but he's a pretty standard shoujo male character. I guess people lost the tolerance they had in the 2000's.

543633_50
joined Sep 10, 2022

I'm hesitating between dropping it and resuming it. Though it's a lot of work for something so hated.

The ending isn't that terrible. Yoh rejects the guy and tells him that the one she likes is Misa. Later, she confesses to Misa, who tells her she's always seen her as her best friend and never thought of the same sex as a possible romantic partner, but she promises to consider her seriously. Bonus chapter hints that it may happen in the future, because Misa gets flustered by Yoh's rizz

It doesn't end in het at all.

Probably people think the guy should be sent to the gallows or something, but he's a pretty standard shoujo male character. I guess people lost the tolerance they had in the 2000's.

It's that the author wrote this for a girls manga and has been honest about writing interactions with the male character to please the shoujo audience that doesn't want yuri. The ending isn't terrible but the series is "unbalanced" for a yuri manga. Even the author was not expecting yuri audience's to enjoy the series. If I remember right, they also pitched it to a yuri publication and got rejected for some reason related to the characters.

There's a lot of physical closeness and blushing within the series between him and what should be the "girl who likes girls," and I believe the need to tease readers wanting a typical shoujo romance is largely why. Even the "open" ending could be seen as a way to please that shoujo audience--all that for a "maybe," even in the extra chapter. That tone is what I think readers here picked up on and felt off about. I otherwise have no issue with men in series, and I think I've been in other comment threads showing that.

Still, I think you should finish it. I don't like it, but others probably wil,l and it's already almost done, since it's short. I don't want to discourage that. It's just in a weird middle ground to me.

last edited at Aug 24, 2025 11:45AM

joined Apr 16, 2022

I'm hesitating between dropping it and resuming it. Though it's a lot of work for something so hated.

The ending isn't that terrible. Yoh rejects the guy and tells him that the one she likes is Misa. Later, she confesses to Misa, who tells her she's always seen her as her best friend and never thought of the same sex as a possible romantic partner, but she promises to consider her seriously. Bonus chapter hints that it may happen in the future, because Misa gets flustered by Yoh's rizz

It doesn't end in het at all.

Probably people think the guy should be sent to the gallows or something, but he's a pretty standard shoujo male character. I guess people lost the tolerance they had in the 2000's.

Yuri fandom is a lot less forgiving of the sexually aggressive shoujo ML archetype, even in a female character (see Oduka Mai) but especially in a male character. Generally I think that's a good thing because that archetype is representative of patriarchal attitudes (and frankly is one reason I'm very picky about which shoujo I read).

I still generally enjoy this manga because every character is severely flawed, even if the guy is the most flawed. The melodrama entertains me so I selfishly want you to continue. But I also fully understand why you might lack motivation to translate a manga that gets so hated upon with every new chapter lol. (At least it gets some sort of reaction and isn't just ignored?)

To reply you must either login or sign up.